In the first two posts concerning the Deepwater Horizon blowout I tried to establish that BP willingly cut corners to rush the project to market and that they were aided in this by a complacent regulatory regime who let the oil company get away with this. The regulators did not regulate. In the second post we looked at the impact on the region of this spill and the high probability that when this is done the region will live with serious ecological and environmental damage for a long time to come. This third post will focus in particular on the Obama administration's handling of this and more generally on the power of the financial/industrial elites to control the government that is supposed to control them.
The best place to start a discussion of the Obama administration's response to this crisis should begin with the man himself, Barack Obama. Many Americans, and not just those in the Gulf, are very upset at what they see as a lackluster response to the unfolding crisis. For the first couple of weeks it seemed Obama was nowhere to be seen, hiding behind the excuse that this is BP's problem and they will find a way to clean it up. Of course it was Barack himself who shortly before the blowout reversed his position on off shore drilling and suddenly announced his support to end the moratorium on off shore drilling and open up more of the Gulf and Florida and the Atlantic coast to new drilling. He also pledged his support for new areas in Alaska to explore. Of course in the campaign against John McCain he was opposed to ending the moratorium on off shore drilling and criticized McCain for his support of it. Like all things Obama, there is the Obama of the "speech" and the decisions he actually implements. They are not often the same thing. I was onto Obama early on. I never bought the mantra that he was a progressive or a new type of politician. I looked at his voting record and compared it to Hillary and found little difference between the two. Many progressives and liberals were so captivated at the words he used in his speeches that they never bothered to actually look at his voting record or the choices he has made. Whether it was his support for Joe Lieberman against Ned Lamont in the Connecticut primary or his support for the 2005 Energy Bill that was strongly supported by Dick Cheney, that gave a slew of tax cuts and incentives to the oil companies, among many other things it seems that the speeches of Barack and the actual decisions he makes are two very different things. It seems that Obama lives in the world of the fuzzy middle and the eternal compromise. Moderation in all things and never ever stand for something, no matter how politically unpopular it is. He reacts to pressure and it seems not to matter if it is from the left or the right. He tries to avoid conflict at all costs which would explain his disastrous attempt at a bi-partisan strategy at the start of his administration. This was a strategic error of major proportions and it is time and momentum he will never get back. There was always a kind of smugness and condescension about the typical Obama supporter that annoyed me. There was this feeling among a certain percentage of his supporters that they and he were something special and that if you didn't buy into it you were somehow un-hip. To this day, even after all the flip flops on financial regulation, deepwater drilling, the escalation of Afghanistan, Bagram being the new Guantanamo and on and on many of his supporters continue to refuse to call him out and get real pissy with progressives who do criticize him, like myself. This is unfortunate because as I said earlier Obama seems to have no real convictions that he will fight to the end on. He only responds to pressure and if the "left" does not want to bring pressure on him he will ignore their concerns. He is a corporate Democrat through and through and little different in this regard than the man that Obama supporters loved to trash in the primary, Bill Clinton. Nowhere is this more apparent then in the people that he has chosen to surround himself with. He is a very passive president who reacts to events and does not want to step out in front and take charge. Nowhere is this trait more on display than in the events that are happening in the Gulf of Mexico.
Perhaps nothing illustrates the passivity of the Obama administration to this crisis better than the amount of oil that is leaking out of the riser pipe. For about a month BP has insisted that it is 5.000 barrels a day. That has been challenged by many independent observers. The video that BP has of the leak was withheld from the press and Congress with the consent of the administration who went along with the story. Thanks to the efforts of Barbara Boxer (D-Ca) and especially Bill Nelson (D-Fl) these were finally released. They made it obvious that what was leaking out was far more than the 5,000 barrels BP was claiming. BP themselves later admitted as much as I wrote and linked about in my previous post. They basically lied for a whole month and the Obama administration did little to force their hand. BP claims that there was no way to get an accurate handle on how much was leaking. This was immediately contradicted by many in the scientific community. No doubt the Obama administration, very aware of the potential political fallout of this a la Katrina, was hoping that BP would get a handle on this quickly and did not want to call attention to something that had political implications. I assume but do not know for sure that BP thought they would bring this thing under control. The dispersants that BP were using were doing a good job of keeping oil off the surface and out of sight was out of mind, at least that is how it appeared to look to the Obama administration. After a time it was becoming obvious to more people that this leak was far worse than was being claimed and still it took a couple of Democratic senators to put the pressure on BP to release the video, not the White House. This is an appalling lack of leadership. Had we known how much was leaking out at the start we would be in a better position to judge just where that oil is going to. As it stands now we are in the dark. Other than the public relations problem there appears to be another reason that BP hoarded the video and refused any independent readings of the oil leak. According to McClatchy news from a May 20th article BP's lowball count and the Obama administration's acceptance of those figures and refusal to send an independent verification team to find out for themselves could save BP a boatload of money in damages when the financial impact of this thing is resolved. BP has claimed that an independent verification would interfere with the cleanup but this is contradicted by their own internal memo. I quote from the article, " BP and the Obama administration have said they don't want to take the measurements for fear of interfering with efforts to stop the leaks. That decision, however, runs counter to BP's own regional plan for dealing with offshore leaks. "In the event of a significant release of oil," the 583-page plan says on Page 2, "an accurate estimation of the spill's total volume . . . is essential in providing preliminary data to plan and initiate cleanup operations."Legal experts said that not having a credible official estimate of the leak's size provides another benefit for BP: The amount of oil spilled is certain to be key evidence in the court battles that are likely to result from the disaster. The size of the Exxon Valdez spill in Alaska, for example, was a significant factor that the jury considered when it assessed damages against Exxon."If they put off measuring, then it's going to be a battle of dueling experts after the fact trying to extrapolate how much spilled after it has all sunk or has been carried away," said Lloyd Benton Miller, one of the lead plaintiffs' lawyers in the Exxon Valdez spill litigation. "The ability to measure how much oil was released will be impossible." There you have it. I have no doubt that the reason BP has stonewalled this thing is to cover their own ass, public be damned. I have a hard time believing that the government was totally unaware of the liability issue here. If this was the Bush administration we would naturally assume collusion and we would no doubt be correct. I am not suggesting that Barack Obama himself was covering for BP, however it is a strong possibility that others in his administration are. Either way, he is in charge and history will judge him.
