Friday, January 15, 2010
Short thoughts for a Friday morning
1) The response time on my computer this morning is awful so I will not be able to say everything that I would like but I want to briefly discuss the recent attack on an Iranian nuclear physicist in Tehran that resulted in the death of Masoud Ali Mohammadi. According to the article in the New York Times and I quote, " A remote-controlled bomb attached to a motorcycle killed an Iranian physics professor outside his home in north Tehran on Tuesday, state media reported. The reports blamed the United States and Israel for the attack." Predictably Iran blamed the United States and Israel and just as predictably the United States said that this was "nonsense". The article written by Nazila Fathi goes on to cast suspicions on the Ahmadinejad regime for the attack supposedly because Mohammadi was a member of the opposition. Fathi devotes most of the article to attacking the regime and making the case that they were responsible for the attack while ignoring any discussion or analysis as to why Israel may be the guilty party. This is typical of the Times and the Western media in general. It is a trend that I have observed starting with the contested election where just about every mainstream journalist and liberals like Juan Cole assume that the election was stolen. I on the other hand think that it is very possible that Ahmadinejad did win this election. I don't know that to be the case I merely make the case that it is a possibility. I have linked previously on this subject to polls taken before the election that showed Ahmadinejad winning and while it is assumed by many liberals and Iranian exiles that vote fraud only happened one way there is no reason to believe that Moussavi's side was blameless on this score. Ali Akbar Rafsanjani, who is the Ahmed Chalabi of Iran, was a prominant supporter of Moussavi and who had his own axe to grind with Ahmadinejad was certainly capable of organizing stolen votes of his own. Yet I do not notice this fact ever being brought up. It seems what we have here is what I call "cheerleader journalism" which means that because we want an outcome so bad and we think that outcome is morally justified we skew our reporting to reflect our biases. It is clear to me that Fathi is doing something similar in the reporting on the murder of the Iranian physicist. As Fathi well knows Israel is hell bent on denying Iran not only nuclear weapons but also what I call "the Japan option". The ability to acquire the technical and infrastructual know-how to assemble and deliver a nuclear weapon on short notice if the need arises (As in the case of an American or Israeli attack). That being the case why wouldn't Israel resort to murder to prevent this from occurring? As the region is painfully aware Israel does not believe in nor observe international law. They take whatever actions they feel they must if they feel their national security interests are at stake and they know that in just about every case they can count on the support of the United States. We know that Israel is making plans to attack Iran to take out their nuclear capabilities as I write this. We also know that the Obama administration and every one else in the region and beyond worry, justifiably so, about how this will impact the price of oil and the effect that this will have on the world economy does not want Israel to attack Iran and are hoping that sanctions and peer pressure will do the trick. Given that and the fact that this is not the first time a Iranian nuclear physicist has been killed or disappeared it should be obvious that Israel should be at the top of the list of suspects in this murder. Yet Fathi who writes for the most prestigious paper in America doesn't seem to understand this? I suspect that Fathi is very aware of the strong possibility of Israeli involvement but chooses to ignore it instead keeping the reader in ignorance. Given what we know of the Times dismal performance in the run up to the Iraq war I suspect that they are up to their old tricks. This is bad journalism and does a disservice to readers who should be more informed about what really goes on in the world. Iran considers their nuclear physicists to be a national asset and the idea that they would murder one of their own because he was a member of the opposition seems far fetched to say the least, especially if the stories are true that Mohammadi was for the most part apolitical. Storm clouds are gathering in the region as Paul Rogers discusses in his Open Democracy article that I link to and we may be reaching the end game here where Israel feels they have to strike to maintain their nuclear monopoly no matter what the consequences are for the rest of us. Read these articles that I link to because they are far more informative about what is really going on here than the shallow analysis that passes for a New York Times article. Read the Times article here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/13/world/middleeast/13iran.html?ref=world Read this series of articles by Paul Rogers from Open Democracy that goes into detail about the Iranian/Israeli/American relationship and why it is so serious. Read them here:http://www.opendemocracy.net/paul-rogers/israels-shadow-over-iran and here:http://www.opendemocracy.net/opendemocracy-general/paul-rogers/america-and-iran-big-bombs-and-base-politics and here:http://www.opendemocracy.net/article/iran-america-israel-the-nuclear-gamble. Also this article by Trita Parsi who has also written a very informative book about this strategic triangle called "Treacherous Alliance - The Secret Dealings of Iran, Israel and the United States (Yale University Press, 2007). http://www.opendemocracy.net/democracy-irandemocracy/israel_2974.jsp Finally Glenn Greenwald thoughts on this topic: http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/01/12/iran_scientist/index.html
Sunday, January 3, 2010
More short thoughts
1) Last week of football and another season of futility for the Chicago Bears. When my team is out of the hunt I try to find another team to root for. This is not that easy this season. I could go for the Broncos because I like Kyle Orton and felt like the Bears never game him a chance here but I'm not even sure they are in the hunt. I like to watch New England but I really dislike their coach so that is out. I like this years edition of the Vikings with Favre however they have not played that well in the last couple of games and perhaps Favre will start to show his age in the playoffs. Oh well I know one thing- I wish the worst for the Indianapolis Colts. I really do!
2) I cannot let the Blackwater story go without linking to this article that appeared last month in the New York Times. It details how involved these guys were in Iraq in the critical years from 2004-2006. I quote from the article, "Five former Blackwater employees and four current and former American intelligence officials interviewed for this article would speak only on condition of anonymity because Blackwater’s activities for the agency were secret and former employees feared repercussions from the company. The Blackwater employees said they participated in the raids or had direct knowledge of them.Along with the former officials, they provided few details about the targets of the raids in Iraq and Afghanistan, although they said that many of the Iraq raids were directed against members of Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia. To corroborate the claims of the company’s involvement, a former Blackwater security guard provided photographs to The Times that he said he took during the raids. They showed detainees and armed men whom he and a former company official identified as Blackwater employees. The former intelligence officials said that Blackwater’s work with the C.I.A. in Iraq and Afghanistan had grown out of its early contracts with the spy agency to provide security for the C.I.A. stations in both countries." I remember one of the major networks showed video of these house raids where they would kick down doors humiliate and scare the crap out of these families, many of whom probably were not guilty of anything other than resenting the occupation. I remember thinking to myself if I was in their shoes if I wasn't an insurgent before I probably would be now or I would at least help the ones out who were. When people are subject to humiliation they are not going to be your friends. Blackwater who was immune from prosecution could do a lot of the things that our military had to be more careful about. They were perfect for these kinds of raids. Along with the systemic torture and humiliation that went on in Abu Ghraib, the kind of things that make neo-cons and right wingers hearts go ga-ga over, this did not pass unnoticed by the Iraqi population. Take a look at the dates that this went on. 2004-2006. Now look and see when the insurgency against American troops started to kick in. Think there was a correlation here? Huh? As I try to point out to these angry emotional right wing types who can't get enough torture and humiliation to satisfy them actions have consequences. When you treat people like shit and you are in their country you can't very well expect them to respect you. I often wonder how many ordinary Iraqi citizens suffered at the hands of these kinds of operations that did not deserve to and as a result of this how many American soldiers came home in a box or without one of their limbs. There is a casual chain here. One of the many problems our culture has is that we do not practice empathy here. We seldom put ourselves in other peoples shoes and try to see how I would view the world if I was them. It is why we are always so quick condone torture, more wars and a loss of civil liberties here so we can show that we are "tough" on terror. Obviously this did not work in Iraq in 2004-2006 did it? Unfortunately it is next to impossible to get this point across to the hot heads who think along these lines. It is hard to argue with hardliners who are emotional and angry and are looking for blood. They are oblivious to the effect that these policies will have on their target audience out there in the rest of the world. Nor do they care about international law or in the words of Obama's man in Afghanistan Stanley McChrystal quaint things like the Geneva convention. Beat the crap out of them and that will do the trick say these people and even if it doesn't it will make the hotheads feel better. Meanwhile in the long run we just create more enemies. We play checkers while Al-Queda plays chess. I am not saying that we should do nothing here. Obviously we have a problem with an element of Islam that veers toward extremism. However, and this may come as a news flash to the hotheads and neo-cons who want to make Islam the enemy, most Muslims do not have these attitudes although they are fed up with American foreign policy. We could save ourselves a boatload of money here and pursue a more intelligent strategy if we went about this the old fashioned way through the sharing of intelligence and police networks around the world. The way we are pursuing the war on terror, and you can see it in the media frenzy over the latest attempted attack, is to ensure that we will be fighting "the war on terror" as long as the money holds out. Eventually the money will run out and we will have to pack it in and admit that the empire is busted. In the meanwhile to pay for the guns we will take away the butter for people here and we will continue to see an erosion of our civil liberties, all because a bunch of cowards are so scared of the possibility of a terror attack that they think that by curtailing our freedoms we will have perfect security. That will never happen and even if it was possible it would mean we were a police state. That is not the America I signed up for thank you. This is not Stalin's Soviet Union or Mao's China where the government watches your every move and as a result you have very low crime statistics. I'm big and I'm tough enough to put up with the occasional terror attack and not throw away our values. Are you? Read the article about Blackwater here:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/11/us/politics/11blackwater.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all
