Saturday, February 28, 2009
Why I look forward to Saturday morning
It's Saturday morning and in the Chicago metropolitan area that means another installation of my favorite progressive/left show on the radio. Northwestern University radio station WNUR 89.3 and "This is hell" with host Chuck Mertz that normally runs from 9:00am to 1:00 pm except when pre-empted for Northwestern sports. This is simply the most informative and entertaining progressive show on the radio right now with a consistently excellent guest list that deals with a wide range of topics in depth and no commercial constraints. It blows Keith Olbermann and Air America out of the water (with the exception of Thom Hartmann) and should be cloned and broadcast all over America to get the progressive voice out. It is a genuine alternative for those like me who feel under our "two party" system progressive alternatives are frozen out of both the media and in Congress. Chuck and his guests pull no punches and go after both parties. Obama supporters beware. If you are one of the starry eyed minions who held your "change we can believe in" signs you may be offended. This show is not about coddling the Democratic Party. They also podcast and you can access their web site here: http://www.thisishell.net/
Friday, February 27, 2009
They don't call him fast Eddie for nuttin'
I had my caption all ready to go as I awaited what I thought would be the inevitable jail time that "fast Eddie" Vrdolyak would receive as a result of his pleading guilty to his involvement in a shady real estate deal. It would have went like this. Somewhere in that big city hall up in the sky Harold Washington is flashing that infectious grin of his upon hearing that fast Eddie Vrdolyak is going to jail today. That headline will not be written however because an 84 year old judge who supposedly has impeccable credentials decided to give fast Eddie no jail time. Nada. Instead Judge Milton Shadur seemed more upset at the fact that the prosecution would refer to Vrdolyak as an insider. How dare they!! While Vrdolyak will pay a relatively small fine and has lost his law license, according to Mark Brown of the Chicago Sun Times, fast Eddie will still receive $250,000 a year through 2024. Unbelievable. Eddie is the ultimate Chicago insider. He wrote the book. At least Eddie knew who to thank. It wasn't the judge. On the way out of the courthouse Vrdolyak flashed his trademark shit eating grin and simply said "God is great" as he had a cell phone in his ear no doubt cutting the next deal. Indeed God is.
Thursday, February 26, 2009
R.I.P Norm Van Lier
Former Chicago Bull Norm Van Lier was found dead today. Cause of death unknown. To the younger generation around Chicago Norm is known as a media analyst who was opinionated, entertaining and a bit of a curmudgeon. To those of us who are older and came of age in the 70's or before Norm is remembered as a hard nosed pit bull of a guard who played on those very good Bulls teams of the 70s. They never won a championship (although they came close one year) unlike the Michael Jordan-Scottie Pippen-Dennis Rodman Bulls but those 70s Bulls teams with Norm and Jerry Sloan, Chet Walker, Bob Love, Tom Boerwinkle and Bobby Weiss were a fun team to watch. They didn't have the most talent but they made up for it with tenacious defense and intelligent play. I remember many nights listening to their games on WIND in the car when Jim Durham and Johnny Kerr announced the games and totally annoying a girl I was seeing at the time. Norm was also a big music fan and I would see him on occasion at Second Hand Tunes in Oak Park trying to find that good deal. He will be missed.
Short thoughts for a Thursday
1) If Bobby Jindahl is the best thing the Republican party has going for them then if I were a Republican I would work like hell to change the constitution and find a way to make it legal for Arnold to run. These guys are pathetic.
2) There is that magic number 30 again!! From UPI news comes this headline: "30 die in multiple attacks in Afghanistan."
3) Ozzie Guillen manager of the Chicago White Sox on how he would like to go off into the great beyond: "I hope I die on the field. I hope when I walk to the mound to change the pitcher, I drop dead and that's it. I know that my family would be so happy that it happened on the field. They wouldn't feel bad because that's what I've always wanted to do." Regardless of whether you are a White Sox fan or not you gotta love this guy!!
2) There is that magic number 30 again!! From UPI news comes this headline: "30 die in multiple attacks in Afghanistan."
3) Ozzie Guillen manager of the Chicago White Sox on how he would like to go off into the great beyond: "I hope I die on the field. I hope when I walk to the mound to change the pitcher, I drop dead and that's it. I know that my family would be so happy that it happened on the field. They wouldn't feel bad because that's what I've always wanted to do." Regardless of whether you are a White Sox fan or not you gotta love this guy!!
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
Nawaz Sharif
In a previous post I made reference to a conversation Richard Holbrooke, our point man for Southeast Asia, had with Nawaz Sharif who is Pakistans most popular opposition politician and twice headed the government in the 90's. I said this:
"One other item in Shazads report struck my attention. According to the article Holbrooke met with Nawaz Sharif to get him to drop his support for the lawyers movement against the government because this could destabilize the government. So just like the Bush administration before it the Obama administration will join in a long line of US administrations that look the other way to Pakistani democracy."
Now this from the LA Times: http://http//www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-pakistan26-2009feb26,0,1360310.story The relevant paragraphs: "The Supreme Court today banned the country's most popular opposition politician, former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, from holding elected office, a verdict that could trigger prolonged political upheaval in Pakistan.Sharif's supporters angrily protested the ruling, saying they do not recognize the legitimacy of the high court. They repeated demands for the reinstatement of the former chief justice and other senior judges dismissed by ex-President Pervez Musharraf in late 2007 during a bout of de facto martial law." Some thoughts:
1) This is a bad decision. I very much doubt that the high court of Pakistan would pass this without the United States being aware of it and approving this. Obviously Holbrooke's talk with Sharif did not go well. According to the Chicago Tribune the reason given had to do with criminal charges that were brought against Sharif when he tried to prevent Pervez Musharraf from overthrowing him back in 1999. However Sharif was able to compete in the most recent elections and with the death of Benazir Bhutto is probably the most popular politician in Pakistan right now, far more popular than Benazir's widower Asif Zardari (Mr. 10%). They also banned his brother Shabaz Sharif who is currently the chief minister of the Punjab, Pakistan's most important province. As I pointed out in that previous post the Obama administration joins a long line of previous administrations who have shut the door on democracy in Pakistan starting with the Eisenhower administrations embrace of Ayub Khan in 1958 and continuing with General Zia in the 1980s, Pervez Musharraf and recently the Bush administration's heavy handed attempts at a shotgun marriage between Benazir and Pervez that helped bring about her death. Sharif claims that because this court is illegitimate so is this decision and he repeated his calls for the reinstatement of Iftiqar Chaudry and the other judges sacked by Musharraf in a blatant attempt to protect himself from a judicial ruling that might have disqualified him from power. Sharif is hypocritical here because when he was in power he tried to intimidate the court himself but regardless of his motives he is right here. The judges should be reinstated. This is what the people want and this is why they in effect voted Musharraf out of power in the last election. We bear a lot of the blame here for the sorry state of Pakistan right now because of our blatant interference over the years in Pakistan's political development. There is always some "crisis" that we use to slam the door shut on democracy in Pakistan whether it is the communist menace or the war on terror. It is no wonder anti-Americanism is at an all time high.
2)I imagine that this ruling will create a firestorm of protest and rightfully so. If Holbrooke is so concerned about the destabilization of the Pakistani government this is a strange way of showing it. Again the timing here is critical. This move comes after Holbrook's talks with Sharif and after army chief of staff Ashfaq Kiani's visit to the US. Just like every coup that occurs in Pakistan it is hard to believe that we were completely out of the loop on this. Obama needs to speak out publicly against this and soon to contain the damage. However given that Holbrooke's fingerprints are all over this I doubt that will occur. As I have said before we are playing a very dangerous game here in regards to Pakistan. By allowing this to stand it appears that we are actively trying to destabilize Pakistan thereby giving us an excuse to go in and "grab the nukes" Either that or these guys are just clueless.
"One other item in Shazads report struck my attention. According to the article Holbrooke met with Nawaz Sharif to get him to drop his support for the lawyers movement against the government because this could destabilize the government. So just like the Bush administration before it the Obama administration will join in a long line of US administrations that look the other way to Pakistani democracy."
Now this from the LA Times: http://http//www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-pakistan26-2009feb26,0,1360310.story The relevant paragraphs: "The Supreme Court today banned the country's most popular opposition politician, former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, from holding elected office, a verdict that could trigger prolonged political upheaval in Pakistan.Sharif's supporters angrily protested the ruling, saying they do not recognize the legitimacy of the high court. They repeated demands for the reinstatement of the former chief justice and other senior judges dismissed by ex-President Pervez Musharraf in late 2007 during a bout of de facto martial law." Some thoughts:
1) This is a bad decision. I very much doubt that the high court of Pakistan would pass this without the United States being aware of it and approving this. Obviously Holbrooke's talk with Sharif did not go well. According to the Chicago Tribune the reason given had to do with criminal charges that were brought against Sharif when he tried to prevent Pervez Musharraf from overthrowing him back in 1999. However Sharif was able to compete in the most recent elections and with the death of Benazir Bhutto is probably the most popular politician in Pakistan right now, far more popular than Benazir's widower Asif Zardari (Mr. 10%). They also banned his brother Shabaz Sharif who is currently the chief minister of the Punjab, Pakistan's most important province. As I pointed out in that previous post the Obama administration joins a long line of previous administrations who have shut the door on democracy in Pakistan starting with the Eisenhower administrations embrace of Ayub Khan in 1958 and continuing with General Zia in the 1980s, Pervez Musharraf and recently the Bush administration's heavy handed attempts at a shotgun marriage between Benazir and Pervez that helped bring about her death. Sharif claims that because this court is illegitimate so is this decision and he repeated his calls for the reinstatement of Iftiqar Chaudry and the other judges sacked by Musharraf in a blatant attempt to protect himself from a judicial ruling that might have disqualified him from power. Sharif is hypocritical here because when he was in power he tried to intimidate the court himself but regardless of his motives he is right here. The judges should be reinstated. This is what the people want and this is why they in effect voted Musharraf out of power in the last election. We bear a lot of the blame here for the sorry state of Pakistan right now because of our blatant interference over the years in Pakistan's political development. There is always some "crisis" that we use to slam the door shut on democracy in Pakistan whether it is the communist menace or the war on terror. It is no wonder anti-Americanism is at an all time high.
2)I imagine that this ruling will create a firestorm of protest and rightfully so. If Holbrooke is so concerned about the destabilization of the Pakistani government this is a strange way of showing it. Again the timing here is critical. This move comes after Holbrook's talks with Sharif and after army chief of staff Ashfaq Kiani's visit to the US. Just like every coup that occurs in Pakistan it is hard to believe that we were completely out of the loop on this. Obama needs to speak out publicly against this and soon to contain the damage. However given that Holbrooke's fingerprints are all over this I doubt that will occur. As I have said before we are playing a very dangerous game here in regards to Pakistan. By allowing this to stand it appears that we are actively trying to destabilize Pakistan thereby giving us an excuse to go in and "grab the nukes" Either that or these guys are just clueless.