The choice of Ken Salzar as Secretary of the Interior says a lot about Barack Obama himself. A centrist Democrat, whose environmental record is mixed, he has throughout his career shown himself to be friendly to big industry and not the kind of person you would expect to stand up to the abuse of power. Much like many other Obama appointments like Tim Geithner, Robert Gates, Hillary Clinton, Rahm Emmanuel and Larry Summers, Barack will never choose a progressive but will always go for the centrist, who can be counted on to maintain the status quo. What did Salazar bring to the table? On the plus side he was opposed to the rush to develop oil shale by the Bush administration arguing that there needed to be a lot more studies on the impact to the environment.On the minus side he was opposed to increasing Cafe standards, voted to continue tax breaks for major oil companies, voted on a bill to end protections that would limit off shore drilling, supported Joe Lieberman against Ned Lamont and supported the horrific Bush appointee of the Interior, Gale Norton. In other words, very typical of the typical Obama appointee. Always the mushy middle. Contrast that with the Republicans who never miss a beat to force their far right appointees on the American public. These appointees are usually bad news but still in a weird sort of way you have to kind of admire a party that acts on their convictions, no matter how bad they are. That is a problem you do not have to worry about with today's Democratic party.
The question of moratoriums on new drilling permits and the granting of environmental wavers provides a view of the fuzzy way that Obama governs as well as giving evidence of his ability to say one thing in a speech and do something else in a policy act. An article in the New York Times from May 23rd tells the story. After giving a tough speech on May 14th in which Obama promised a moratorium on permits for new offshore drilling and an end to the granting of a controversial type of environmental waiver, according to the Times this tough talk is not being followed. I quote from the article, " In the days since President Obama announced a moratorium on permits for drilling new offshore oil wells and a halt to a controversial type of environmental waiver that was given to the Deepwater Horizon rig, at least seven new permits for various types of drilling and five environmental waivers have been granted, according to records. The records also indicate that since the April 20 explosion on the rig, federal regulators have granted at least 19 environmental waivers for gulf drilling projects and at least 17 drilling permits, most of which were for types of work like that on the Deepwater Horizon shortly before it exploded, pouring a ceaseless current of oil into the Gulf of Mexico. Asked about the permits and waivers, officials at the Department of the Interior and the Minerals Management Service, which regulates drilling, pointed to public statements by Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, reiterating that the agency had no intention of stopping all new oil and gas production in the gulf." Say what? Later on we find out what was really going on. I quote, "Department of the Interior officials said in a statement that the moratorium was meant only to halt permits for the drilling of new wells. It was not meant to stop permits for new work on existing drilling projects like the Deepwater Horizon." Ah! I get it. Note that these waivers and permits have been for wells that in many cases are in areas as deep or deeper than the well that blew up. The money quote is here, " However, these waivers have been especially troublesome to environmentalists because they were granted through a special legal provision that is supposed to be limited to projects that present minimal or no risk to the environment. At least six of the drilling projects that have been given waivers in the past four weeks are for waters that are deeper — and therefore more difficult and dangerous — than where Deepwater Horizon was operating. While that rig, which was drilling at a depth just shy of 5,000 feet, was classified as a deep-water operation, many of the wells in the six projects are classified as “ultra” deep water, including four new wells at over 9,100 feet." This is incredible to me. I expect this kind of thing with a Republican administration, but naive as I know I am, I expect a little more backbone from a Democratic administration. Read the whole article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/24/us/24moratorium.html?pagewanted=1&hp . It is an eye opener.