2) I cannot let the Blackwater story go without linking to this article that appeared last month in the New York Times. It details how involved these guys were in Iraq in the critical years from 2004-2006. I quote from the article, "Five former Blackwater employees and four current and former American intelligence officials interviewed for this article would speak only on condition of anonymity because Blackwater’s activities for the agency were secret and former employees feared repercussions from the company. The Blackwater employees said they participated in the raids or had direct knowledge of them.Along with the former officials, they provided few details about the targets of the raids in Iraq and Afghanistan, although they said that many of the Iraq raids were directed against members of Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia. To corroborate the claims of the company’s involvement, a former Blackwater security guard provided photographs to The Times that he said he took during the raids. They showed detainees and armed men whom he and a former company official identified as Blackwater employees. The former intelligence officials said that Blackwater’s work with the C.I.A. in Iraq and Afghanistan had grown out of its early contracts with the spy agency to provide security for the C.I.A. stations in both countries." I remember one of the major networks showed video of these house raids where they would kick down doors humiliate and scare the crap out of these families, many of whom probably were not guilty of anything other than resenting the occupation. I remember thinking to myself if I was in their shoes if I wasn't an insurgent before I probably would be now or I would at least help the ones out who were. When people are subject to humiliation they are not going to be your friends. Blackwater who was immune from prosecution could do a lot of the things that our military had to be more careful about. They were perfect for these kinds of raids. Along with the systemic torture and humiliation that went on in Abu Ghraib, the kind of things that make neo-cons and right wingers hearts go ga-ga over, this did not pass unnoticed by the Iraqi population. Take a look at the dates that this went on. 2004-2006. Now look and see when the insurgency against American troops started to kick in. Think there was a correlation here? Huh? As I try to point out to these angry emotional right wing types who can't get enough torture and humiliation to satisfy them actions have consequences. When you treat people like shit and you are in their country you can't very well expect them to respect you. I often wonder how many ordinary Iraqi citizens suffered at the hands of these kinds of operations that did not deserve to and as a result of this how many American soldiers came home in a box or without one of their limbs. There is a casual chain here. One of the many problems our culture has is that we do not practice empathy here. We seldom put ourselves in other peoples shoes and try to see how I would view the world if I was them. It is why we are always so quick condone torture, more wars and a loss of civil liberties here so we can show that we are "tough" on terror. Obviously this did not work in Iraq in 2004-2006 did it? Unfortunately it is next to impossible to get this point across to the hot heads who think along these lines. It is hard to argue with hardliners who are emotional and angry and are looking for blood. They are oblivious to the effect that these policies will have on their target audience out there in the rest of the world. Nor do they care about international law or in the words of Obama's man in Afghanistan Stanley McChrystal quaint things like the Geneva convention. Beat the crap out of them and that will do the trick say these people and even if it doesn't it will make the hotheads feel better. Meanwhile in the long run we just create more enemies. We play checkers while Al-Queda plays chess. I am not saying that we should do nothing here. Obviously we have a problem with an element of Islam that veers toward extremism. However, and this may come as a news flash to the hotheads and neo-cons who want to make Islam the enemy, most Muslims do not have these attitudes although they are fed up with American foreign policy. We could save ourselves a boatload of money here and pursue a more intelligent strategy if we went about this the old fashioned way through the sharing of intelligence and police networks around the world. The way we are pursuing the war on terror, and you can see it in the media frenzy over the latest attempted attack, is to ensure that we will be fighting "the war on terror" as long as the money holds out. Eventually the money will run out and we will have to pack it in and admit that the empire is busted. In the meanwhile to pay for the guns we will take away the butter for people here and we will continue to see an erosion of our civil liberties, all because a bunch of cowards are so scared of the possibility of a terror attack that they think that by curtailing our freedoms we will have perfect security. That will never happen and even if it was possible it would mean we were a police state. That is not the America I signed up for thank you. This is not Stalin's Soviet Union or Mao's China where the government watches your every move and as a result you have very low crime statistics. I'm big and I'm tough enough to put up with the occasional terror attack and not throw away our values. Are you? Read the article about Blackwater here:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/11/us/politics/11blackwater.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all
Saturday, January 2, 2010
Thoughts to kick off a new year!
1) Happy New Year! Hopefully 2010 will be better than 2009. Time will tell. My resolution for the new year is to get my own computer so I can blog on a more steady basis. Hopefully the finances will be better this year. The year may be new but the same old problems remain with no end in sight. Some reflections and comments:
2) It seems that those five Blackwater employees who were on trial for the killing of 17 Iraqi civilians have had their case dismissed for prosecutorial misconduct. According to this New York Times article and I quote, "In a significant blow to the Justice Department, a federal judge on Thursday threw out the indictment of five former Blackwater security guards over a shooting in Baghdad in 2007 that left 17 Iraqis dead and about 20 wounded.The judge cited misuse of statements made by the guards in his decision, which brought to a sudden halt one of the highest-profile prosecutions to arise from the Iraq war. The shooting at Nisour Square frayed relations between the Iraqi government and the Bush administration and put a spotlight on the United States’ growing reliance on private security contractors in war zones.....In a “reckless violation of the defendants’ constitutional rights,” the judge wrote, investigators, prosecutors and government witnesses had inappropriately relied on statements that the guards had been compelled to make in debriefings by the State Department shortly after the shootings. The State Department had hired the guards to protect its officials." It seems that after the shootings the State Department debriefed the Blackwater employees and took testimony that they claimed had to be given but that would not be used against them later on. However the prosecutors did use these statements in their case against the employees. Again I quote, "The guards could not be prosecuted under Iraqi law because of an immunity agreement that had been signed by the Coalition Provisional Authority, the governing authority installed by the United States after the invasion of Iraq. But American prosecutors knew from the beginning that they were facing a difficult task in bringing the case. Complications included the applicability of federal statutes to the guards because they were working overseas at the time for the State Department, and the significant problem stemming from statements the guards gave shortly after the shootings. The guards had been told by State Department investigators that they could be fired if they did not talk about the case, but that whatever they said would not be used against them in any criminal proceeding. Nevertheless, Judge Urbina found that “in their zeal to bring charges,” investigators and prosecutors had extensively used those statements, disregarding “the warning of experienced, senior prosecutors” that “the course of action threatened the viability of prosecution.” The money quote here is that the prosecutors disregarded the warnings of experienced senior prosecutors that the course of action threatened the viability of the prosecution. So why did they do it? This story brings out many of the reasons that I dislike the mainstream/corporate media so much. This story has not been covered very much to begin with and when it is the obvious questions do not seem to be asked. Such as given that the Bush administration hired Blackwater and gave them immunity from Iraqi prosecution the idea that the Bush justice department was going to seriously go after these guys was a stretch to many of us who think the Bush justice department was one of the most politicized and dishonest since the Nixon administration. That being the case did it ever occur to these clowns who make up your media that perhaps the Bush justice department bungled this on purpose? That they were not interested in convicting them to begin with? Ya think? However the media have not pursued this angle. Blackwater is despised in Iraq for what is perceived as their reckless disregard for the citizens of Iraq. It got so bad that the government of Iraq asked them to leave. Predictably the Iraqis are not too happy that the case has been dropped. It is unlikely the case can be appealed. One can be sure that this will fire up more anti-American attitudes around the world. By becoming so dependant on these private security contractors who operate as a law unto themselves we make it easier for Al-Queda groups to find new recruits for global jihad. Contrary to what the right would have you believe actions have consequences. American policies do make a difference in the way that Muslims view the world. The knee-jerk support we give Israel, the invasion and occupation of Iraq, the torture and the use of trigger happy private contractors like Blackwater who are immune from any accountability piss just about all Muslims around the world off. Thankfully most do not let their anger drive them into the arms of Al-Queda like organizations but along the way some will give in, no doubt aided by this kind of crap. In the New York Times article concerning the Iraqi reaction a man named Abdul Wahab Adul Khader is quoted. He says, "What are we — not human. Why do they have the right to kill people? Is our blood so cheap? For America, the land of justice and law, what does it mean to let criminals go?” After the last eight years especially, few people take our rhetoric about human rights and the rule of law seriously. Only gullible Americans who do not take the time to really get informed about the world and what we do buy into this. Read the article about the dismissal here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/01/us/01blackwater.html Read about the Iraqi reaction here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/02/us/02blackwater.html?hp Read about the Iraqi decision to revoke Blackwater's license here:http://www.mcclatchydc.com/iraq/story/61018.html
2) It seems that those five Blackwater employees who were on trial for the killing of 17 Iraqi civilians have had their case dismissed for prosecutorial misconduct. According to this New York Times article and I quote, "In a significant blow to the Justice Department, a federal judge on Thursday threw out the indictment of five former Blackwater security guards over a shooting in Baghdad in 2007 that left 17 Iraqis dead and about 20 wounded.The judge cited misuse of statements made by the guards in his decision, which brought to a sudden halt one of the highest-profile prosecutions to arise from the Iraq war. The shooting at Nisour Square frayed relations between the Iraqi government and the Bush administration and put a spotlight on the United States’ growing reliance on private security contractors in war zones.....In a “reckless violation of the defendants’ constitutional rights,” the judge wrote, investigators, prosecutors and government witnesses had inappropriately relied on statements that the guards had been compelled to make in debriefings by the State Department shortly after the shootings. The State Department had hired the guards to protect its officials." It seems that after the shootings the State Department debriefed the Blackwater employees and took testimony that they claimed had to be given but that would not be used against them later on. However the prosecutors did use these statements in their case against the employees. Again I quote, "The guards could not be prosecuted under Iraqi law because of an immunity agreement that had been signed by the Coalition Provisional Authority, the governing authority installed by the United States after the invasion of Iraq. But American prosecutors knew from the beginning that they were facing a difficult task in bringing the case. Complications included the applicability of federal statutes to the guards because they were working overseas at the time for the State Department, and the significant problem stemming from statements the guards gave shortly after the shootings. The guards had been told by State Department investigators that they could be fired if they did not talk about the case, but that whatever they said would not be used against them in any criminal proceeding. Nevertheless, Judge Urbina found that “in their zeal to bring charges,” investigators and prosecutors had extensively used those statements, disregarding “the warning of experienced, senior prosecutors” that “the course of action threatened the viability of prosecution.” The money quote here is that the prosecutors disregarded the warnings of experienced senior prosecutors that the course of action threatened the viability of the prosecution. So why did they do it? This story brings out many of the reasons that I dislike the mainstream/corporate media so much. This story has not been covered very much to begin with and when it is the obvious questions do not seem to be asked. Such as given that the Bush administration hired Blackwater and gave them immunity from Iraqi prosecution the idea that the Bush justice department was going to seriously go after these guys was a stretch to many of us who think the Bush justice department was one of the most politicized and dishonest since the Nixon administration. That being the case did it ever occur to these clowns who make up your media that perhaps the Bush justice department bungled this on purpose? That they were not interested in convicting them to begin with? Ya think? However the media have not pursued this angle. Blackwater is despised in Iraq for what is perceived as their reckless disregard for the citizens of Iraq. It got so bad that the government of Iraq asked them to leave. Predictably the Iraqis are not too happy that the case has been dropped. It is unlikely the case can be appealed. One can be sure that this will fire up more anti-American attitudes around the world. By becoming so dependant on these private security contractors who operate as a law unto themselves we make it easier for Al-Queda groups to find new recruits for global jihad. Contrary to what the right would have you believe actions have consequences. American policies do make a difference in the way that Muslims view the world. The knee-jerk support we give Israel, the invasion and occupation of Iraq, the torture and the use of trigger happy private contractors like Blackwater who are immune from any accountability piss just about all Muslims around the world off. Thankfully most do not let their anger drive them into the arms of Al-Queda like organizations but along the way some will give in, no doubt aided by this kind of crap. In the New York Times article concerning the Iraqi reaction a man named Abdul Wahab Adul Khader is quoted. He says, "What are we — not human. Why do they have the right to kill people? Is our blood so cheap? For America, the land of justice and law, what does it mean to let criminals go?” After the last eight years especially, few people take our rhetoric about human rights and the rule of law seriously. Only gullible Americans who do not take the time to really get informed about the world and what we do buy into this. Read the article about the dismissal here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/01/us/01blackwater.html Read about the Iraqi reaction here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/02/us/02blackwater.html?hp Read about the Iraqi decision to revoke Blackwater's license here:http://www.mcclatchydc.com/iraq/story/61018.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)