The derivatives mess
If you are confused by what is really going on in the economy I came across this post that does an excellent job of explaining the credit default swaps and the collateralized debt obligations to the average person who does not have an economics degree and is not privy to the language of the economic "experts" written by someone who bills herself as "the other Katherine Harris"!
http://dandelionsalad.wordpress.com/2009/02/18/exclusive-derivatives-for-dummies-by-the-other-katherine-harris/ Some thoughts:
1) I seldom hear anyone in the media talk about credit default swaps and the centrality of them in our economic meltdown. I watched the Frontline special on PBS that dealt with the chronology of the meltdown leading up to the passage of the TARP. It was made clear that when Paulsen decided to let Lehman Brothers fail this triggered all kinds of financial obligations that AIG had to pay based on these swaps. Hence the bailout. Yet Paulsen who is supposed to be a financial hot shot seemed to be unaware of the implications of what would happen when Lehman went under. If according to the Bank for International Settlements using the best guess they have that there are potentially 1.6 quadrillion dollars of potential liabilities here, that is more money than there is in the world!! (Unless you start printing money recklessly creating hyperinflation) One has to wonder that if AIG was knee deep in this crap who else is? How many banks and insurance companies are tied down with this. Which leads to my next point.
2) Most of these swaps are private affairs. They are not registered on a public market. There is no transparency here. This would help explain why many of the largest banks will not lend to each other. They don't trust the others balance sheet because they know how tied in they are in this. Remember I am talking only about the credit default swaps here and am ignoring the collateralized debt obligations which is another land mine. Until we get at the bottom of who owes what and who is holding what all the money in the world Obama wants to throw at Wall Street will not get us out of this mess. However if Paulsen himself seemed to be unaware of the impact of these things on allowing Lehman Brothers collapse I am not optimistic we will get to the bottom of this. This is the 800 pound gorilla in the room that will work against any resolution of this crisis.
3) The only way out of this mess is to declare ALL credit default swaps null and void. No doubt this will not go over well with Wall Street but that is too bad. These things were reckless from the get go. To quote from the article:
"but imagine that your payoff depends on the failure of a company, a currency or a country. The weaker your target is perceived to be, as reflected by the cost of default insurance on its debt, the closer you move toward your ultimate goal. So you and your friends will do all you can to drive that cost up and make the world fully aware of it, including buying and selling CDS contracts openly. This makes the rising cost apparent and you can count on the rating agencies to take notice swiftly. Their downgrade will become the death-knell.
Therein lies another great problem with Credit Default Swaps. They work exactly like short-selling and rumor-mongering (which CDS owners may well be doing, too) to create self-fulfilling prophecies."
In other words these bets can become self-fulfilling prophesies where to make money you actively engage in the failure of the institution you have a bet on and the American public pays for it. THIS IS NUTS!!! Declaring these swaps null and void will not solve our economic mess but will be a good first step in containing the damage. This should have been in Obama's speech last night.
http://dandelionsalad.wordpress.com/2009/02/18/exclusive-derivatives-for-dummies-by-the-other-katherine-harris/ Some thoughts:
1) I seldom hear anyone in the media talk about credit default swaps and the centrality of them in our economic meltdown. I watched the Frontline special on PBS that dealt with the chronology of the meltdown leading up to the passage of the TARP. It was made clear that when Paulsen decided to let Lehman Brothers fail this triggered all kinds of financial obligations that AIG had to pay based on these swaps. Hence the bailout. Yet Paulsen who is supposed to be a financial hot shot seemed to be unaware of the implications of what would happen when Lehman went under. If according to the Bank for International Settlements using the best guess they have that there are potentially 1.6 quadrillion dollars of potential liabilities here, that is more money than there is in the world!! (Unless you start printing money recklessly creating hyperinflation) One has to wonder that if AIG was knee deep in this crap who else is? How many banks and insurance companies are tied down with this. Which leads to my next point.
2) Most of these swaps are private affairs. They are not registered on a public market. There is no transparency here. This would help explain why many of the largest banks will not lend to each other. They don't trust the others balance sheet because they know how tied in they are in this. Remember I am talking only about the credit default swaps here and am ignoring the collateralized debt obligations which is another land mine. Until we get at the bottom of who owes what and who is holding what all the money in the world Obama wants to throw at Wall Street will not get us out of this mess. However if Paulsen himself seemed to be unaware of the impact of these things on allowing Lehman Brothers collapse I am not optimistic we will get to the bottom of this. This is the 800 pound gorilla in the room that will work against any resolution of this crisis.
3) The only way out of this mess is to declare ALL credit default swaps null and void. No doubt this will not go over well with Wall Street but that is too bad. These things were reckless from the get go. To quote from the article:
"but imagine that your payoff depends on the failure of a company, a currency or a country. The weaker your target is perceived to be, as reflected by the cost of default insurance on its debt, the closer you move toward your ultimate goal. So you and your friends will do all you can to drive that cost up and make the world fully aware of it, including buying and selling CDS contracts openly. This makes the rising cost apparent and you can count on the rating agencies to take notice swiftly. Their downgrade will become the death-knell.
Therein lies another great problem with Credit Default Swaps. They work exactly like short-selling and rumor-mongering (which CDS owners may well be doing, too) to create self-fulfilling prophecies."
In other words these bets can become self-fulfilling prophesies where to make money you actively engage in the failure of the institution you have a bet on and the American public pays for it. THIS IS NUTS!!! Declaring these swaps null and void will not solve our economic mess but will be a good first step in containing the damage. This should have been in Obama's speech last night.
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
Tiny bubbles
The late comedian George Carlin used to do a skit where he was a hippie weatherman and was giving his nightly weather report. He noticed that our radar had picked up the fact that Soviet nuclear missiles were headed for the American heartland. At the same time the weather forecast called for thunderstorms. Carlin's comment was for this night "don't sweat the thunderstorms". This article appeared in the LA Times recently: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-global-warming-methane22-2009feb22,0,2624775,print.story
I guess we shouldn't sweat the carbon dioxide.
I guess we shouldn't sweat the carbon dioxide.
Good news from Washington
If this story is accurate it is the best thing to happen in Washington foreign policy in a long time. Chas Freeman, a well respected and well travelled career diplomat with a long and impressive resume is apparently going to head up the National Intelligence Council which is the group that produces the NIEs (the National Intelligence Estimates) after going over the reports of all the various intelligence agencies. What makes this appointment special though is that Freeman is a well known critic of American support of Israel having been very vocal over the years in making the case that our unconditional support of everything Israel does is harmful overall to American interests and creates enemies in the Muslim world unnecessarily. Along with this is this other piece of good news that Dennis Ross apparently will not be named our official point man on Iran. Hallelujah!! I believe that the situation in Afghanistan has a lot to do with this along with the recent Israeli elections and the situation in Iraq. We will need Iranian help in dealing with the Afghan mess and I think events our pushing us in this direction whether this was the original intention or not. Expect a huge push back from AIPAC on this. My only fear is that Freeman may get the Colin Powell treatment and find himself marginalized. That could happen. However I am going to allow myself to look at the glass as half full today and say what a nice way to start off a Tuesday!!
Sunday, February 22, 2009
Short thoughts for a Sunday
Two of the stupidest statements concerning the Middle East:
1) Golda Meir denying in a London Times article in 1969 that "there was no such thing as Palestinians...It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a people and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist." Apologists for Meir make the argument that historically there was no Palestinian entity and that the Palestinians never thought of themselves historically as Palestinians but rather as Arabs. This misses the point. The Palestinians became a people when around 750,000 of them were forced or fled from their homes in 1948. The problem got worse when Israel occupied the West Bank and submitted more unwilling people to their occupation. Regardless of what they were before 1948 they are Palestinians now and forever. Until they receive justice there will never be peace.
2) Condoleeza Rice commenting in 2006 as Israel was carpet bombing Lebanon and attacking Gaza leaving behind death and destruction and scores of refugees "we are witnessing the birth pangs of a new Middle East." She wasn't called the "ice queen" for nothing!
1) Golda Meir denying in a London Times article in 1969 that "there was no such thing as Palestinians...It was not as though there was a Palestinian people in Palestine considering itself as a people and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist." Apologists for Meir make the argument that historically there was no Palestinian entity and that the Palestinians never thought of themselves historically as Palestinians but rather as Arabs. This misses the point. The Palestinians became a people when around 750,000 of them were forced or fled from their homes in 1948. The problem got worse when Israel occupied the West Bank and submitted more unwilling people to their occupation. Regardless of what they were before 1948 they are Palestinians now and forever. Until they receive justice there will never be peace.
2) Condoleeza Rice commenting in 2006 as Israel was carpet bombing Lebanon and attacking Gaza leaving behind death and destruction and scores of refugees "we are witnessing the birth pangs of a new Middle East." She wasn't called the "ice queen" for nothing!
Friday, February 20, 2009
Roland Burris and that Senate seat
I feel sorry for Roland Burris in a way. He doesn't deserve the verbal abuse that he is receiving from the media-both national and local. (I am thinking of Tribune columnist John Kass in particular who on a good day has about as much charm as a dead skunk decomposing on a highway and has been even more verbally abusive than usual) Burris is not an evil man. He has been bouncing around Illinois politics since I came of age in the 70's. At that time there were very few black politicians of a statewide stature and I remember Burris and Cecil Partee as two of the few. They were basically go along get along types who did not make waves and did as they were told. Solid centrist Democrats cut from a different cloth than Jesse Jackson and Ralph Metcalfe. (Metcalfe got in the game late as a result of Chicago police harassment of black dentists and police brutality) When the Senate seat came up I am sure Burris thought that this would be a good way to close out his career. He probably thought that because of the hysteria over Blago he wouldn't mention the contacts he had with Blago's brother about possible fundraisers and set up roadblocks to his appointment. After all there is nothing illegal in holding a fundraiser for someone and in the end Burris did not have one. So I am sure he thought why bring it up. Then it probably turned out that his conversations were recorded on one of Fitzgerald's tapes and he couldn't hide that fact. Now there is a huge firestorm over possible cover-up and perjury. The Republicans and the Chicago Tribune want Burris to drop out and have a special election to fill the seat. Some observations.
1) I just heard on the news that not only does acting governor Pat Quinn think Burris should step down but that there should be a special election to fill the seat. I was afraid this was going to happen. HOW DUMB ARE THESE GUYS!!! Putting aside the fact that this election would be good for about a year and the high cost of it at a time when Illinois is running large deficits, lets all conduct a thought experiment here. Lets imagine the situation was reversed and a Republican governor had appointed the equivalent of Burris. Then the governor was impeached and the lieutenant governor was a Republican also. Assuming that the Republicans would even ask the GOP equivalent of Burris to resign (a mighty big if-Republicans do not apologize!) the idea that they would ask for a special election that would allow the Democrats to win a seat they couldn't win in the general election is preposterous. They would have the GOP acting governor pick a Republican replacement and that would be the end of it. No apologies and no backsliding and THEY WOULD HAVE EVERY LEGAL RIGHT TO DO SO!! They would want that Republican vote and they would take political advantage when they were allowed to do so. Why do Democrats have such a hard time playing power politics? The idea that if a special election is called that means that columnists like John Kass will like you is absurd. He'll find something else to bitch about. These guys will never be happy.
2) The Republicans are desperate to block Obama anyway they can and they smell blood here. They cannot win an election the normal way and are using this as a way to get in the back door. I think they even have a candidate picked out already. My own congressman Mark Kirk. who they think they can sell as a moderate Republican even though he voted with Bush something like 95% of the time. Don't let them do it. Let the Tribune scream all they want along with the national media. The stakes are too high to let the Republicans in when legally you do not have to. Make no mistake. This is not just about Roland Burris, If it was Quinn could just appoint another Democrat not tainted in anyway by Blago and that would be the end of it. Blago and Quinn were never on good terms. This is about Republicans picking up a Senate seat that they desperately need.
3) My opinion on this for what it is worth is that if the voters of Illinois want to change the way that vacancies are filled in these kinds of circumstances (which seldom come up) then let the voters decide in a referendum next election. A Democrat won the election in 2004 and should fill out the term. I would feel the same way if the situation was reversed and a Republican vacated the seat. The party that originally won the election should fill the seat. Period. If the voters want to change that they can do that next election.
4) As for Burris, he should have known that considering how toxic Blago is, even though he didn't do anything wrong, (based at what we know at present) full disclosure was called for. As it is he should resign and let Quinn pick somebody else and be done with it. Considering that the Tribune endorsed George W. Bush twice and routinely endorses Richie Daley I find it hard to take their new conversion to reform Illinois politics seriously. It is time for Democrats to grow a couple.
1) I just heard on the news that not only does acting governor Pat Quinn think Burris should step down but that there should be a special election to fill the seat. I was afraid this was going to happen. HOW DUMB ARE THESE GUYS!!! Putting aside the fact that this election would be good for about a year and the high cost of it at a time when Illinois is running large deficits, lets all conduct a thought experiment here. Lets imagine the situation was reversed and a Republican governor had appointed the equivalent of Burris. Then the governor was impeached and the lieutenant governor was a Republican also. Assuming that the Republicans would even ask the GOP equivalent of Burris to resign (a mighty big if-Republicans do not apologize!) the idea that they would ask for a special election that would allow the Democrats to win a seat they couldn't win in the general election is preposterous. They would have the GOP acting governor pick a Republican replacement and that would be the end of it. No apologies and no backsliding and THEY WOULD HAVE EVERY LEGAL RIGHT TO DO SO!! They would want that Republican vote and they would take political advantage when they were allowed to do so. Why do Democrats have such a hard time playing power politics? The idea that if a special election is called that means that columnists like John Kass will like you is absurd. He'll find something else to bitch about. These guys will never be happy.
2) The Republicans are desperate to block Obama anyway they can and they smell blood here. They cannot win an election the normal way and are using this as a way to get in the back door. I think they even have a candidate picked out already. My own congressman Mark Kirk. who they think they can sell as a moderate Republican even though he voted with Bush something like 95% of the time. Don't let them do it. Let the Tribune scream all they want along with the national media. The stakes are too high to let the Republicans in when legally you do not have to. Make no mistake. This is not just about Roland Burris, If it was Quinn could just appoint another Democrat not tainted in anyway by Blago and that would be the end of it. Blago and Quinn were never on good terms. This is about Republicans picking up a Senate seat that they desperately need.
3) My opinion on this for what it is worth is that if the voters of Illinois want to change the way that vacancies are filled in these kinds of circumstances (which seldom come up) then let the voters decide in a referendum next election. A Democrat won the election in 2004 and should fill out the term. I would feel the same way if the situation was reversed and a Republican vacated the seat. The party that originally won the election should fill the seat. Period. If the voters want to change that they can do that next election.
4) As for Burris, he should have known that considering how toxic Blago is, even though he didn't do anything wrong, (based at what we know at present) full disclosure was called for. As it is he should resign and let Quinn pick somebody else and be done with it. Considering that the Tribune endorsed George W. Bush twice and routinely endorses Richie Daley I find it hard to take their new conversion to reform Illinois politics seriously. It is time for Democrats to grow a couple.
Short thoughts for a Friday
1) Watching the evening news last night and seeing the warm reception Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton received in Canada and Indonesia respectively made me realize that whatever problems I have with the Obama administration it sure is nice to have leaders that are respected and admired leading our country instead of the bumbling and arrogant George W. Bush and the clueless "ice queen" Condeleeza Rice. What a relief for the rest of the world!
2) It looks like Benjamin Netanyahu has been selected to form Israel's next government. This decision comes after Avigdor Lieberman of the far-right Yisrael Beitenu party recommended him on the condition that he forms a broad based coalition government. In Israel a party has to win at least 61 seats out of a total of 120 seats to form a government on their own, if not they have to rule in a coalition. There are a lot of parties that compete in Israel although over the years they have all veered farther to the right. A Netanyahu government will be trouble and Obama will have his hands full. Hopefully we will finally reassess our unconditional support for everything Israel does although I am not holding my breath.
3) Even though Tzipni Livni's Kadima party won the most seats (one more than Netanyahu's Likud) because they fell short of 61 seats they could not take power on their own and had to find a partner/s to form a coalition. Looks like they couldn't do it and the Likud party will form the coalition government. Because of the proliferation of parties the smaller parties that will form a government will be in a position to get support for some of their positions in return for their support. This is real democracy totally unlike what goes on in our wretched "two party system". Many voices are heard in a parliamentary system that would not be under our system. Someday maybe we as a country will wake up and flush the two party system down the toilet where it belongs and bring in a system whereby the two parties cannot take millions of people for granted because "they have nowhere else to go". I can dream can't I?
2) It looks like Benjamin Netanyahu has been selected to form Israel's next government. This decision comes after Avigdor Lieberman of the far-right Yisrael Beitenu party recommended him on the condition that he forms a broad based coalition government. In Israel a party has to win at least 61 seats out of a total of 120 seats to form a government on their own, if not they have to rule in a coalition. There are a lot of parties that compete in Israel although over the years they have all veered farther to the right. A Netanyahu government will be trouble and Obama will have his hands full. Hopefully we will finally reassess our unconditional support for everything Israel does although I am not holding my breath.
3) Even though Tzipni Livni's Kadima party won the most seats (one more than Netanyahu's Likud) because they fell short of 61 seats they could not take power on their own and had to find a partner/s to form a coalition. Looks like they couldn't do it and the Likud party will form the coalition government. Because of the proliferation of parties the smaller parties that will form a government will be in a position to get support for some of their positions in return for their support. This is real democracy totally unlike what goes on in our wretched "two party system". Many voices are heard in a parliamentary system that would not be under our system. Someday maybe we as a country will wake up and flush the two party system down the toilet where it belongs and bring in a system whereby the two parties cannot take millions of people for granted because "they have nowhere else to go". I can dream can't I?
Monday, February 16, 2009
When will we leave Iraq?
I have been reading and hearing a lot of talk recently about how we are going to be in Iraq a lot longer than people have been led to believe. Now this article appears in the Washington Post by Thomas Ricks a man who is pretty familiar with Iraq. Correct me if I am wrong but didn't Bush sign a Status of Forces Agreement government shortly before he left office saying that all our troops will be out by 2011. Why does Ricks and all the people he quotes in this article ignore this. It is not mentioned once. Read this from the article:
"I don't think the Iraq war is over, and I worry that there is more to come than any of us suspect. A smaller but long-term U.S. military presence in Iraq is probably the best we can hope for. The thought of having small numbers of U.S. troops dying for years to come in the country's deserts and palm groves isn't appealing, but it appears to be better than either being ejected or pulling out -- and letting the genocidal chips fall where they may."
Ricks goes on to quote others:
"Many worried that as the United States withdraws and its influence wanes, the Iraqi tendency toward violent solutions will increase. In September 2008, John McCreary, a veteran analyst for the Defense Intelligence Agency, predicted that the arrangement imposed by the U.S. government on Iraqi factions should worry us for several reasons. First, it produces what looks like peace -- but isn't. Second, one of the factions in such situations will invariably seek to break out of the arrangement. "Power sharing is always a prelude to violence," usually after the force imposing it withdraws, he maintained.
Many of those closest to the situation in Iraq expect a full-blown civil war to break out there in the coming years. "I don't think the Iraqi civil war has been fought yet," one colonel told me. Others were concerned that Iraq was drifting toward a military takeover. Counterinsurgency expert David Kilcullen worried that the classic conditions for a military coup were developing -- a venal political elite divorced from the population lives inside the Green Zone, while the Iraqi military outside the zone's walls grows both more capable and closer to the people, working with them and trying to address their concerns.
In addition, the American embrace of former insurgents has created many new local power centers in Iraq, but many of the faces of those who run them remain obscure. "We've made a lot of deals with shady guys," Col. Michael Galloucis, the Military Police commander in Baghdad, said in 2007, at the end of his tour. "It's working. But the key is, is it sustainable?"
Then this at near the end of the article:
"The quiet consensus emerging among many who have served in Iraq is that U.S. soldiers will probably be engaged in combat there until at least 2015 -- which would put us at about the midpoint of the conflict now."
Thomas Ricks is a smart guy with a lot of contacts so if he is writing about this there must be something to it. Many liberals/progressives mistakenly believe that Obama is pulling out all troops in 16 months. That is not what he said. He said he would pull out most combat troops but leave a residual force for counter-terrorism efforts and any other unspecified reasons. But all these military people Ricks is quoting and the Obama crowd seem to be ignoring the fact that Iraq signed an agreement and are under the impression that by 2011 it is bye-bye US. If that is not the case many people will be upset. In case any one noticed Iraq just had provincial elections and Malicki's party did very well. They ran as a nationalist party not a narrow sectarian party and even pulled in some Sunni votes. I would suspect one of the reasons he did so well was because of the SOFA agreement. If the US does not follow through on this agreement Malicki has an opportunity to unite the Sunnis and Shiites for the first time since our invasion. We have not faced a united opposition as of yet but that could happen if we ignore the SOFA. If this thing heats up again at the same time that we escalate Afghanistan and possibly deal with a destabilized Pakistan I don't see how we can afford it let alone how our military which is already stretched to the limit will be able to handle this added load. At some point in time we will have to come to some kind of an arrangement with Iran about Iraq and get out. It is the only way. This is a black hole that will only suck us in deeper and deeper.
"I don't think the Iraq war is over, and I worry that there is more to come than any of us suspect. A smaller but long-term U.S. military presence in Iraq is probably the best we can hope for. The thought of having small numbers of U.S. troops dying for years to come in the country's deserts and palm groves isn't appealing, but it appears to be better than either being ejected or pulling out -- and letting the genocidal chips fall where they may."
Ricks goes on to quote others:
"Many worried that as the United States withdraws and its influence wanes, the Iraqi tendency toward violent solutions will increase. In September 2008, John McCreary, a veteran analyst for the Defense Intelligence Agency, predicted that the arrangement imposed by the U.S. government on Iraqi factions should worry us for several reasons. First, it produces what looks like peace -- but isn't. Second, one of the factions in such situations will invariably seek to break out of the arrangement. "Power sharing is always a prelude to violence," usually after the force imposing it withdraws, he maintained.
Many of those closest to the situation in Iraq expect a full-blown civil war to break out there in the coming years. "I don't think the Iraqi civil war has been fought yet," one colonel told me. Others were concerned that Iraq was drifting toward a military takeover. Counterinsurgency expert David Kilcullen worried that the classic conditions for a military coup were developing -- a venal political elite divorced from the population lives inside the Green Zone, while the Iraqi military outside the zone's walls grows both more capable and closer to the people, working with them and trying to address their concerns.
In addition, the American embrace of former insurgents has created many new local power centers in Iraq, but many of the faces of those who run them remain obscure. "We've made a lot of deals with shady guys," Col. Michael Galloucis, the Military Police commander in Baghdad, said in 2007, at the end of his tour. "It's working. But the key is, is it sustainable?"
Then this at near the end of the article:
"The quiet consensus emerging among many who have served in Iraq is that U.S. soldiers will probably be engaged in combat there until at least 2015 -- which would put us at about the midpoint of the conflict now."
Thomas Ricks is a smart guy with a lot of contacts so if he is writing about this there must be something to it. Many liberals/progressives mistakenly believe that Obama is pulling out all troops in 16 months. That is not what he said. He said he would pull out most combat troops but leave a residual force for counter-terrorism efforts and any other unspecified reasons. But all these military people Ricks is quoting and the Obama crowd seem to be ignoring the fact that Iraq signed an agreement and are under the impression that by 2011 it is bye-bye US. If that is not the case many people will be upset. In case any one noticed Iraq just had provincial elections and Malicki's party did very well. They ran as a nationalist party not a narrow sectarian party and even pulled in some Sunni votes. I would suspect one of the reasons he did so well was because of the SOFA agreement. If the US does not follow through on this agreement Malicki has an opportunity to unite the Sunnis and Shiites for the first time since our invasion. We have not faced a united opposition as of yet but that could happen if we ignore the SOFA. If this thing heats up again at the same time that we escalate Afghanistan and possibly deal with a destabilized Pakistan I don't see how we can afford it let alone how our military which is already stretched to the limit will be able to handle this added load. At some point in time we will have to come to some kind of an arrangement with Iran about Iraq and get out. It is the only way. This is a black hole that will only suck us in deeper and deeper.
Sunday, February 15, 2009
That magic number 30
I referenced this in a previous post about how that magic number 30 keeps popping up whenever they tally the dead Al-Queda/Taliban as a result of one of our drone/military attacks in Afghanistan/Pakistan. I wish I would have been the one to point this out first but I wasn't. To give credit where credit is due it was the Moon of Alabama website. I went back to their archives and dug up the original post. It is amazing how often this number pops up! How do they know 30 died? How do they know they are really Al-Queda/Taliban? How do they know they are not just civilians? Of course to the neo-cons and most conservatives any Muslim is a potential terrorist and therefore the killings are a necessary part of "the long war". Next time you read a news account of the next US military strike and that magic number 30 pops up keep those questions in mind. This appeared in the Moon of Alabama web site on August 23, 2008:
Around the Hindu Kush, 30 is a Magic Number
... or so it seems ...
U.S.: 30 militants killed in west Afghanistan, AP, Aug 22, 2008KABUL, Afghanistan - U.S.-led troops attacked a compound where Taliban leaders were meeting and killed 30 militants, American and Afghan military officials said Friday, but the Interior Ministry said a large number of civilians died. The U.S. said it would investigate....The coalition said its troops called in airstrikes on the compound in the Shindand district of western Herat province Thursday...However, the Afghan Interior Ministry claimed U.S. coalition bombs killed 76 civilians, including 19 women and 50 children under the age of 15. The ministry called the bombing a "mistake."
... let's add 15 x '30 militants' killed to that toll ....
US coalition: 30 militants die in Afghan battle, AP, Aug 21, 2008KABUL, Afghanistan - U.S.-led coalition troops battled a group of militants in eastern Afghanistan, killing over 30 insurgents, while three NATO soldiers were killed in a roadside blast elsewhere, officials said Thursday.
The coalition troops used small arms and airstrikes during the raid in eastern Laghman province on Wednesday, killing more than 30 fighters, the coalition said. A cache of mortars and bomb-making material was also destroyed.
---
US and Afghan Troops Kill Dozens of Militants in Afghanistan, VOA News, Aug. 16The U.S.-led coalition Saturday said more than 30 militants were killed in three days of fierce fighting in Zamto Valley, in southern Kandahar province. The coalition said its troops along with Afghan forces called in airstrikes during the clashes that began Wednesday and ended Friday.
---
Pakistan army targets militants in northwest, AP, Aug 8, 2008KHAR, Pakistan---- At least 30 militants and seven Pakistani paramilitary troops have died in clashes near the Afghan border, where security forces pounded insurgent hideouts Friday with helicopter gunships and mortar fire, officials and residents said.
The offensive in the tribal region of Bajur came in the wake of a militant assault on an outpost manned by security forces Wednesday.
---
Taliban commander and 30 militants killed , Quqnoos, Feb 22, 2008AFGHAN troops have killed 30 Taliban militants in Helmand, according to the Ministry of Defence.
Taliban commander Mullah Abdul Bari and 29 of his men were killed yesterday in the districts of Musa Qala and Kajaki (Wednesday) during a five hour battle that involved ground soldiers and air strikes.
---
Militants release students and teachers taken hostage at Pakistan school, Guardian, Jan 28, 2008Last week, Pakistani forces killed up to 30 militants in clashes near the city of Peshawar, after militants seized four trucks carrying ammunition and other paramilitary supplies.
Security forces recently launched a ground and air assault against Baitullah Mehsud, the Taliban commander accused of orchestrating the assassination in December of the opposition leader, Benazir Bhutto.
---
Report: 30 militants killed in Swat , UPI, Nov 26, 2007Pakistani forces say they killed 30 militants in their latest offensive to regain control of the violence-racked Swat valley, Dawn reported Monday.
---
Forces Kill 30 Militants, Find Weapons Caches in Afghanistan, AFPS, Sep 9, 2007WASHINGTON, Sept. 9, 2007 – Afghan and coalition forces killed more than 30 suspected militants during an operation yesterday in Afghanistan’s Helmand province.
The combined force suspected targeted compounds, located in the Garmser district, were providing sanctuary to anti-coalition militants. Precision munitions were employed to destroy the buildings, which had fortified fighting positions and interlocking tunnels.
---
Two British soldiers, 45 insurgents killed in Afghan fighting, AP, Sep 5, 2007Taliban attacks killed two British soldiers and two Afghan police officers Wednesday in restive southern Afghanistan, while nearly 30 militants were killed elsewhere, authorities said.
---
U.S. Says Attacks Are Surging in Afghanistan , NYT, Jan 16, 2007Shortly before Mr. Gates arrived along the border, the Pakistani Army announced that it had launched an airstrike on a suspected militant camp in South Waziristan, killing 25 to 30 militants that it said were Al Qaeda members, according to The Associated Press, which quoted a Pakistani Army spokesman.
---
30 militants killed in S. Afghanistan., Xinhua, Jan 14, 2007Afghan and NATO forces killed 30 Taliban operatives in the troubled Helmand province in south Afghanistan on Saturday, provincial police chief Mohammad Nabi Mullahkhil said Sunday.
"In an operation launched by Afghan and NATO troops against insurgents in Kajaki district Saturday, 30 enemies were killed and 20 others were wounded," Mullahkhil told Xinhua.
---
Coalition predicts "significant fighting" in southern Afghanistan, 30 militants killed, AP, June 21, 2006Dateline: KABUL, Afghanistan Southern Afghanistan will witness "significant fighting" between U.S.-led coalition and Taliban forces for several months before NATO takes control of the region, the military said Wednesday.
The grim warning came a day after coalition and Afghan forces conducted raids in southern Helmand and Uruzgan provinces, killing 30 insurgents, Afghan and coalition forces said.
---
'Scores of Afghan Taleban killed' , BBC, June 10, 2006A statement by the US-led coalition said "more than 30" militants were killed in a clash with Afghan and Canadian forces in Arghandab district in Zabul on Monday.
---
Rumsfeld arrives in Kabul as 30 Taleban killed in Helmand, Times Online, July 11, 2006US-led forces hunting a Taleban commander have killed an estimated 30 Taleban militia in an overnight raid on a hide-out in southern Afghanistan, the US military said today.
The raid came shortly before Donald Rumsfeld, the US Defence Secretary, arrived on an unannounced visit to Kabul, where he expressed confidence that the Taleban would be defeated.
---
Up to 30 militants killed in Pakistan, CBC News, Mar 11, 2006Pakistani security forces backed by helicopter gunships have attacked a suspected hideout of Islamist militants in a tribal region near the Afghan border, killing up to 30 people.
The overnight attack in the North Waziristan tribal region was ordered after intelligence reports suggested that militants were gathered in a compound along with a huge cache of arms, ammunition and explosives.
---
Afghan, U.S. troops battle insurgents in Afghanistan, at least 19 dead, AP, Feb 3, 2006KANDAHAR, Afghanistan (AP) - Fierce fighting involving U.S. warplanes and Afghan troops in southern Afghanistan left at least 16 suspected Taliban rebels and three police dead, an official said Friday. ...A U.S. military spokesman, Lt. Col. Jerry O'Hara, said American forces, including A-10 war planes, responded to an initial attack on Afghan security forces by up to 30 militants.
Why did the marketing/propaganda buffoons chose 30 as the magic number?
Posted by b on August 23, 2008 at 12:11 AM Permalink Comments (19)
-->
Around the Hindu Kush, 30 is a Magic Number
... or so it seems ...
U.S.: 30 militants killed in west Afghanistan, AP, Aug 22, 2008KABUL, Afghanistan - U.S.-led troops attacked a compound where Taliban leaders were meeting and killed 30 militants, American and Afghan military officials said Friday, but the Interior Ministry said a large number of civilians died. The U.S. said it would investigate....The coalition said its troops called in airstrikes on the compound in the Shindand district of western Herat province Thursday...However, the Afghan Interior Ministry claimed U.S. coalition bombs killed 76 civilians, including 19 women and 50 children under the age of 15. The ministry called the bombing a "mistake."
... let's add 15 x '30 militants' killed to that toll ....
US coalition: 30 militants die in Afghan battle, AP, Aug 21, 2008KABUL, Afghanistan - U.S.-led coalition troops battled a group of militants in eastern Afghanistan, killing over 30 insurgents, while three NATO soldiers were killed in a roadside blast elsewhere, officials said Thursday.
The coalition troops used small arms and airstrikes during the raid in eastern Laghman province on Wednesday, killing more than 30 fighters, the coalition said. A cache of mortars and bomb-making material was also destroyed.
---
US and Afghan Troops Kill Dozens of Militants in Afghanistan, VOA News, Aug. 16The U.S.-led coalition Saturday said more than 30 militants were killed in three days of fierce fighting in Zamto Valley, in southern Kandahar province. The coalition said its troops along with Afghan forces called in airstrikes during the clashes that began Wednesday and ended Friday.
---
Pakistan army targets militants in northwest, AP, Aug 8, 2008KHAR, Pakistan---- At least 30 militants and seven Pakistani paramilitary troops have died in clashes near the Afghan border, where security forces pounded insurgent hideouts Friday with helicopter gunships and mortar fire, officials and residents said.
The offensive in the tribal region of Bajur came in the wake of a militant assault on an outpost manned by security forces Wednesday.
---
Taliban commander and 30 militants killed , Quqnoos, Feb 22, 2008AFGHAN troops have killed 30 Taliban militants in Helmand, according to the Ministry of Defence.
Taliban commander Mullah Abdul Bari and 29 of his men were killed yesterday in the districts of Musa Qala and Kajaki (Wednesday) during a five hour battle that involved ground soldiers and air strikes.
---
Militants release students and teachers taken hostage at Pakistan school, Guardian, Jan 28, 2008Last week, Pakistani forces killed up to 30 militants in clashes near the city of Peshawar, after militants seized four trucks carrying ammunition and other paramilitary supplies.
Security forces recently launched a ground and air assault against Baitullah Mehsud, the Taliban commander accused of orchestrating the assassination in December of the opposition leader, Benazir Bhutto.
---
Report: 30 militants killed in Swat , UPI, Nov 26, 2007Pakistani forces say they killed 30 militants in their latest offensive to regain control of the violence-racked Swat valley, Dawn reported Monday.
---
Forces Kill 30 Militants, Find Weapons Caches in Afghanistan, AFPS, Sep 9, 2007WASHINGTON, Sept. 9, 2007 – Afghan and coalition forces killed more than 30 suspected militants during an operation yesterday in Afghanistan’s Helmand province.
The combined force suspected targeted compounds, located in the Garmser district, were providing sanctuary to anti-coalition militants. Precision munitions were employed to destroy the buildings, which had fortified fighting positions and interlocking tunnels.
---
Two British soldiers, 45 insurgents killed in Afghan fighting, AP, Sep 5, 2007Taliban attacks killed two British soldiers and two Afghan police officers Wednesday in restive southern Afghanistan, while nearly 30 militants were killed elsewhere, authorities said.
---
U.S. Says Attacks Are Surging in Afghanistan , NYT, Jan 16, 2007Shortly before Mr. Gates arrived along the border, the Pakistani Army announced that it had launched an airstrike on a suspected militant camp in South Waziristan, killing 25 to 30 militants that it said were Al Qaeda members, according to The Associated Press, which quoted a Pakistani Army spokesman.
---
30 militants killed in S. Afghanistan., Xinhua, Jan 14, 2007Afghan and NATO forces killed 30 Taliban operatives in the troubled Helmand province in south Afghanistan on Saturday, provincial police chief Mohammad Nabi Mullahkhil said Sunday.
"In an operation launched by Afghan and NATO troops against insurgents in Kajaki district Saturday, 30 enemies were killed and 20 others were wounded," Mullahkhil told Xinhua.
---
Coalition predicts "significant fighting" in southern Afghanistan, 30 militants killed, AP, June 21, 2006Dateline: KABUL, Afghanistan Southern Afghanistan will witness "significant fighting" between U.S.-led coalition and Taliban forces for several months before NATO takes control of the region, the military said Wednesday.
The grim warning came a day after coalition and Afghan forces conducted raids in southern Helmand and Uruzgan provinces, killing 30 insurgents, Afghan and coalition forces said.
---
'Scores of Afghan Taleban killed' , BBC, June 10, 2006A statement by the US-led coalition said "more than 30" militants were killed in a clash with Afghan and Canadian forces in Arghandab district in Zabul on Monday.
---
Rumsfeld arrives in Kabul as 30 Taleban killed in Helmand, Times Online, July 11, 2006US-led forces hunting a Taleban commander have killed an estimated 30 Taleban militia in an overnight raid on a hide-out in southern Afghanistan, the US military said today.
The raid came shortly before Donald Rumsfeld, the US Defence Secretary, arrived on an unannounced visit to Kabul, where he expressed confidence that the Taleban would be defeated.
---
Up to 30 militants killed in Pakistan, CBC News, Mar 11, 2006Pakistani security forces backed by helicopter gunships have attacked a suspected hideout of Islamist militants in a tribal region near the Afghan border, killing up to 30 people.
The overnight attack in the North Waziristan tribal region was ordered after intelligence reports suggested that militants were gathered in a compound along with a huge cache of arms, ammunition and explosives.
---
Afghan, U.S. troops battle insurgents in Afghanistan, at least 19 dead, AP, Feb 3, 2006KANDAHAR, Afghanistan (AP) - Fierce fighting involving U.S. warplanes and Afghan troops in southern Afghanistan left at least 16 suspected Taliban rebels and three police dead, an official said Friday. ...A U.S. military spokesman, Lt. Col. Jerry O'Hara, said American forces, including A-10 war planes, responded to an initial attack on Afghan security forces by up to 30 militants.
Why did the marketing/propaganda buffoons chose 30 as the magic number?
Posted by b on August 23, 2008 at 12:11 AM Permalink Comments (19)
-->
Saturday, February 14, 2009
Feinstein, Pakistan and drones
I have commented in previous posts about the dangerous game we are playing in Pakistan with our escalation of drone attacks on the Pakistani side of the border. According to the New York Times our drones have struck again killing the usual 30 Al-Queda and Taliban militants (every time our drones hit Taliban/Al-Queda targets it seems like that magic number of 30 is always trotted out- Moon of Alabama web site first pointed this out and damn if that ain't the truth!).
"Two missiles fired from American drone aircraft killed more than 30 people, including Qaeda and Taliban fighters, near the Pakistani border with Afghanistan on Saturday, according to a Pakistani intelligence official and residents of the area.
The missiles struck three compounds, including one where the leader of the Pakistani Taliban, Baitullah Mehsud, and foreign and local fighters loyal to him sometimes gather, the official and residents said.
Mr. Mehsud, one of the most feared leaders in Pakistan’s lawless tribal areas, was not among those killed, according to the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the press."
This drone attack comes right on the heels of Sen. Diane Feinstein (D-Ca) blurting out in a senate hearing that these drone attacks operate out of a Pakistani base. How dumb are these people in Congress! Sometimes I think that we are trying to destabilize on Pakistan on purpose so we can break up the country and seize their nukes. This will inflame public opinion in Pakistan where an overwhelming majority of the population opposes these attacks. Obama seems committed to escalating the war in Afghanistan and Pakistan. I think this is a huge mistake. Regardless of my opinion the least Obama can do is to tell Feinstein and anybody else in the Democratic Party who feels the need to opine about Pakistan to refrain from doing so. Or in layman's terms--shut the f**k up!!!
"Two missiles fired from American drone aircraft killed more than 30 people, including Qaeda and Taliban fighters, near the Pakistani border with Afghanistan on Saturday, according to a Pakistani intelligence official and residents of the area.
The missiles struck three compounds, including one where the leader of the Pakistani Taliban, Baitullah Mehsud, and foreign and local fighters loyal to him sometimes gather, the official and residents said.
Mr. Mehsud, one of the most feared leaders in Pakistan’s lawless tribal areas, was not among those killed, according to the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to the press."
This drone attack comes right on the heels of Sen. Diane Feinstein (D-Ca) blurting out in a senate hearing that these drone attacks operate out of a Pakistani base. How dumb are these people in Congress! Sometimes I think that we are trying to destabilize on Pakistan on purpose so we can break up the country and seize their nukes. This will inflame public opinion in Pakistan where an overwhelming majority of the population opposes these attacks. Obama seems committed to escalating the war in Afghanistan and Pakistan. I think this is a huge mistake. Regardless of my opinion the least Obama can do is to tell Feinstein and anybody else in the Democratic Party who feels the need to opine about Pakistan to refrain from doing so. Or in layman's terms--shut the f**k up!!!
Letter from Alan Dershowitz
Professor Alan Dershowitz sent this letter to the New York Times in response to an op-ed entitled "Why the Muslim world can't hear Obama". Courtesy of the Angry Arab website.
Re “Why the Muslim World Can’t Hear Obama” (Op-Ed, Feb. 8):
Alaa Al Aswany says that the only way the Arab street, particularly in Cairo, will hear Barack Obama is if our new president recognizes “the right of people in an occupied territory to resist military occupation.”
But it was precisely when Israel ended its occupation of Gaza that Hamas increased its rocket attacks against Israeli civilians.
Did Dr. Al Aswany forget that Egypt occupied Gaza between 1949 and 1967? I doubt that the Cairo street would have tolerated rocket attacks from occupied Gaza against Egyptian civilian targets.
If the price of the Arab street hearing President Obama is to accept terrorism against civilians as a “right” of formerly occupied people, then it is too high a price to pay.
In America, we have a word for what Israel did to prevent Hamas from playing Russian roulette with the lives of its children. We call it self-defense, as Mr. Obama recognized when he, then a presidential candidate, stood in front of Hamas rockets in Sderot and said: “If somebody was sending rockets into my house where my two daughters sleep at night, I’m going to do everything in my power to stop that. And I would expect Israelis to do the same thing.”
Alan Dershowitz Cambridge, Mass., Feb. 8, 2009
The writer is a professor of law at Harvard University.
There are so many holes in Dershowitz's argument it would take too long to respond to. This response from another reader sums it up quite nicely and gets right to the heart of the issue.
To the Editor:
If President Obama wants to be heard by Muslims, he must strip away the politics and honestly answer the question: “What’s the moral justification for the dispossession of the Palestinians from Palestine by the Israelis that has gone on systematically since 1948?” And then he must act on it.
Lowell Johnston New York, Feb. 8, 2009
Re “Why the Muslim World Can’t Hear Obama” (Op-Ed, Feb. 8):
Alaa Al Aswany says that the only way the Arab street, particularly in Cairo, will hear Barack Obama is if our new president recognizes “the right of people in an occupied territory to resist military occupation.”
But it was precisely when Israel ended its occupation of Gaza that Hamas increased its rocket attacks against Israeli civilians.
Did Dr. Al Aswany forget that Egypt occupied Gaza between 1949 and 1967? I doubt that the Cairo street would have tolerated rocket attacks from occupied Gaza against Egyptian civilian targets.
If the price of the Arab street hearing President Obama is to accept terrorism against civilians as a “right” of formerly occupied people, then it is too high a price to pay.
In America, we have a word for what Israel did to prevent Hamas from playing Russian roulette with the lives of its children. We call it self-defense, as Mr. Obama recognized when he, then a presidential candidate, stood in front of Hamas rockets in Sderot and said: “If somebody was sending rockets into my house where my two daughters sleep at night, I’m going to do everything in my power to stop that. And I would expect Israelis to do the same thing.”
Alan Dershowitz Cambridge, Mass., Feb. 8, 2009
The writer is a professor of law at Harvard University.
There are so many holes in Dershowitz's argument it would take too long to respond to. This response from another reader sums it up quite nicely and gets right to the heart of the issue.
To the Editor:
If President Obama wants to be heard by Muslims, he must strip away the politics and honestly answer the question: “What’s the moral justification for the dispossession of the Palestinians from Palestine by the Israelis that has gone on systematically since 1948?” And then he must act on it.
Lowell Johnston New York, Feb. 8, 2009
Friday, February 13, 2009
Dahr Jamail strikes again!!!
Dhar Jamail has written an excellent article that is in today's Asia Times and also in Tom Dispatch about what is really going on in Fallujah and Anbar Province. Read the article. It is well worth your time. I will highlight what I find to be some of the more interesting paragraphs.
"Driving through Fallujah, once the most rebellious Sunni city in this country, I saw little evidence of any kind of reconstruction underway. At least 70% of that city's structures were destroyed during massive U.S. military assaults in April, and again in November 2004, and more than four years later, in the "new Iraq," the city continues to languish. The shells of buildings pulverized by U.S. bombs, artillery, or mortar fire back then still line Fallujah's main street, or rather, what's left of it. As one of the few visible signs of reconstruction in the city, that street -- largely destroyed during the November 2004 siege -- is slowly being torn up in order to be repaved. Unemployment is rampant here, the infrastructure remains largely in ruins, and tens of thousands of residents who fled in 2004 are still refugees. How could it be otherwise, given the amount of effort that went into its destruction and not, subsequently, into rebuilding it? It's a place where a resident must still carry around a U.S.-issued personal biometric ID card, which must also be shown any time you enter or exit the city if you are local. Such a card can only be obtained after U.S. military personnel have scanned your retinas and taken your fingerprints.
The trauma from the 2004 attacks remains visible everywhere. Given the countless still-bullet-pocked walls of restaurants, stores, and homes, it is impossible to view the city from any vantage point, or look in any direction, without observing signs of those sieges. "
"In late 2006, roughly speaking, months before George W. Bush's "surge" strategy sent 30,000 more American troops into Baghdad and surrounding areas, the U.S. began making down-payments on the cooperation of local al-Anbar tribal sheiks and started funding and arming the Sunni militias they were then organizing. As a result, the number of insurgent attacks quickly began to drop, and so the Americans widened the program to other provinces. It grew to include nearly 100,000 Sunni fighters, most of whom were paid $300 a month -- a sizeable income in a devastated city like Fallujah with sky-high unemployment rates.
The program was soon hailed as a success, and the groups were dubbed anything from The Awakening, to Sons of Iraq (al-Sahwa), or as the U.S. military preferred for a time, Concerned Local Citizens. Whatever the name, most of their members were former resistance fighters; many were also former members of Saddam Hussein's Baath Party; and significant numbers were -- and, of course, remain -- both.
There was an even deeper history to the path the Americans finally chose in order to tame the insurgency and the home-grown al-Qaeda-in-Iraq (AQI) groups that had spun off from it. In an interview with David Enders and Richard Rowley, colleagues of mine, in the summer of 2007, Sheikh Aifan laid this out quite clearly: "Saddam Hussein supported some tribes and some sheiks. Some of those sheiks, he used their power in their areas. The first support came by money. He supported them by big projects, by money, and he made them very rich. So you see, they can deal with anyone in Iraq with money. The Americans, they made the same plan with all the sheiks."
The main goal of the Americans was never the reconstruction of devastated al-Anbar Province. That was just the label given to a project whose objective -- from the U.S. point of view -- was to save American lives and to tamp down violence in Iraq before the U.S. presidential election of 2008.
Today, leading sheiks like Aifan will tell you that they are in "the construction business." That's a polite phrase for what they're doing, and the rubric under which a lot of the payouts take place (however modest actual reconstruction work might be). Think of it this way: Every dealer needs a front man. The U.S. bought the sheiks off and it was to their immediate advantage to be bought off. They regained a kind of power that had been seeping away, while all the money and arms allowed them to put real muscle into recruiting people in the tribes they controlled and into building the Awakening Movement.
The reasons -- and they are indeed plural -- why the tribal leaders were so willing to collaborate with the occupiers of their country are, at least in retrospect, relatively clear. Those in al-Anbar who had once supported, and had been supported by, Saddam Hussein, and then had initially supported the resistance became far keener to work with occupation forces as they saw their power eroded by al-Qaeda-in-Iraq.
AQI proved a threat to the sheiks, many of whom had initially worked directly with it, when it began to try to embed its own fierce, extremist Sunni ideology in the region -- and perhaps even more significantly, when it began to infringe on the cross-border smuggling trade that had kept many tribal sheiks rich. As AQI grew larger and threatened their financial and power bases, they had little choice but to throw in their lot with the Americans.
As a result, these men obtained backing for their private militias, renamed Awakening groups, and in addition, signed "construction" contracts with the Americans who put millions of dollars in their pockets, even if not always into actual construction sites. As early as April 2006, the Rand Corporation released a report, "The Anbar Awakening," identifying America's potential new allies as a group of sheiks who used to control smuggling rings and organized crime in the area.
One striking example was Sheik Abdul Sattar Abu Risha, who founded the first Awakening groups in al-Anbar and later led the entire movement until he was assassinated in 2007, shortly after he met with President Bush. It was well known in the region that Abu Risha was primarily a smuggler defending his business operations by joining the Americans.
Not surprisingly, given the lucrative nature of the cooperative relationship that developed, whenever an Awakening group sheik is assassinated, another is always there to take his place. Abu Risha was, in fact, promptly replaced as "president" of the Anbar Awakening by his brother Sheik Ahmad Abu Risha, also now in the "construction business."
"Once the visit was concluded, we headed back for Fallujah and had a late night snack at Sheik Aifan's place before settling in for a night's sleep as his guest. His daughter, a shy girl of perhaps seven years of age, sat beside him as we ate. At one point, he suddenly peeled a crisp U.S. $100 bill off a wad of bills that would have stunned any movie mafia boss, smiled benevolently, and added that she shouldn't let her mother know about the gift.
The sheik, of course, had $100 bills to spare, as millions of dollars for so-called construction projects have been funneled his way. It's how he pays the roughly 900 men that he estimates make up his private militia. For all of this he can thank the U.S. military, which delivers regular installments of money -- shrink-wrapped bricks of those $100 bills -- because post-invasion Iraq remains largely a cash-only economy.
Before our journey to Ramadi, a patrol of U.S. Marines had paid Sheik Aifan a visit. As the soldiers climbed the stairs to his meeting room, they took clips of ammunition away from the sheik's security team, and kept them until they left his compound. It was a gentle reminder of who still has the final say in this part of Iraq and of just how far the trust extends between these partners of necessity. Sheikh Aifan offered a warm greeting to the Marine commander, and the two men sat down to talk. Each was visibly distracted, anxiously looking around. Sheik Aifan toyed anxiously with his prayer beads, wiggling his legs like a nervous schoolchild, while telling his guest how well everything was going. The meeting was repeatedly interrupted by cell phone calls for the sheik who, at one point, left briefly to welcome another visitor.
After the meeting, platters of food were brought in and everyone feasted. As they were leaving, I asked one of the Marines if meetings like these happened regularly. "This is our job," he replied. "We visit sheiks. And this guy is like John Gotti." (Gotti, labeled "the Teflon Don," ran the Gambino crime family in New York City before being jailed.) "
What is interesting here is that the so called success of the "surge" has more to do with factors that had absolutely nothing to do with the increase in American troops and more to do with the fact that the Sunnis and the tribal leaders that had joined in the insurgency started to feel themselves squeezed. Although the they had checkmated the worlds strongest military, (no small achievement), they found themselves unable to hold off the Shiites who were not only winning the battle of Baghdad but because of their numerical superiority taking back other parts of the country at the same time that the Al-Queda in Iraq groups were starting to implement a puritanical extreme version of the Sunni religion that did not appeal to the tribes but also began to cut in on their smuggling business that had nurtured the tribal way of live for generations. The Americans were the only way out. So they turned on the Sunni extremists and now it is hard to find any Al-Queda types in Anbar province while at the same time they stopped attacking Americans. As this was going on Iran reigned in Moqtada al-Sadrs movement, the battle for Baghdad had been won by the Shiites and hence the "success" of the surge. It was not the increase of American troops that caused the decline in American deaths. It was these other factors. Yet today most Americans are under the illusion that the surge in American troops is responsible for the relative calm in Iraq. What happens when we stop paying off these tribal leaders is any ones guess.
"Driving through Fallujah, once the most rebellious Sunni city in this country, I saw little evidence of any kind of reconstruction underway. At least 70% of that city's structures were destroyed during massive U.S. military assaults in April, and again in November 2004, and more than four years later, in the "new Iraq," the city continues to languish. The shells of buildings pulverized by U.S. bombs, artillery, or mortar fire back then still line Fallujah's main street, or rather, what's left of it. As one of the few visible signs of reconstruction in the city, that street -- largely destroyed during the November 2004 siege -- is slowly being torn up in order to be repaved. Unemployment is rampant here, the infrastructure remains largely in ruins, and tens of thousands of residents who fled in 2004 are still refugees. How could it be otherwise, given the amount of effort that went into its destruction and not, subsequently, into rebuilding it? It's a place where a resident must still carry around a U.S.-issued personal biometric ID card, which must also be shown any time you enter or exit the city if you are local. Such a card can only be obtained after U.S. military personnel have scanned your retinas and taken your fingerprints.
The trauma from the 2004 attacks remains visible everywhere. Given the countless still-bullet-pocked walls of restaurants, stores, and homes, it is impossible to view the city from any vantage point, or look in any direction, without observing signs of those sieges. "
"In late 2006, roughly speaking, months before George W. Bush's "surge" strategy sent 30,000 more American troops into Baghdad and surrounding areas, the U.S. began making down-payments on the cooperation of local al-Anbar tribal sheiks and started funding and arming the Sunni militias they were then organizing. As a result, the number of insurgent attacks quickly began to drop, and so the Americans widened the program to other provinces. It grew to include nearly 100,000 Sunni fighters, most of whom were paid $300 a month -- a sizeable income in a devastated city like Fallujah with sky-high unemployment rates.
The program was soon hailed as a success, and the groups were dubbed anything from The Awakening, to Sons of Iraq (al-Sahwa), or as the U.S. military preferred for a time, Concerned Local Citizens. Whatever the name, most of their members were former resistance fighters; many were also former members of Saddam Hussein's Baath Party; and significant numbers were -- and, of course, remain -- both.
There was an even deeper history to the path the Americans finally chose in order to tame the insurgency and the home-grown al-Qaeda-in-Iraq (AQI) groups that had spun off from it. In an interview with David Enders and Richard Rowley, colleagues of mine, in the summer of 2007, Sheikh Aifan laid this out quite clearly: "Saddam Hussein supported some tribes and some sheiks. Some of those sheiks, he used their power in their areas. The first support came by money. He supported them by big projects, by money, and he made them very rich. So you see, they can deal with anyone in Iraq with money. The Americans, they made the same plan with all the sheiks."
The main goal of the Americans was never the reconstruction of devastated al-Anbar Province. That was just the label given to a project whose objective -- from the U.S. point of view -- was to save American lives and to tamp down violence in Iraq before the U.S. presidential election of 2008.
Today, leading sheiks like Aifan will tell you that they are in "the construction business." That's a polite phrase for what they're doing, and the rubric under which a lot of the payouts take place (however modest actual reconstruction work might be). Think of it this way: Every dealer needs a front man. The U.S. bought the sheiks off and it was to their immediate advantage to be bought off. They regained a kind of power that had been seeping away, while all the money and arms allowed them to put real muscle into recruiting people in the tribes they controlled and into building the Awakening Movement.
The reasons -- and they are indeed plural -- why the tribal leaders were so willing to collaborate with the occupiers of their country are, at least in retrospect, relatively clear. Those in al-Anbar who had once supported, and had been supported by, Saddam Hussein, and then had initially supported the resistance became far keener to work with occupation forces as they saw their power eroded by al-Qaeda-in-Iraq.
AQI proved a threat to the sheiks, many of whom had initially worked directly with it, when it began to try to embed its own fierce, extremist Sunni ideology in the region -- and perhaps even more significantly, when it began to infringe on the cross-border smuggling trade that had kept many tribal sheiks rich. As AQI grew larger and threatened their financial and power bases, they had little choice but to throw in their lot with the Americans.
As a result, these men obtained backing for their private militias, renamed Awakening groups, and in addition, signed "construction" contracts with the Americans who put millions of dollars in their pockets, even if not always into actual construction sites. As early as April 2006, the Rand Corporation released a report, "The Anbar Awakening," identifying America's potential new allies as a group of sheiks who used to control smuggling rings and organized crime in the area.
One striking example was Sheik Abdul Sattar Abu Risha, who founded the first Awakening groups in al-Anbar and later led the entire movement until he was assassinated in 2007, shortly after he met with President Bush. It was well known in the region that Abu Risha was primarily a smuggler defending his business operations by joining the Americans.
Not surprisingly, given the lucrative nature of the cooperative relationship that developed, whenever an Awakening group sheik is assassinated, another is always there to take his place. Abu Risha was, in fact, promptly replaced as "president" of the Anbar Awakening by his brother Sheik Ahmad Abu Risha, also now in the "construction business."
"Once the visit was concluded, we headed back for Fallujah and had a late night snack at Sheik Aifan's place before settling in for a night's sleep as his guest. His daughter, a shy girl of perhaps seven years of age, sat beside him as we ate. At one point, he suddenly peeled a crisp U.S. $100 bill off a wad of bills that would have stunned any movie mafia boss, smiled benevolently, and added that she shouldn't let her mother know about the gift.
The sheik, of course, had $100 bills to spare, as millions of dollars for so-called construction projects have been funneled his way. It's how he pays the roughly 900 men that he estimates make up his private militia. For all of this he can thank the U.S. military, which delivers regular installments of money -- shrink-wrapped bricks of those $100 bills -- because post-invasion Iraq remains largely a cash-only economy.
Before our journey to Ramadi, a patrol of U.S. Marines had paid Sheik Aifan a visit. As the soldiers climbed the stairs to his meeting room, they took clips of ammunition away from the sheik's security team, and kept them until they left his compound. It was a gentle reminder of who still has the final say in this part of Iraq and of just how far the trust extends between these partners of necessity. Sheikh Aifan offered a warm greeting to the Marine commander, and the two men sat down to talk. Each was visibly distracted, anxiously looking around. Sheik Aifan toyed anxiously with his prayer beads, wiggling his legs like a nervous schoolchild, while telling his guest how well everything was going. The meeting was repeatedly interrupted by cell phone calls for the sheik who, at one point, left briefly to welcome another visitor.
After the meeting, platters of food were brought in and everyone feasted. As they were leaving, I asked one of the Marines if meetings like these happened regularly. "This is our job," he replied. "We visit sheiks. And this guy is like John Gotti." (Gotti, labeled "the Teflon Don," ran the Gambino crime family in New York City before being jailed.) "
What is interesting here is that the so called success of the "surge" has more to do with factors that had absolutely nothing to do with the increase in American troops and more to do with the fact that the Sunnis and the tribal leaders that had joined in the insurgency started to feel themselves squeezed. Although the they had checkmated the worlds strongest military, (no small achievement), they found themselves unable to hold off the Shiites who were not only winning the battle of Baghdad but because of their numerical superiority taking back other parts of the country at the same time that the Al-Queda in Iraq groups were starting to implement a puritanical extreme version of the Sunni religion that did not appeal to the tribes but also began to cut in on their smuggling business that had nurtured the tribal way of live for generations. The Americans were the only way out. So they turned on the Sunni extremists and now it is hard to find any Al-Queda types in Anbar province while at the same time they stopped attacking Americans. As this was going on Iran reigned in Moqtada al-Sadrs movement, the battle for Baghdad had been won by the Shiites and hence the "success" of the surge. It was not the increase of American troops that caused the decline in American deaths. It was these other factors. Yet today most Americans are under the illusion that the surge in American troops is responsible for the relative calm in Iraq. What happens when we stop paying off these tribal leaders is any ones guess.
Thursday, February 12, 2009
Another wonderful example of privatization
If you live in Chicago like I do tomorrow is the day that the new parking meter rates go into effect. As a result of Mayor Daley 's privatization of parking revenue rates will quadruple from .25 to a $1.00 for an hour in most of Chicago and up to $3.50 downtown! The lease that Daley signed gave him $1.15 billion upfront for a 75 year lease. A 75 year lease! For those of us who use our cars a lot and are forced to use the meters this is outrageous and yet I have not heard many people complain. Yet. I don't know if it is possible to terminate this deal but some push back would be welcome. Isn't there anybody out there that can challenge Daley? Hell- as long as he/she wasn't a right wing cultural conservative nut job I would even support a Republican! Daley must go.
The return of "Super-K"
This from the Asia Times concerning new supply routes:
"Russian connection: The Obama administration went the extra mile to achieve this task by unofficially using the services of veteran Henry Kissinger, a former US national security advisor and secretary of state, to deal with Russia. Kissinger has been dealing with Moscow on START (Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty) negotiations as the accord expires in December this year. On the sidelines of this past weekend's 45th Munich Security Conference, Kissinger was instrumental in making a deal with Russia under which the most Russian-influenced Central Asian republic, Kazakhstan, agreed to refine and supply 100% of the oil needed for NATO in Afghanistan. Currently, 90% of the oil is supplied by Pakistani refineries, with 5% coming from Azerbaijan and the rest via other Central Asian sates. Russia has also tacitly agreed to allow NATO's military supplies to pass through its territory as routes through Pakistan are being severely disrupted. In return, Moscow would expect NATO expansion into Europe to stop and that other defense-related issues in Europe would take into consideration Russian demands."
Shades of the glory days of Nixon-Kissinger detente Henry the "K' steps into the phone booth and puts on his cape and flies to Russia to enlist Russian assistance in an Afghan war that is quickly going south. The irony of the United States asking Russia for help on Afghanistan is seldom commented on. The supply routes through Russian territory that Kissinger is trying to arrange will cost a bundle. Because of the mess in Pakistan if we want to escalate this war we will need to use supply routes that will take longer to get to their destination and will cost a lot more. They will also involve dealing with countries that do not really like us. I have commented on this before but it needs to pointed out again and again. This will come at a price. While Dmitri Medvedev may be the current leader of Russia I have no doubt that Putin still runs the show and he is a very shrewd geopolitical poker player. Russian help will come at a price.
Also from the same article: (By the intrepid and fearless Syed Saleem Shahzad )
"On the battlefields in Pakistan and Afghanistan, meanwhile, plans are afoot to launch the strongest offensive yet against militants. This could begin once Pakistani army chief General Ashfaq Parvez Kiani returns to Pakistan from the United States where he will discuss in detail the dynamics of the militancy and enhanced cooperation between Islamabad and Washington. Holbrooke has already met with the leadership of the Pakistan Muslim League of Nawaz Sharif and is expected to persuade Sharif from supporting a potentially politically destabilizing lawyers' movement in March against the government. Pakistan is continuing its efforts to curtail militants in Khyber Agency, where they are causing havoc with the bulk of the NATO supplies that pass through the area on the way to Afghanistan. The next plan is to target the Taliban in Mohmand Agency, Bajaur Agency and the Swat Valley, as well as in North Waziristan and the South Waziristan, which serve as vital bases for the Taliban's efforts in Afghanistan. In recent weeks, the Pakistani Taliban have stepped up attacks on Pakistani cities as advance warning to the Pakistani security apparatus not to implement any joint US-Pakistan operations against the Taliban and al-Qaeda. These are expected to reach deep inside Pakistani territory. In this vicious cycle, new responses could emerge in coming days, such as attacks in Islamabad, where security has been tightened to unprecedented levels. Such a development in the capital of the most important non-NATO ally would be devastating"
I have said it before and I will say it again. We are playing a very dangerous game here. By taking the battle to the tribal areas in the hope of destroying the Talibans sanctuaries and the remnants of Al-Queda we are setting the stage for the destabilization of Pakistan. This will make Iraq seem like a picnic. Not only does Pakistan have nuclear weapons but a destabilized Pakistan could draw China in who will not sit by and allow Pakistan to fail. China depends on Pakistan to tie up their potentail rival India and will not look kindly if that buffer is removed. Other regional powers like Iran, India and Russia have their own agendas. This is a train wreck waiting to happen. With India and Pakistan nuclear powers the consequences of this could be horrific. One other item in Shazads report struck my attention. According to the article Holbrooke met with Nawaz Sharif to get him to drop his support for the lawyers movement against the government because this could destabilize the government. So just like the Bush administration before it the Obama administartion will join in a long line of US administrations that look the other way to Pakistani democracy. This is arguably the main problem in Pakistan and is responsible for the mess we are in today. By coddling these military dictators and slamming the door on legitimate democratic movements we have increased the hatred of the Pakistani people toward us. The lawyers movement was extremely popular and drew huge crowds that eventually brought down Musharraf. As Tariq Ali points out in his book "The Duel" the Red Mosque incident happened at around the same time as the lawyers movement and contrary to the average Americans perception of Pakistan as a country of crazy jihadi wannabees huge crowds came out in support of Iftikar Chaudry while the crowds in support of the extremist followers of the Red Mosque killings was minuscule. In the North West Frontier Province the Awami National Party won the latest elections, a secular party in a region that is thought to be all jihadi all the time. The people would like real democracy and the fact that the United States has prevented it repeatedly explains the dislike and suspicion of American intentions. By pursuing this Afghan escalation we may very well bring about the thing we fear most. A radical Islamic Pakistan. I've said it before and I will say it again. The only way out is a negotiated settlement in Afghanistan involving the Taliban and all the regional powers including Iran. Any other option is fraught with danger.
"Russian connection: The Obama administration went the extra mile to achieve this task by unofficially using the services of veteran Henry Kissinger, a former US national security advisor and secretary of state, to deal with Russia. Kissinger has been dealing with Moscow on START (Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty) negotiations as the accord expires in December this year. On the sidelines of this past weekend's 45th Munich Security Conference, Kissinger was instrumental in making a deal with Russia under which the most Russian-influenced Central Asian republic, Kazakhstan, agreed to refine and supply 100% of the oil needed for NATO in Afghanistan. Currently, 90% of the oil is supplied by Pakistani refineries, with 5% coming from Azerbaijan and the rest via other Central Asian sates. Russia has also tacitly agreed to allow NATO's military supplies to pass through its territory as routes through Pakistan are being severely disrupted. In return, Moscow would expect NATO expansion into Europe to stop and that other defense-related issues in Europe would take into consideration Russian demands."
Shades of the glory days of Nixon-Kissinger detente Henry the "K' steps into the phone booth and puts on his cape and flies to Russia to enlist Russian assistance in an Afghan war that is quickly going south. The irony of the United States asking Russia for help on Afghanistan is seldom commented on. The supply routes through Russian territory that Kissinger is trying to arrange will cost a bundle. Because of the mess in Pakistan if we want to escalate this war we will need to use supply routes that will take longer to get to their destination and will cost a lot more. They will also involve dealing with countries that do not really like us. I have commented on this before but it needs to pointed out again and again. This will come at a price. While Dmitri Medvedev may be the current leader of Russia I have no doubt that Putin still runs the show and he is a very shrewd geopolitical poker player. Russian help will come at a price.
Also from the same article: (By the intrepid and fearless Syed Saleem Shahzad )
"On the battlefields in Pakistan and Afghanistan, meanwhile, plans are afoot to launch the strongest offensive yet against militants. This could begin once Pakistani army chief General Ashfaq Parvez Kiani returns to Pakistan from the United States where he will discuss in detail the dynamics of the militancy and enhanced cooperation between Islamabad and Washington. Holbrooke has already met with the leadership of the Pakistan Muslim League of Nawaz Sharif and is expected to persuade Sharif from supporting a potentially politically destabilizing lawyers' movement in March against the government. Pakistan is continuing its efforts to curtail militants in Khyber Agency, where they are causing havoc with the bulk of the NATO supplies that pass through the area on the way to Afghanistan. The next plan is to target the Taliban in Mohmand Agency, Bajaur Agency and the Swat Valley, as well as in North Waziristan and the South Waziristan, which serve as vital bases for the Taliban's efforts in Afghanistan. In recent weeks, the Pakistani Taliban have stepped up attacks on Pakistani cities as advance warning to the Pakistani security apparatus not to implement any joint US-Pakistan operations against the Taliban and al-Qaeda. These are expected to reach deep inside Pakistani territory. In this vicious cycle, new responses could emerge in coming days, such as attacks in Islamabad, where security has been tightened to unprecedented levels. Such a development in the capital of the most important non-NATO ally would be devastating"
I have said it before and I will say it again. We are playing a very dangerous game here. By taking the battle to the tribal areas in the hope of destroying the Talibans sanctuaries and the remnants of Al-Queda we are setting the stage for the destabilization of Pakistan. This will make Iraq seem like a picnic. Not only does Pakistan have nuclear weapons but a destabilized Pakistan could draw China in who will not sit by and allow Pakistan to fail. China depends on Pakistan to tie up their potentail rival India and will not look kindly if that buffer is removed. Other regional powers like Iran, India and Russia have their own agendas. This is a train wreck waiting to happen. With India and Pakistan nuclear powers the consequences of this could be horrific. One other item in Shazads report struck my attention. According to the article Holbrooke met with Nawaz Sharif to get him to drop his support for the lawyers movement against the government because this could destabilize the government. So just like the Bush administration before it the Obama administartion will join in a long line of US administrations that look the other way to Pakistani democracy. This is arguably the main problem in Pakistan and is responsible for the mess we are in today. By coddling these military dictators and slamming the door on legitimate democratic movements we have increased the hatred of the Pakistani people toward us. The lawyers movement was extremely popular and drew huge crowds that eventually brought down Musharraf. As Tariq Ali points out in his book "The Duel" the Red Mosque incident happened at around the same time as the lawyers movement and contrary to the average Americans perception of Pakistan as a country of crazy jihadi wannabees huge crowds came out in support of Iftikar Chaudry while the crowds in support of the extremist followers of the Red Mosque killings was minuscule. In the North West Frontier Province the Awami National Party won the latest elections, a secular party in a region that is thought to be all jihadi all the time. The people would like real democracy and the fact that the United States has prevented it repeatedly explains the dislike and suspicion of American intentions. By pursuing this Afghan escalation we may very well bring about the thing we fear most. A radical Islamic Pakistan. I've said it before and I will say it again. The only way out is a negotiated settlement in Afghanistan involving the Taliban and all the regional powers including Iran. Any other option is fraught with danger.
Wednesday, February 11, 2009
Israeli Elections
The Israeli elections are over and it looks like either Benjamin Netanyahus Likud Party or the Kadima party of Tzipi Livni is the winner. The real question that has not been resolved is who will be able to form the next government. The election was a mandate for right wing parties like Likud and Avigdor Liberman and his Beitenu party. I find it curious that a party that was started by Ariel Sharon could possibly be called a moderate party (Kadima) but I guess given how far to the right the rest of these groups are I suppose it 's all relative. According to Juan Cole the Labor Party only recieved 13 votes. How the mighty have fallen. Two conclusions here: 1)If I am a Palestinian I would be very worried. There is no doubt that all these parties will try to outdo the others to show how "tough" they are on terrorism which means ordinary Palestinians can expect the "iron fist" 2) The silver lining here is if Netenyahu forms the next government and is as extremist and intransigent as expected it gives the Obama administration an historic opportunity to reassess our relationship with Israel and to let them know the blank check and unconditional support is over. The pushback by AIPAC and the neo-cons will be nasty and Obama can kiss whatever bi-partisan fantasies he has out the window. The honeymoon with the press will probably be finished. However it needs to be done. Whether Obama has the stomach for this is debatable. He has never struck me as someone who steps out on a ledge and risks conflict. However it is high time we reassess our relationship with Israel. Netenyahu and his fellow travelers on the right are trouble. Big trouble and could very well destroy whatever hope an Obama administration has of repairing our relationship with the rest of the world that the Bush administration destroyed. That is the best case scenario. The worst case is that Israel attacks Iran against our wishes assuming that we will give them the unconditional support we always do and we find ourselves in a war with Iran that destroys the world economy even more than it already is and puts the final nail in the coffin of any pretensions of American unipolar hegemony. Obama has a decision to make.
Monday, February 9, 2009
This from Janes Intelligence Report concerning the closure of the US airbase in Kyrgystan:
"The decree was issued after President Kurmanbek Bakiyev stated on 3 February that the Manas airbase would close. This announcement was made during a visit by Bakiyev to Moscow where he held talks with his Russian counterpart Dmitry Medvedev regarding a major Russian aid package to Kyrgyzstan. This would include the cancellation of Bishkek's USD180 million debt to Russia, USD150 million in financial assistance and a USD2 billion discounted loan.
It is likely that Moscow sought the closure of the Manas airbase in return for the assistance as part of its broader strategy of limiting US power in the former Soviet Union. Bakiyev also stated that Washington was not willing to pay "the right price" for the base. The US Department of State said on 4 February that it had received no formal notification of the closure. "
This from Asia Times:
"When full-scale fighting resumes come the end of winter this year in Afghanistan, the United-States-led coalition will have more on its hands than a resurgent Taliban. The situation is compounded by different regional players, including Pakistan, Iran, Russia
and China, jockeying to exploit the situation. The administration of US President Barack Obama has already expressed grave concern over the situation in Afghanistan. "It is like no other problem we have confronted, and in my view it's going to be much tougher than Vietnam ... I have never seen anything like the mess we have inherited," Richard Holbrooke, the
US special envoy for Pakistan and Afghanistan, said at the weekend's 45th Munich Security Conference that brought together a dozen world leaders and about 50 top diplomats and defense officials. The annual conference was this year particularly focussed on resolving the Afghan quagmire and on finding alternative routes for the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) supplies that pass through Pakistan. The most logical route is through Iran's
Chabahar port, but nothing formal was agreed. This leaves individual NATO member countries to deal with Tehran bilaterally to arrange for supplies for their troops to pass through Iran. Germany, France, Canada and Italy are a few of the countries with forces in Afghanistan with relatively good relations with Iran. However, even in these cases, Iran is in a position to manipulate the situation in its favor. "
This is what Afghanistan has been reduced to. To continue our occupation and and create conditions favorable for the "surge" (supply routes) we have to depend on the goodwill of countries that are not our freinds like Iran and Russia. All this at a time when we are running out of money to finance this war. Why is Obama commited to this? Russia smells blood and will demand a high price for their "help". No more NATO expansion, cutting Saakashvili loose and regaining their dominant position in Central Asia for starters. Oh and no missle defense in Eastern Europe. Just at the time when it is obvious to the rest of the world that our financial position makes us very vulnerable we act as if it is still 1991 and we just won the Cold War. If Holbrookes comment about this being much tougher than Vietnam is true then what is the endgame here? Why is it necessary to escalate this war. The longer we stay the less support we will have. What is called the "Taliban" is in reality the Pashtun population who resent foreigners along with an increasing number of other Afghans. Whatever support we had dissipated a long time ago. That train left the station a while ago and is not coming back. We cannot afford this war and by escalating this war in the Pakistani tribal areas we run the risk of destabilizing Pakistan. China will not be happy and they are in a position to hurt us financially. I pray Obama is not falling into the Lyndon Johnson trap where to advance his sweeping domestic policies LBJ felt he had to be hawkish on Vietnam to neutralize the right wing. It did not work then and if this is Obamas gameplan it will not work now. If the goal right now is to prevent a Taliban resurgence it is too late. They are here. Any settlement will have to include them. That is too bad but it is our own fault for diverting our attention to Iraq. As for Al-Queda the way to go after what is left of the movement is the old fashioned way-police and intelligence co-operation with other countries. Escalation and the inevitable civilian deaths that will follow will not bring peace. It will drain our treasury and increase the likelihood of further attacks against the US. Where have we heard that before?
"The decree was issued after President Kurmanbek Bakiyev stated on 3 February that the Manas airbase would close. This announcement was made during a visit by Bakiyev to Moscow where he held talks with his Russian counterpart Dmitry Medvedev regarding a major Russian aid package to Kyrgyzstan. This would include the cancellation of Bishkek's USD180 million debt to Russia, USD150 million in financial assistance and a USD2 billion discounted loan.
It is likely that Moscow sought the closure of the Manas airbase in return for the assistance as part of its broader strategy of limiting US power in the former Soviet Union. Bakiyev also stated that Washington was not willing to pay "the right price" for the base. The US Department of State said on 4 February that it had received no formal notification of the closure. "
This from Asia Times:
"When full-scale fighting resumes come the end of winter this year in Afghanistan, the United-States-led coalition will have more on its hands than a resurgent Taliban. The situation is compounded by different regional players, including Pakistan, Iran, Russia
and China, jockeying to exploit the situation. The administration of US President Barack Obama has already expressed grave concern over the situation in Afghanistan. "It is like no other problem we have confronted, and in my view it's going to be much tougher than Vietnam ... I have never seen anything like the mess we have inherited," Richard Holbrooke, the
US special envoy for Pakistan and Afghanistan, said at the weekend's 45th Munich Security Conference that brought together a dozen world leaders and about 50 top diplomats and defense officials. The annual conference was this year particularly focussed on resolving the Afghan quagmire and on finding alternative routes for the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) supplies that pass through Pakistan. The most logical route is through Iran's
Chabahar port, but nothing formal was agreed. This leaves individual NATO member countries to deal with Tehran bilaterally to arrange for supplies for their troops to pass through Iran. Germany, France, Canada and Italy are a few of the countries with forces in Afghanistan with relatively good relations with Iran. However, even in these cases, Iran is in a position to manipulate the situation in its favor. "
This is what Afghanistan has been reduced to. To continue our occupation and and create conditions favorable for the "surge" (supply routes) we have to depend on the goodwill of countries that are not our freinds like Iran and Russia. All this at a time when we are running out of money to finance this war. Why is Obama commited to this? Russia smells blood and will demand a high price for their "help". No more NATO expansion, cutting Saakashvili loose and regaining their dominant position in Central Asia for starters. Oh and no missle defense in Eastern Europe. Just at the time when it is obvious to the rest of the world that our financial position makes us very vulnerable we act as if it is still 1991 and we just won the Cold War. If Holbrookes comment about this being much tougher than Vietnam is true then what is the endgame here? Why is it necessary to escalate this war. The longer we stay the less support we will have. What is called the "Taliban" is in reality the Pashtun population who resent foreigners along with an increasing number of other Afghans. Whatever support we had dissipated a long time ago. That train left the station a while ago and is not coming back. We cannot afford this war and by escalating this war in the Pakistani tribal areas we run the risk of destabilizing Pakistan. China will not be happy and they are in a position to hurt us financially. I pray Obama is not falling into the Lyndon Johnson trap where to advance his sweeping domestic policies LBJ felt he had to be hawkish on Vietnam to neutralize the right wing. It did not work then and if this is Obamas gameplan it will not work now. If the goal right now is to prevent a Taliban resurgence it is too late. They are here. Any settlement will have to include them. That is too bad but it is our own fault for diverting our attention to Iraq. As for Al-Queda the way to go after what is left of the movement is the old fashioned way-police and intelligence co-operation with other countries. Escalation and the inevitable civilian deaths that will follow will not bring peace. It will drain our treasury and increase the likelihood of further attacks against the US. Where have we heard that before?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)