The federal regulatory agency responsible for regulating off shore drilling is the Minerals Management Service (MMS). It has taken a lot of heat as a result of their role in this fiasco. A couple of articles that appeared in the New York Times and the Washington Post shine a light on what went wrong at the agency and highlights how our regulatory agencies have become captive to the industries they are supposed to regulate. These two articles go into detail about the various misdeeds of the agency including unethical behavior, shoddy work and an inability to divorce themselves from the industry's interests. For instance we hear stories about employees who accepted tickets to sporting events, meals and gifts from at least one major oil company. Stories about how federal regulators let industry officials file their own inspection reports in pencil and then turned them over to the regulators who then traced it over in ink and submitted the final report to the agency. We hear of cases of drug use and instances where regulators who were conducting inspections on a drilling platform are at the same time negotiating to get a job with that company. These practices were especially common in the Lake Charles, Louisiana office. MMS officials are said to receive cash bonuses in the thousands of dollars for meeting federal deadlines for leasing oil and gas offshore exploration! This quote from the Post article pretty much sums up what is wrong with our regulatory regime. I quote, "MMS actions are shaped in part by a 2005 regulation it adopted that assumes oil and gas companies can best evaluate the environmental effects of their operations. The rule governing which information the MMS should receive and review before signing off on drilling plans states: "The lessee or operator is in the best position to determine the environmental effects of its proposed activity based on whether the operation is routine or non-routine." MMS said in a May 2000 draft environmental analysis of deep-water drilling in the Gulf of Mexico that "the oil industry's experience base in deep-water well control is limited" and that a massive spill "could easily turn out to be a potential showstopper for the [Outer Continental Shelf] program if the industry and MMS do not come together as a whole to prevent such an incident." But when the MMS finalized the document that month, it jettisoned those two statements and concluded that there was no need to prepare an environmental impact analysis for deep-water drilling: "Most deep-water operations and activities are substantially the same as those associated with conventional operations and activities on the continental shelf." While this post has concentrated on the Obama administration's response to the crisis it is important to realize that most of the abuses mentioned in the inspector general report occurred under George W. Bush. While the tension between the public interest and private profit is always present the degree of corruption was taken to a new high under George W. Bush. The Republican strategy, that goes back to the Reagan years, has been to discredit government in the eyes of the general public. To do that you have to trash it. They have run up massive deficits based on a faulty economic program called Reaganomics, not just under Reagan but again under George W. Bush and then blamed this on government spending on social programs such as social security and Medicare which must be eliminated to bring about "fiscal responsibility". At the same time they have made sure that the regulatory positions that by statute have to be filled have been held by people who are tools of the financial interests they are supposed to regulate. When the inevitable crisis occurs (economic meltdown of 2008 or the Deepwater blowout) they can claim that regulation did not prevent it, hence it is unnecessary. Many gullible teabaggers, whose economic interests are not helped by the Republican agenda, have bought into this. While these abuses have been particularly egregious under George W. Bush, they have also occurred under Democratic administrations as well. The real problem here is that the financial/industrial elites have become so powerful that they have taken control of the government and in the pursuit of profit they will do whatever they want regardless of the public interest. When the inevitable disaster happens we the people can be expected to pick up the tab. If the teabaggers would take the wax out of their ears and listen for once they might understand that the problem is not "government". Rather the problem is that these elites have usurped the government and used the American people as roadkill on the road to profit. The problem is not capitalism per se, but this type of capitalism, the kind that is too big too fail and has the resources to buy off the government that is supposed to regulate it in the public interest.
I started this post on the 25th of May and I am finishing it on the 28th of May. As of today Barack Obama has just given a press conference defending his administration's handlking of this crisis. BP, after saying the top kill procedure seemed to be working, has now suspended it for a while. We are not sure what is going on. At this point why would anyone believe anything BP says?I hope the top kill works for if does not it will be a long deadly summer. Meanwhile BP is still using the dispersent Corexit into the water despite the Obama administration ordering them not to. The Obama administration did not cause this spill. We are drilling in these deepwater wells because we are rapidly running out of areas where the cheap easy to get oil is and the rest is in unstable areas like Iraq. Perhaps the only good thing to come out of this is perhaps the American people will get a wake-up call and realize that for many reasons we need to make a serious transition to an economy not based on foosil fuels. It will be costly and it will pinch people in the pocketbook. Right now the oil companies, like BP, have fought this transition tooth and nail because they are making boatloads of money right now ($45 million in profit a day by BP!). It will take a lot of courage to stand up to them and sell this thing to the American people. It is called leadership. It is chance for Barack Obama to overcome the perception of someone who is not in control of events and merely reacts to them. It requires a different approach than we have seen so far.
Read the articles concerning the Minerals Management Services here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/25/us/25mms.html and here http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/25/AR2010052502817.html. Barack Obama support for off shore drilling here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/mar/31/barack-obama-offshore-drilling. The McClatchy article on oil spill estimates is here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2010/05/20/94581/low-estimate-of-oil-spills-size.html
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment