1) On occasion you will hear it be said by defenders of BP and those who would like to minimize the damage that is being done on the Gulf region by this spill that there have always been leaks, natural leaks that over time have leaked large amounts of oil into the Gulf and that over time the Gulf has adapted to this and it will to this latest man made disaster. It has been estimated that over the course of a year natural seeps of oil, which occur as a result of fissures that allow oil and gas to seep into the water, release between 560,000 to around 1,400,000 barrels of oil a year throughout the Gulf. This would be equivalent to around 1,500 to 3,800 barrels a day. Over time it seems that the ecosystem of the Gulf has developed a way to adjust to this and inoculate itself. However what is critical to note here is the concentration of the oil and not just the total quantity spread throughout the whole Gulf. While true that over thousands of years bacteria evolved that are able to eat up the released oil what we are talking about here is a whole different animal. The amount of oil being released per day and the concentration of it adds a whole new dimension to what would naturally occur. It should be noted that natural seeps are not constantly active. The volume can vary throughout the day and hence only a small area close to the seep is exposed to the most toxic non-degraded oil. Very different from what is going on as I write. Clearly what is going on right now threatens to overwhelm the natural coping mechanisms that are in place to deal with a natural leak. This has led some people to suggest that one response to this disaster would be to release large additional amounts of oil eating bacteria into the Gulf to take care of the spill. The response to this is that these microbes also suck up dissolved oxygen along with the oil thereby setting up an additional set of problems. The question of oxygen levels is a serious one. The big question for many researchers now is what is the effects on oxygen depletion as a result of the oil plumes that have developed as a result of the widespread use of the dispersants BP is using?
Unfortunately there does not seem to be as much research into what is happening with the plumes as there should be. I have posted previously about this. Clearly though what is going on down here is the elephant in the room. One would think that the Obama administration would give it a more urgent priority. One person who is concerned about this issue is Dr. Samantha Joyce who writes for the blog Gulf Oil Blog and has done research into the plumes. She has been out conducting research in the Gulf on the plumes and describes her experiences in a travel log. At the same time she answers some questions that people have about the effects of the spill on the surrounding ecosystem. Concerning the dissolved oxygen levels she says and I quote, "How serious is the oxygen depletion problem? Potentially, this is a very serious problem. At present, oxygen concentrations exceed 2 mg/L but if concentrations drop below that, it would spell problems for any oxygen requiring organisms. The Southwest Plume is, at a minimum, 15 miles long x 2 miles long and the plume is about 600 feet thick. Temperatures in the plume are about 8-12ÂșC. We do not know the absolute oil content at this time. The plume is largely water. This is not thick oil like you see on the surface in some places, it’s diluted oil and it’s most concentrated closest to the leaking riser pipe. Unlike a natural oil seep, which is most intense on the bottom and whose signal decreases with depth above the seafloor, the plume we are studying starts 200m above the seafloor and its intensity decreases horizontally with distance away from the leaking wellhead. The specific gravity of oil is irrelevant to this discussion. This is not oil like you buy at the auto supply store. Think of it as gas-saturated oil that has been shot out of a deep sea cannon under intense pressure – it’s like putting olive oil in a spray can, pressurizing it and pushing the spray button. What comes out when you push that button? A mist of olive oil. This well is leaking a mist of oil that is settling out in the deep sea." She goes on to say that there is significant respiration going on in the plumes, 5-10 times higher than usual. The conditions are very good for the microbes to ingest the oil droplets but that as of today they do not know enough about whether the toxicity levels of what the microbes are consuming will prove detrimental later on. Remember that crude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons, compounds made of hydrogen and carbon. These compounds vary. Some are simple like methane which is one carbon atom and four hydrogen atoms (CH4). Some are much more complex with over 40 or so carbon atoms. In addition, crude oil also has compounds that contain sulfur, oxygen, nitrogen along with metals such as iron, nickle and copper. There are also traces of mineral salts. This means that not all crude oil is the same. Some are better quality than others. There is heavy oil which contains a lot of impurities like metals and salts and sweet crude which is short on sulfur. When making gasoline for your automobile the light sweet kind is the one that is normally preferred. Dr. Bill Chameides of Duke has a blog called the Green Grog and he discusses the toxicity of the oil spilling into the Gulf. He assumes that it is light sweet crude. He focuses on one group of toxins called Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAC's) that he finds particularly worrisome. I quote from the article, " A wide array of toxic chemicals is found in oil — and in gasoline by the way, so be careful when you fill your tank and definitely try not to breathe in the fumes. Let’s focus here on one of those toxins: polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). PAHs are compounds where the carbon atoms are arrayed in a series of six-sided hexagons called rings.A 2003 study by the National Academy of Sciences found that of all the typical hydrocarbons in crude oil, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) pose the greatest risk to the environment.There are at least three things that make PAHs worrisome: They are linked to cancer and other health problems, including fertility, reproductive and developmental issues, in both humans and wildlife.They are soluble in water so can be mobilized into the environment.They can persist in the environment where chronic exposure can cause long-term damage and even mortality at very low concentrations. In fact, these are the toxins that have been implicated in the slow recovery of the Bristol Bay ecosystems after the Valdez spill.Here’s a rough estimate of how much PAH contamination has been released into the gulf from the Deepwater disaster.Estimated metric tons of PAHs from the Deepwater rig spill as of May 19, 2010: 270-3,300 *For comparison:Estimated metric tons of PAHs from the two World Trade Towers' collapse: 100 and 1,000 Estimated metric tons of PAHs [pdf] emitted yearly in the United States as air pollution: 8,600-32,000That’s right — if not capped soon, the amount of PAHs put into the Gulf of Mexico may approach the amount of PAHs we put into the atmosphere across the entire United States over an entire year. Better get your gulf shrimp and oysters while you can." Remember that those totals were as of May 19th. As I write this it is June 18th and the estimated flow rate has been increased substantially since then and the leak continues. Also remember that the dispersants that are being used contain many toxins (although it seems that Nalco. the manufacturer, has gone out of its way to hide what is in there- read here: http://www.naturalnews.com/028974_Corexit_dispersants.html). Also remember that Corexit has been shown to be one of the most dangerous of the dispersants in terms of toxicity and you combine that with the PAH's and the other toxins in crude oil and you are playing with fire. Scary stuff indeed. Read the Gulf Oil Blog here: http://gulfblog.uga.edu/ and the Green Grog blog here: http://nicholas.duke.edu/thegreengrok/gulfspill-pahs. These articles discuss natural oil leaks in the Gulf. http://www.theoildrum.com/node/6552 and http://blogs.chron.com/sciguy/archives/2010/06/debunking_the_myth_that_natural_seeps_are_just_as_1.html.
Thursday, June 17, 2010
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Short thought for a Wednesday
1) The numbers just keep going up! From today's New York Times comes new figures on the estimated amount of oil that is spilling into the Gulf. I quote from the article, " A government panel on Tuesday released yet another estimate of the amount of oil flowing from BP’s damaged well, declaring that as much as 60,000 barrels a day could be spewing into the Gulf of Mexico. That is roughly 2.5 million gallons of oil a day, and it means an amount equal to the Exxon Valdez spill could be gushing from the well about every four days." Remember that BP claims to be capturing around 15,000 barrels a day with their containment device and that means something on the order of 45,000 barrels a day are leaking out. I quote again from the article, " The new estimate is far above the figure of 5,000 barrels a day that the government and BP clung to for weeks after the spill started, following the April 20 explosion of the Deepwater Horizon oil rig. That estimate was made by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration using methods not recommended for large oil spills, and it came under attack from professors and advocacy groups who said the spill had to be larger. Time has proven those critics right. The latest estimate reflects a possible increase in the flow rate that occurred after BP cut an underwater pipe called a riser on June 3 to install a new device to capture part of the oil. It is based on new information, including high-resolution video made after the riser cut, and on pressure readings taken by a device that was inserted this week into the equipment at the sea floor. Energy Secretary Steven Chu, a Nobel Prize-winning scientist, was personally involved in using those pressure readings to help make the latest calculation. “This estimate brings together several scientific methodologies and the latest information from the sea floor, and represents a significant step forward in our effort to put a number on the oil that is escaping from BP’s well,” Secretary Chu said in a statement. “As we continue to collect additional data and refine these estimates, it is important to realize that the numbers can change.” BP cut the riser pipe on June 3rd, although the original cut did not go as planned and instead of a clean cut with diamond wire saw they had to cut the pipe with shears that did not leave as clean a cut and made it more difficult to put the containment pipe over the spill possibly contributing to an increase in flow. BP plans to have the relief wells ready in August, so until then the oil will flow unabated. If the relief wells do not do the trick, then what? Read the article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/16/us/16spill.html?hp
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Short thoughts for a Tuesday
1) An article in the New York Times from June 14, 2010 provides evidence that BP did willingly cut corners in their rush to get the Deepwater Horizon well completed. This backs up what I tried to prove in my previous posts. The article lists several things that BP did to save time and money and compromise safety to get the well completed on time. According to the article the well was already behind schedule and in March they had applied for a bypass whereby a well is drilled around a problem area. By the day of the blowout, April 20th, the rig which was leased from Transocean at one half a million dollars a day plus contracting fees, was 43 days late for its next drilling operation. It would seem that it was this delay that led to a series of hasty and fatal decisions that resulted in the blowout whose effects we are still trying to get a handle on. One of the bad decisions was to use what is called a tapered string casing design which costs about 7-10 million dollars less than other methods but offers less protection if the cementing job is poor and gas were to rise up the well. Casing refers to the pipe that is assembled and then inserted into a recently drilled borehole and then held in place by cement. It helps to perform a variety of functions that facilitates the drilling operation. Although using this method saved BP money it also meant that the well had only two barriers to an upward gas flow that could cause a blowout. One was cement near the bottom of the well and a steel assembly near the top. Unfortunately the company made bad decisions regarding cementing. In regards to the cementing, BP used fewer centralizers, devices that make sure that the final string of casing is centered in the well hole and ensures that cement flows evenly around the casing. BP used only six instead of the twenty one that were recommended by the cement contractor Haliburton (yep! Those guys!). Haliburton had warned BP of severe gas flow problems. According to the article on April 16th in an internal e-mail a BP official complained that it would take 10 hours to do this and he didn't like this. In addition it turns out that BP did not fully circulate heavy drilling mud through the well , because that would have taken an additional 12 hours, before they started the cement job. The American Petroleum Institute recommends full circulation to reduce the possibility that the mud will contaminate the cement and contribute to failure. BP also failed to order a cement band log, which is a testing procedure that would have evaluated the quality of the cement barrier which had already been shown by computer model run by BP to be of poor quality. A company called Schlumberger was tasked with this job but on the morning of the blowout the projected test was cancelled and the Schlumberger employees were sent home. The test would have taken an additional 12 hours. You can read the Times article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/15/science/earth/15rig.html?hp
2) I wrote in one of my previous posts on this Gulf oil blowout that this story would have legs. I didn't know it would have this many! From the LA Times comes this story that goes into some detail about how companies get around US safety inspections by registering these off shore rigs, which are considered ships under international law, with foreign countries whose safety and maintenance rules are easily circumvented or nonexistent. It turns out that the Deepwater Horizon rig is registered to that bastion of tough environmental and occupational safety inspections...the Marshall Islands! This is a tiny impoverished group of atolls many of which are smaller than the Deepwater rig itself! Because these rigs are classified as foreign vessels the Coast Guard will conduct a cursory inspection and rely on the safety reports that are prepared by the outside firms that are often paid directly by the owner of the vessel. Minerals and Management Service is responsible for what goes on "below the waterline" but not for what occurs on the top including staffing decisions and command structure. It is this command and staffing structure that may have helped contribute to the blowout. According to Donald Brown who has been a chief mechanic on the rig since it was built in 2000, there has been a gradual reduction of manpower over the years. This has led to dual command structure whereby on the day of the explosion an oil drilling expert made critical decisions ahead of a licensed sea captain. John Konrad, who is a licensed sea captain and who writes a maritime blog, said that oil rigs should be under the command of a licensed sea captain. It turns out that on the Deepwater Horizon the oil drilling expert made the decisions about safety. This kind of dual command system would not be permitted on a US flagged operation. Offshore rigs like the Deepwater Horizon float above the well connected by thousands of pipes and are kept in place by elaborate navigational systems hence the need for an experienced sea captain. Read the LA Times article here: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-oil-inspection-20100615,0,7349376.story and access John Konrad's maritime blog here: http://gcaptain.com/
2) I wrote in one of my previous posts on this Gulf oil blowout that this story would have legs. I didn't know it would have this many! From the LA Times comes this story that goes into some detail about how companies get around US safety inspections by registering these off shore rigs, which are considered ships under international law, with foreign countries whose safety and maintenance rules are easily circumvented or nonexistent. It turns out that the Deepwater Horizon rig is registered to that bastion of tough environmental and occupational safety inspections...the Marshall Islands! This is a tiny impoverished group of atolls many of which are smaller than the Deepwater rig itself! Because these rigs are classified as foreign vessels the Coast Guard will conduct a cursory inspection and rely on the safety reports that are prepared by the outside firms that are often paid directly by the owner of the vessel. Minerals and Management Service is responsible for what goes on "below the waterline" but not for what occurs on the top including staffing decisions and command structure. It is this command and staffing structure that may have helped contribute to the blowout. According to Donald Brown who has been a chief mechanic on the rig since it was built in 2000, there has been a gradual reduction of manpower over the years. This has led to dual command structure whereby on the day of the explosion an oil drilling expert made critical decisions ahead of a licensed sea captain. John Konrad, who is a licensed sea captain and who writes a maritime blog, said that oil rigs should be under the command of a licensed sea captain. It turns out that on the Deepwater Horizon the oil drilling expert made the decisions about safety. This kind of dual command system would not be permitted on a US flagged operation. Offshore rigs like the Deepwater Horizon float above the well connected by thousands of pipes and are kept in place by elaborate navigational systems hence the need for an experienced sea captain. Read the LA Times article here: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-oil-inspection-20100615,0,7349376.story and access John Konrad's maritime blog here: http://gcaptain.com/
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
BP and the oil spill- Part three
In the first two posts concerning the Deepwater Horizon blowout I tried to establish that BP willingly cut corners to rush the project to market and that they were aided in this by a complacent regulatory regime who let the oil company get away with this. The regulators did not regulate. In the second post we looked at the impact on the region of this spill and the high probability that when this is done the region will live with serious ecological and environmental damage for a long time to come. This third post will focus in particular on the Obama administration's handling of this and more generally on the power of the financial/industrial elites to control the government that is supposed to control them.
The best place to start a discussion of the Obama administration's response to this crisis should begin with the man himself, Barack Obama. Many Americans, and not just those in the Gulf, are very upset at what they see as a lackluster response to the unfolding crisis. For the first couple of weeks it seemed Obama was nowhere to be seen, hiding behind the excuse that this is BP's problem and they will find a way to clean it up. Of course it was Barack himself who shortly before the blowout reversed his position on off shore drilling and suddenly announced his support to end the moratorium on off shore drilling and open up more of the Gulf and Florida and the Atlantic coast to new drilling. He also pledged his support for new areas in Alaska to explore. Of course in the campaign against John McCain he was opposed to ending the moratorium on off shore drilling and criticized McCain for his support of it. Like all things Obama, there is the Obama of the "speech" and the decisions he actually implements. They are not often the same thing. I was onto Obama early on. I never bought the mantra that he was a progressive or a new type of politician. I looked at his voting record and compared it to Hillary and found little difference between the two. Many progressives and liberals were so captivated at the words he used in his speeches that they never bothered to actually look at his voting record or the choices he has made. Whether it was his support for Joe Lieberman against Ned Lamont in the Connecticut primary or his support for the 2005 Energy Bill that was strongly supported by Dick Cheney, that gave a slew of tax cuts and incentives to the oil companies, among many other things it seems that the speeches of Barack and the actual decisions he makes are two very different things. It seems that Obama lives in the world of the fuzzy middle and the eternal compromise. Moderation in all things and never ever stand for something, no matter how politically unpopular it is. He reacts to pressure and it seems not to matter if it is from the left or the right. He tries to avoid conflict at all costs which would explain his disastrous attempt at a bi-partisan strategy at the start of his administration. This was a strategic error of major proportions and it is time and momentum he will never get back. There was always a kind of smugness and condescension about the typical Obama supporter that annoyed me. There was this feeling among a certain percentage of his supporters that they and he were something special and that if you didn't buy into it you were somehow un-hip. To this day, even after all the flip flops on financial regulation, deepwater drilling, the escalation of Afghanistan, Bagram being the new Guantanamo and on and on many of his supporters continue to refuse to call him out and get real pissy with progressives who do criticize him, like myself. This is unfortunate because as I said earlier Obama seems to have no real convictions that he will fight to the end on. He only responds to pressure and if the "left" does not want to bring pressure on him he will ignore their concerns. He is a corporate Democrat through and through and little different in this regard than the man that Obama supporters loved to trash in the primary, Bill Clinton. Nowhere is this more apparent then in the people that he has chosen to surround himself with. He is a very passive president who reacts to events and does not want to step out in front and take charge. Nowhere is this trait more on display than in the events that are happening in the Gulf of Mexico.
Perhaps nothing illustrates the passivity of the Obama administration to this crisis better than the amount of oil that is leaking out of the riser pipe. For about a month BP has insisted that it is 5.000 barrels a day. That has been challenged by many independent observers. The video that BP has of the leak was withheld from the press and Congress with the consent of the administration who went along with the story. Thanks to the efforts of Barbara Boxer (D-Ca) and especially Bill Nelson (D-Fl) these were finally released. They made it obvious that what was leaking out was far more than the 5,000 barrels BP was claiming. BP themselves later admitted as much as I wrote and linked about in my previous post. They basically lied for a whole month and the Obama administration did little to force their hand. BP claims that there was no way to get an accurate handle on how much was leaking. This was immediately contradicted by many in the scientific community. No doubt the Obama administration, very aware of the potential political fallout of this a la Katrina, was hoping that BP would get a handle on this quickly and did not want to call attention to something that had political implications. I assume but do not know for sure that BP thought they would bring this thing under control. The dispersants that BP were using were doing a good job of keeping oil off the surface and out of sight was out of mind, at least that is how it appeared to look to the Obama administration. After a time it was becoming obvious to more people that this leak was far worse than was being claimed and still it took a couple of Democratic senators to put the pressure on BP to release the video, not the White House. This is an appalling lack of leadership. Had we known how much was leaking out at the start we would be in a better position to judge just where that oil is going to. As it stands now we are in the dark. Other than the public relations problem there appears to be another reason that BP hoarded the video and refused any independent readings of the oil leak. According to McClatchy news from a May 20th article BP's lowball count and the Obama administration's acceptance of those figures and refusal to send an independent verification team to find out for themselves could save BP a boatload of money in damages when the financial impact of this thing is resolved. BP has claimed that an independent verification would interfere with the cleanup but this is contradicted by their own internal memo. I quote from the article, " BP and the Obama administration have said they don't want to take the measurements for fear of interfering with efforts to stop the leaks. That decision, however, runs counter to BP's own regional plan for dealing with offshore leaks. "In the event of a significant release of oil," the 583-page plan says on Page 2, "an accurate estimation of the spill's total volume . . . is essential in providing preliminary data to plan and initiate cleanup operations."Legal experts said that not having a credible official estimate of the leak's size provides another benefit for BP: The amount of oil spilled is certain to be key evidence in the court battles that are likely to result from the disaster. The size of the Exxon Valdez spill in Alaska, for example, was a significant factor that the jury considered when it assessed damages against Exxon."If they put off measuring, then it's going to be a battle of dueling experts after the fact trying to extrapolate how much spilled after it has all sunk or has been carried away," said Lloyd Benton Miller, one of the lead plaintiffs' lawyers in the Exxon Valdez spill litigation. "The ability to measure how much oil was released will be impossible." There you have it. I have no doubt that the reason BP has stonewalled this thing is to cover their own ass, public be damned. I have a hard time believing that the government was totally unaware of the liability issue here. If this was the Bush administration we would naturally assume collusion and we would no doubt be correct. I am not suggesting that Barack Obama himself was covering for BP, however it is a strong possibility that others in his administration are. Either way, he is in charge and history will judge him.
The choice of Ken Salzar as Secretary of the Interior says a lot about Barack Obama himself. A centrist Democrat, whose environmental record is mixed, he has throughout his career shown himself to be friendly to big industry and not the kind of person you would expect to stand up to the abuse of power. Much like many other Obama appointments like Tim Geithner, Robert Gates, Hillary Clinton, Rahm Emmanuel and Larry Summers, Barack will never choose a progressive but will always go for the centrist, who can be counted on to maintain the status quo. What did Salazar bring to the table? On the plus side he was opposed to the rush to develop oil shale by the Bush administration arguing that there needed to be a lot more studies on the impact to the environment.On the minus side he was opposed to increasing Cafe standards, voted to continue tax breaks for major oil companies, voted on a bill to end protections that would limit off shore drilling, supported Joe Lieberman against Ned Lamont and supported the horrific Bush appointee of the Interior, Gale Norton. In other words, very typical of the typical Obama appointee. Always the mushy middle. Contrast that with the Republicans who never miss a beat to force their far right appointees on the American public. These appointees are usually bad news but still in a weird sort of way you have to kind of admire a party that acts on their convictions, no matter how bad they are. That is a problem you do not have to worry about with today's Democratic party.
The question of moratoriums on new drilling permits and the granting of environmental wavers provides a view of the fuzzy way that Obama governs as well as giving evidence of his ability to say one thing in a speech and do something else in a policy act. An article in the New York Times from May 23rd tells the story. After giving a tough speech on May 14th in which Obama promised a moratorium on permits for new offshore drilling and an end to the granting of a controversial type of environmental waiver, according to the Times this tough talk is not being followed. I quote from the article, " In the days since President Obama announced a moratorium on permits for drilling new offshore oil wells and a halt to a controversial type of environmental waiver that was given to the Deepwater Horizon rig, at least seven new permits for various types of drilling and five environmental waivers have been granted, according to records. The records also indicate that since the April 20 explosion on the rig, federal regulators have granted at least 19 environmental waivers for gulf drilling projects and at least 17 drilling permits, most of which were for types of work like that on the Deepwater Horizon shortly before it exploded, pouring a ceaseless current of oil into the Gulf of Mexico. Asked about the permits and waivers, officials at the Department of the Interior and the Minerals Management Service, which regulates drilling, pointed to public statements by Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, reiterating that the agency had no intention of stopping all new oil and gas production in the gulf." Say what? Later on we find out what was really going on. I quote, "Department of the Interior officials said in a statement that the moratorium was meant only to halt permits for the drilling of new wells. It was not meant to stop permits for new work on existing drilling projects like the Deepwater Horizon." Ah! I get it. Note that these waivers and permits have been for wells that in many cases are in areas as deep or deeper than the well that blew up. The money quote is here, " However, these waivers have been especially troublesome to environmentalists because they were granted through a special legal provision that is supposed to be limited to projects that present minimal or no risk to the environment. At least six of the drilling projects that have been given waivers in the past four weeks are for waters that are deeper — and therefore more difficult and dangerous — than where Deepwater Horizon was operating. While that rig, which was drilling at a depth just shy of 5,000 feet, was classified as a deep-water operation, many of the wells in the six projects are classified as “ultra” deep water, including four new wells at over 9,100 feet." This is incredible to me. I expect this kind of thing with a Republican administration, but naive as I know I am, I expect a little more backbone from a Democratic administration. Read the whole article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/24/us/24moratorium.html?pagewanted=1&hp . It is an eye opener.
The federal regulatory agency responsible for regulating off shore drilling is the Minerals Management Service (MMS). It has taken a lot of heat as a result of their role in this fiasco. A couple of articles that appeared in the New York Times and the Washington Post shine a light on what went wrong at the agency and highlights how our regulatory agencies have become captive to the industries they are supposed to regulate. These two articles go into detail about the various misdeeds of the agency including unethical behavior, shoddy work and an inability to divorce themselves from the industry's interests. For instance we hear stories about employees who accepted tickets to sporting events, meals and gifts from at least one major oil company. Stories about how federal regulators let industry officials file their own inspection reports in pencil and then turned them over to the regulators who then traced it over in ink and submitted the final report to the agency. We hear of cases of drug use and instances where regulators who were conducting inspections on a drilling platform are at the same time negotiating to get a job with that company. These practices were especially common in the Lake Charles, Louisiana office. MMS officials are said to receive cash bonuses in the thousands of dollars for meeting federal deadlines for leasing oil and gas offshore exploration! This quote from the Post article pretty much sums up what is wrong with our regulatory regime. I quote, "MMS actions are shaped in part by a 2005 regulation it adopted that assumes oil and gas companies can best evaluate the environmental effects of their operations. The rule governing which information the MMS should receive and review before signing off on drilling plans states: "The lessee or operator is in the best position to determine the environmental effects of its proposed activity based on whether the operation is routine or non-routine." MMS said in a May 2000 draft environmental analysis of deep-water drilling in the Gulf of Mexico that "the oil industry's experience base in deep-water well control is limited" and that a massive spill "could easily turn out to be a potential showstopper for the [Outer Continental Shelf] program if the industry and MMS do not come together as a whole to prevent such an incident." But when the MMS finalized the document that month, it jettisoned those two statements and concluded that there was no need to prepare an environmental impact analysis for deep-water drilling: "Most deep-water operations and activities are substantially the same as those associated with conventional operations and activities on the continental shelf." While this post has concentrated on the Obama administration's response to the crisis it is important to realize that most of the abuses mentioned in the inspector general report occurred under George W. Bush. While the tension between the public interest and private profit is always present the degree of corruption was taken to a new high under George W. Bush. The Republican strategy, that goes back to the Reagan years, has been to discredit government in the eyes of the general public. To do that you have to trash it. They have run up massive deficits based on a faulty economic program called Reaganomics, not just under Reagan but again under George W. Bush and then blamed this on government spending on social programs such as social security and Medicare which must be eliminated to bring about "fiscal responsibility". At the same time they have made sure that the regulatory positions that by statute have to be filled have been held by people who are tools of the financial interests they are supposed to regulate. When the inevitable crisis occurs (economic meltdown of 2008 or the Deepwater blowout) they can claim that regulation did not prevent it, hence it is unnecessary. Many gullible teabaggers, whose economic interests are not helped by the Republican agenda, have bought into this. While these abuses have been particularly egregious under George W. Bush, they have also occurred under Democratic administrations as well. The real problem here is that the financial/industrial elites have become so powerful that they have taken control of the government and in the pursuit of profit they will do whatever they want regardless of the public interest. When the inevitable disaster happens we the people can be expected to pick up the tab. If the teabaggers would take the wax out of their ears and listen for once they might understand that the problem is not "government". Rather the problem is that these elites have usurped the government and used the American people as roadkill on the road to profit. The problem is not capitalism per se, but this type of capitalism, the kind that is too big too fail and has the resources to buy off the government that is supposed to regulate it in the public interest.
I started this post on the 25th of May and I am finishing it on the 28th of May. As of today Barack Obama has just given a press conference defending his administration's handlking of this crisis. BP, after saying the top kill procedure seemed to be working, has now suspended it for a while. We are not sure what is going on. At this point why would anyone believe anything BP says?I hope the top kill works for if does not it will be a long deadly summer. Meanwhile BP is still using the dispersent Corexit into the water despite the Obama administration ordering them not to. The Obama administration did not cause this spill. We are drilling in these deepwater wells because we are rapidly running out of areas where the cheap easy to get oil is and the rest is in unstable areas like Iraq. Perhaps the only good thing to come out of this is perhaps the American people will get a wake-up call and realize that for many reasons we need to make a serious transition to an economy not based on foosil fuels. It will be costly and it will pinch people in the pocketbook. Right now the oil companies, like BP, have fought this transition tooth and nail because they are making boatloads of money right now ($45 million in profit a day by BP!). It will take a lot of courage to stand up to them and sell this thing to the American people. It is called leadership. It is chance for Barack Obama to overcome the perception of someone who is not in control of events and merely reacts to them. It requires a different approach than we have seen so far.
Read the articles concerning the Minerals Management Services here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/25/us/25mms.html and here http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/25/AR2010052502817.html. Barack Obama support for off shore drilling here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/mar/31/barack-obama-offshore-drilling. The McClatchy article on oil spill estimates is here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2010/05/20/94581/low-estimate-of-oil-spills-size.html
The best place to start a discussion of the Obama administration's response to this crisis should begin with the man himself, Barack Obama. Many Americans, and not just those in the Gulf, are very upset at what they see as a lackluster response to the unfolding crisis. For the first couple of weeks it seemed Obama was nowhere to be seen, hiding behind the excuse that this is BP's problem and they will find a way to clean it up. Of course it was Barack himself who shortly before the blowout reversed his position on off shore drilling and suddenly announced his support to end the moratorium on off shore drilling and open up more of the Gulf and Florida and the Atlantic coast to new drilling. He also pledged his support for new areas in Alaska to explore. Of course in the campaign against John McCain he was opposed to ending the moratorium on off shore drilling and criticized McCain for his support of it. Like all things Obama, there is the Obama of the "speech" and the decisions he actually implements. They are not often the same thing. I was onto Obama early on. I never bought the mantra that he was a progressive or a new type of politician. I looked at his voting record and compared it to Hillary and found little difference between the two. Many progressives and liberals were so captivated at the words he used in his speeches that they never bothered to actually look at his voting record or the choices he has made. Whether it was his support for Joe Lieberman against Ned Lamont in the Connecticut primary or his support for the 2005 Energy Bill that was strongly supported by Dick Cheney, that gave a slew of tax cuts and incentives to the oil companies, among many other things it seems that the speeches of Barack and the actual decisions he makes are two very different things. It seems that Obama lives in the world of the fuzzy middle and the eternal compromise. Moderation in all things and never ever stand for something, no matter how politically unpopular it is. He reacts to pressure and it seems not to matter if it is from the left or the right. He tries to avoid conflict at all costs which would explain his disastrous attempt at a bi-partisan strategy at the start of his administration. This was a strategic error of major proportions and it is time and momentum he will never get back. There was always a kind of smugness and condescension about the typical Obama supporter that annoyed me. There was this feeling among a certain percentage of his supporters that they and he were something special and that if you didn't buy into it you were somehow un-hip. To this day, even after all the flip flops on financial regulation, deepwater drilling, the escalation of Afghanistan, Bagram being the new Guantanamo and on and on many of his supporters continue to refuse to call him out and get real pissy with progressives who do criticize him, like myself. This is unfortunate because as I said earlier Obama seems to have no real convictions that he will fight to the end on. He only responds to pressure and if the "left" does not want to bring pressure on him he will ignore their concerns. He is a corporate Democrat through and through and little different in this regard than the man that Obama supporters loved to trash in the primary, Bill Clinton. Nowhere is this more apparent then in the people that he has chosen to surround himself with. He is a very passive president who reacts to events and does not want to step out in front and take charge. Nowhere is this trait more on display than in the events that are happening in the Gulf of Mexico.
Perhaps nothing illustrates the passivity of the Obama administration to this crisis better than the amount of oil that is leaking out of the riser pipe. For about a month BP has insisted that it is 5.000 barrels a day. That has been challenged by many independent observers. The video that BP has of the leak was withheld from the press and Congress with the consent of the administration who went along with the story. Thanks to the efforts of Barbara Boxer (D-Ca) and especially Bill Nelson (D-Fl) these were finally released. They made it obvious that what was leaking out was far more than the 5,000 barrels BP was claiming. BP themselves later admitted as much as I wrote and linked about in my previous post. They basically lied for a whole month and the Obama administration did little to force their hand. BP claims that there was no way to get an accurate handle on how much was leaking. This was immediately contradicted by many in the scientific community. No doubt the Obama administration, very aware of the potential political fallout of this a la Katrina, was hoping that BP would get a handle on this quickly and did not want to call attention to something that had political implications. I assume but do not know for sure that BP thought they would bring this thing under control. The dispersants that BP were using were doing a good job of keeping oil off the surface and out of sight was out of mind, at least that is how it appeared to look to the Obama administration. After a time it was becoming obvious to more people that this leak was far worse than was being claimed and still it took a couple of Democratic senators to put the pressure on BP to release the video, not the White House. This is an appalling lack of leadership. Had we known how much was leaking out at the start we would be in a better position to judge just where that oil is going to. As it stands now we are in the dark. Other than the public relations problem there appears to be another reason that BP hoarded the video and refused any independent readings of the oil leak. According to McClatchy news from a May 20th article BP's lowball count and the Obama administration's acceptance of those figures and refusal to send an independent verification team to find out for themselves could save BP a boatload of money in damages when the financial impact of this thing is resolved. BP has claimed that an independent verification would interfere with the cleanup but this is contradicted by their own internal memo. I quote from the article, " BP and the Obama administration have said they don't want to take the measurements for fear of interfering with efforts to stop the leaks. That decision, however, runs counter to BP's own regional plan for dealing with offshore leaks. "In the event of a significant release of oil," the 583-page plan says on Page 2, "an accurate estimation of the spill's total volume . . . is essential in providing preliminary data to plan and initiate cleanup operations."Legal experts said that not having a credible official estimate of the leak's size provides another benefit for BP: The amount of oil spilled is certain to be key evidence in the court battles that are likely to result from the disaster. The size of the Exxon Valdez spill in Alaska, for example, was a significant factor that the jury considered when it assessed damages against Exxon."If they put off measuring, then it's going to be a battle of dueling experts after the fact trying to extrapolate how much spilled after it has all sunk or has been carried away," said Lloyd Benton Miller, one of the lead plaintiffs' lawyers in the Exxon Valdez spill litigation. "The ability to measure how much oil was released will be impossible." There you have it. I have no doubt that the reason BP has stonewalled this thing is to cover their own ass, public be damned. I have a hard time believing that the government was totally unaware of the liability issue here. If this was the Bush administration we would naturally assume collusion and we would no doubt be correct. I am not suggesting that Barack Obama himself was covering for BP, however it is a strong possibility that others in his administration are. Either way, he is in charge and history will judge him.
The choice of Ken Salzar as Secretary of the Interior says a lot about Barack Obama himself. A centrist Democrat, whose environmental record is mixed, he has throughout his career shown himself to be friendly to big industry and not the kind of person you would expect to stand up to the abuse of power. Much like many other Obama appointments like Tim Geithner, Robert Gates, Hillary Clinton, Rahm Emmanuel and Larry Summers, Barack will never choose a progressive but will always go for the centrist, who can be counted on to maintain the status quo. What did Salazar bring to the table? On the plus side he was opposed to the rush to develop oil shale by the Bush administration arguing that there needed to be a lot more studies on the impact to the environment.On the minus side he was opposed to increasing Cafe standards, voted to continue tax breaks for major oil companies, voted on a bill to end protections that would limit off shore drilling, supported Joe Lieberman against Ned Lamont and supported the horrific Bush appointee of the Interior, Gale Norton. In other words, very typical of the typical Obama appointee. Always the mushy middle. Contrast that with the Republicans who never miss a beat to force their far right appointees on the American public. These appointees are usually bad news but still in a weird sort of way you have to kind of admire a party that acts on their convictions, no matter how bad they are. That is a problem you do not have to worry about with today's Democratic party.
The question of moratoriums on new drilling permits and the granting of environmental wavers provides a view of the fuzzy way that Obama governs as well as giving evidence of his ability to say one thing in a speech and do something else in a policy act. An article in the New York Times from May 23rd tells the story. After giving a tough speech on May 14th in which Obama promised a moratorium on permits for new offshore drilling and an end to the granting of a controversial type of environmental waiver, according to the Times this tough talk is not being followed. I quote from the article, " In the days since President Obama announced a moratorium on permits for drilling new offshore oil wells and a halt to a controversial type of environmental waiver that was given to the Deepwater Horizon rig, at least seven new permits for various types of drilling and five environmental waivers have been granted, according to records. The records also indicate that since the April 20 explosion on the rig, federal regulators have granted at least 19 environmental waivers for gulf drilling projects and at least 17 drilling permits, most of which were for types of work like that on the Deepwater Horizon shortly before it exploded, pouring a ceaseless current of oil into the Gulf of Mexico. Asked about the permits and waivers, officials at the Department of the Interior and the Minerals Management Service, which regulates drilling, pointed to public statements by Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, reiterating that the agency had no intention of stopping all new oil and gas production in the gulf." Say what? Later on we find out what was really going on. I quote, "Department of the Interior officials said in a statement that the moratorium was meant only to halt permits for the drilling of new wells. It was not meant to stop permits for new work on existing drilling projects like the Deepwater Horizon." Ah! I get it. Note that these waivers and permits have been for wells that in many cases are in areas as deep or deeper than the well that blew up. The money quote is here, " However, these waivers have been especially troublesome to environmentalists because they were granted through a special legal provision that is supposed to be limited to projects that present minimal or no risk to the environment. At least six of the drilling projects that have been given waivers in the past four weeks are for waters that are deeper — and therefore more difficult and dangerous — than where Deepwater Horizon was operating. While that rig, which was drilling at a depth just shy of 5,000 feet, was classified as a deep-water operation, many of the wells in the six projects are classified as “ultra” deep water, including four new wells at over 9,100 feet." This is incredible to me. I expect this kind of thing with a Republican administration, but naive as I know I am, I expect a little more backbone from a Democratic administration. Read the whole article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/24/us/24moratorium.html?pagewanted=1&hp . It is an eye opener.
The federal regulatory agency responsible for regulating off shore drilling is the Minerals Management Service (MMS). It has taken a lot of heat as a result of their role in this fiasco. A couple of articles that appeared in the New York Times and the Washington Post shine a light on what went wrong at the agency and highlights how our regulatory agencies have become captive to the industries they are supposed to regulate. These two articles go into detail about the various misdeeds of the agency including unethical behavior, shoddy work and an inability to divorce themselves from the industry's interests. For instance we hear stories about employees who accepted tickets to sporting events, meals and gifts from at least one major oil company. Stories about how federal regulators let industry officials file their own inspection reports in pencil and then turned them over to the regulators who then traced it over in ink and submitted the final report to the agency. We hear of cases of drug use and instances where regulators who were conducting inspections on a drilling platform are at the same time negotiating to get a job with that company. These practices were especially common in the Lake Charles, Louisiana office. MMS officials are said to receive cash bonuses in the thousands of dollars for meeting federal deadlines for leasing oil and gas offshore exploration! This quote from the Post article pretty much sums up what is wrong with our regulatory regime. I quote, "MMS actions are shaped in part by a 2005 regulation it adopted that assumes oil and gas companies can best evaluate the environmental effects of their operations. The rule governing which information the MMS should receive and review before signing off on drilling plans states: "The lessee or operator is in the best position to determine the environmental effects of its proposed activity based on whether the operation is routine or non-routine." MMS said in a May 2000 draft environmental analysis of deep-water drilling in the Gulf of Mexico that "the oil industry's experience base in deep-water well control is limited" and that a massive spill "could easily turn out to be a potential showstopper for the [Outer Continental Shelf] program if the industry and MMS do not come together as a whole to prevent such an incident." But when the MMS finalized the document that month, it jettisoned those two statements and concluded that there was no need to prepare an environmental impact analysis for deep-water drilling: "Most deep-water operations and activities are substantially the same as those associated with conventional operations and activities on the continental shelf." While this post has concentrated on the Obama administration's response to the crisis it is important to realize that most of the abuses mentioned in the inspector general report occurred under George W. Bush. While the tension between the public interest and private profit is always present the degree of corruption was taken to a new high under George W. Bush. The Republican strategy, that goes back to the Reagan years, has been to discredit government in the eyes of the general public. To do that you have to trash it. They have run up massive deficits based on a faulty economic program called Reaganomics, not just under Reagan but again under George W. Bush and then blamed this on government spending on social programs such as social security and Medicare which must be eliminated to bring about "fiscal responsibility". At the same time they have made sure that the regulatory positions that by statute have to be filled have been held by people who are tools of the financial interests they are supposed to regulate. When the inevitable crisis occurs (economic meltdown of 2008 or the Deepwater blowout) they can claim that regulation did not prevent it, hence it is unnecessary. Many gullible teabaggers, whose economic interests are not helped by the Republican agenda, have bought into this. While these abuses have been particularly egregious under George W. Bush, they have also occurred under Democratic administrations as well. The real problem here is that the financial/industrial elites have become so powerful that they have taken control of the government and in the pursuit of profit they will do whatever they want regardless of the public interest. When the inevitable disaster happens we the people can be expected to pick up the tab. If the teabaggers would take the wax out of their ears and listen for once they might understand that the problem is not "government". Rather the problem is that these elites have usurped the government and used the American people as roadkill on the road to profit. The problem is not capitalism per se, but this type of capitalism, the kind that is too big too fail and has the resources to buy off the government that is supposed to regulate it in the public interest.
I started this post on the 25th of May and I am finishing it on the 28th of May. As of today Barack Obama has just given a press conference defending his administration's handlking of this crisis. BP, after saying the top kill procedure seemed to be working, has now suspended it for a while. We are not sure what is going on. At this point why would anyone believe anything BP says?I hope the top kill works for if does not it will be a long deadly summer. Meanwhile BP is still using the dispersent Corexit into the water despite the Obama administration ordering them not to. The Obama administration did not cause this spill. We are drilling in these deepwater wells because we are rapidly running out of areas where the cheap easy to get oil is and the rest is in unstable areas like Iraq. Perhaps the only good thing to come out of this is perhaps the American people will get a wake-up call and realize that for many reasons we need to make a serious transition to an economy not based on foosil fuels. It will be costly and it will pinch people in the pocketbook. Right now the oil companies, like BP, have fought this transition tooth and nail because they are making boatloads of money right now ($45 million in profit a day by BP!). It will take a lot of courage to stand up to them and sell this thing to the American people. It is called leadership. It is chance for Barack Obama to overcome the perception of someone who is not in control of events and merely reacts to them. It requires a different approach than we have seen so far.
Read the articles concerning the Minerals Management Services here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/25/us/25mms.html and here http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/05/25/AR2010052502817.html. Barack Obama support for off shore drilling here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/mar/31/barack-obama-offshore-drilling. The McClatchy article on oil spill estimates is here: http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2010/05/20/94581/low-estimate-of-oil-spills-size.html
Thursday, May 20, 2010
BP and the oil spill- Part two
In the first post relating to the Deepwater Horizon well blowout I tried to establish that BP willingly compromised safety precautions to rush the well to market aided by a complacent and accommodating regulatory regime that looked the other way. The question now becomes after the explosion what has BP done to try to get a handle on this and have their efforts to contain this made the situation better or worse? Like a blind person who gropes in the dark in a room where the furniture has been rearranged without his knowledge the response of BP to this disaster has been equally clumsy and awkward. BP has tried a variety of measures so far to stem the flow of oil from the well. These included sub sea robots, container domes, insertion tubes and now they will try something called a "top kill". Along with these measures they have used dispersants to break up the oil and prevent it from getting to the surface. Still, the leak continues. Clearly BP fumbled the ball here. The question becomes, can this be contained and stopped before it reaches a point of ecological disaster for the region and the Gulf?
Today according to the AP, BP finally admitted what independent observers have suspected all along. That the amount gushing out of the well is more than 5,000 barrels a day. According to the AP story and I quote, " Mark Proegler, a spokesman for oil giant BP PLC, said a mile-long tube inserted into a leaking pipe over the weekend is capturing 210,000 gallons a day--the total amount the company and the Coast Guard have estimated is gushing into the sea--but some is still escaping. He would not say how much." If a barrel of oil contains 42 gallons then 5,000 barrels times 42 gallons would equal 210,000 gallons which would be the amount that BP claimed was leaking out for the last month even though the video clearly shows large amounts of oil still leaking out that is not being captured! So they basically lied for a whole month and refused to allow anyone independent confirmation of their claims. According to the article when asked about the discrepancy Mark Proegler said and I quote, " Proegler said the 210,000 gallons--5,000 barrels--has always been just an estimate because there is no way to measure how much is spilling from the seafloor." Now they tell us! Just how much has actually gushed out we will never know because BP went out of their way to block any independent verifications and got away with this because of the passivity of the Obama administration. We are totally in the dark here. This is scary.
While it is true that the various steps they have taken to seal the well including container domes and insertion tubes have not done much to seal the oil coming out of the riser pipe it looks like the next step will be something called the top kill. This involves pumping heavy fluids down a 2-3 inch lines inside the wellhead. If this is successful the fluids will stop the oil flow temporarily to allow the operators to seal it with cement. If this is successful supposedly the well will never be used again. Why did they wait this long for this step? BP says that they were waiting for diagnostic tests to be completed concerning pressure readings to insure that the injections did not make matters worse. If the top kill fails then all bets are off. There is something called the "junk shot" which shoots golf balls and rubber shards inside the pipe to temporarily stop the oil flow while allowing a cementing of the wellhead. They are also taking 100 ideas from the general public a day into consideration! I swear I did not make that up! This is an ecological disaster and they are so clueless that they are asking the public for ideas! You would think that they would've figured this out themselves ahead of time. Makes me feel confident. If these procedures do not work then we are in for a long summer. While efforts to stop the oil flow have been a failure there is one thing they have done that would appear on the surface (no pun intended) to have worked. That is the use of dispersants to prevent the oil from reaching the surface and fouling shorelines and wildlife. Large oil slicks on the surface would attract the media and make for a lot more coverage than this disaster seems to be getting right now. Out of sight out of mind which is good for BP and the Obama administration.
The problem is that the use of these dispersants on this massive a scale in water as deep as the Gulf has never been tried before and carry many risks, many of which will show up later on. The purpose of the dispersants is to break up the oil into much smaller pieces which are easier for microbes to digest and break down. These dispersants are molecules that look like a snake. The head likes the water and the tail likes the oil. It is important to note these dispersants do not remove oil from the water but remove it from the surface. They embed themselves between the oil and the water and prevent the oil and water molecules from clinging to themselves. As of today close to 600,000 gallons of dispersants have been dumped into the Gulf and counting. The effect of this which has never been done before is what has many biologists very concerned. Up until recently the dispersants were released onto the surface by helicopters. Recently BP got permission from the EPA to go to the source of the oil flow and use undersea robots to apply the dispersants, a procedure that has never been tried before. While in the short run at least this protects the shoreline (there are reports that heavy oil is coming onshore in Louisiana now) for the subsurface marine life it opens them up to more risks. These include shrimp and oysters and much smaller organisms. Since it has been said that 1 out of 17 people make their living in some way connected to the fishing industry down there this could have serious economic ramifications. One of the big problems that biologists are concerned about is oxygen loss in the waters of the Gulf as a result of this massive use of dispersants.
Why the concern about oxygen loss? Because the dispersants that BP has been using have been pretty effective at keeping large oil slicks off the surface, the dispersed oil is remaining underwater where large oil plumes (layers) of oil have been detected , some reportedly as large as 10 miles wide and 3 miles thick and 300 feet thick. The net effect of these oil plumes is to kill off the oxygen thereby killing sea life near the plumes. What has scientists concerned is that at the end of the day the Gulf will contain large areas that will be considered biological "dead zones". These are zones where no creatures can live because of a lack of oxygen. Another fear is that the oil will get caught up in the Gulf current and bring the oil into the coral reefs off the Florida coast where the consequences could be horrific. Because there are many currents in the Gulf no one is quite sure where the oil will end up. Low levels of dissolved oxygen are the major contributor to fish kills along with toxic spills. There are two main factors that influence the ability of water to hold oxygen. One is the temperature of the water. As the temperature rises the amount of dissolved oxygen lessens. The second factor is the total of other components in the water such as chemicals, solids and gases. These can reduce the amount of dissolved oxygen. Looking at the Gulf area in particular the dissolved oxygen level ranges from 0-13 milligrams per liter (mg/l) depending on the season (temperature) and chemistry. Fish tend to do well at over 5 mg/l. Under 5 mg/l they tend to get stunted and will try to find an area with a higher mg/l content. If the level continues to drop they obviously become more adversely affected. Specific fish have specific dissolved oxygen levels below which they cannot survive or reproduce. Below 3 mg/l fish cannot feed and often will come to the surface and push their noses out of the water and try to capture dissolved oxygen from the air. To make matters worse, the area in which the blowout occurred already has low levels of dissolved oxygen due to nutrient runoff from the Mississippi river. They have measured a 30% oxygen depletion rate near the plumes. If this continues or gets worse then the fish will die and fail to reproduce. Oxygen moves slowly from the surface to the bottom. The widespread use of dispersants inhibit the transfer of oxygen into the water because the droplets are consumed by the microbes who eat the droplets that are being formed as a result of the dispersants. This removes the oxygen from the water. As summer nears and the temperature increases the problem will only get worse. The fear is that in summer the effects of oxygen depletion will become apparent and the result could be wide areas of dead zones where there will be no life in the Gulf which will be catastrophic ecologically and economically. One problem in particular that is very troublesome is what effect this will have on the plankton that larger creatures feed on. The longer this leak continues the more likely these worst case scenarios could come to pass. One other thing that seldom gets mentioned in the press is that along with the large amounts of oil spilling out there is also large amounts of natural gas being released into the water. Natural gas, which occurs along with oil, is composed primarily of methane (CH4) which is 20 times more effective in terms of trapping heat in the atmosphere than carbon dioxide in a 100 year period. It is fortunate that at the moment there is not that much of it in the atmosphere although that could change as the Russian permafrost continues to melt. Given that methane is harmful in the atmosphere what is the effect of all this methane in the water? I have not seen much discussion on this but I have to believe that this is not something that will be benign.
As if the use of the dispersants were not enough of a problem, there is the dispersants that BP was using until recently. The two main dispersants were two types of Corexit, a type called 9500 and the other called EC9527A. These two types were banned in the UK because they were deemed too toxic and there were better alternatives. The EPA itself conducted their own data that showed that they felt that Corexit was more toxic and less effective on south Louisiana crude than other dispersants. Corexit was used after the Valdez spill and was inked to a host of health problems relating to kidneys, livers, blood pressure and the nervous system. Of the two types used by BP, one was for the heavy oil that had been in the water for awhile and the other for the freshly released oil. One fear is their effect on the coral reefs if or when the oil comes into contact with it. Carys Mitchelmore, a profeesor at the University of Maryland, who conducted research on the effects of Corexit on coral reefs found that when exposed to oil and Corexit 9500 the coral reefs growth rate fell significantly. This was also backed up by an Israeli study that found that when six different dispersants were compared the Corexit was found to be the most toxic. So why did BP use it? BP had stockpiled large amounts of Corexit and got approval from the EPA to use it. BP claimed that Corexit was effective and "rigorously tested". One reason they used it might have been that the company that makes the stuff, a company from Naperville Illinois, called Nalco includes a former BP board member and an Exxon executive. The company's board of directors are loaded with company insiders. At one time Exxon and Nalco had a joint venture called NalcoExxon Energy Chemicals in 1994 which was ended in 2001. This does not in itself prove any malicious intent. It merely points out how interconnected the titans of industry are with each other. It is a nexus that is very powerful and tends to get what they want. Although the EPA gave BP the approval that was needed to use Corexit, after these safety concerns were raised some members of Congress led by Ed Markey (D-Mass) got the EPA to order that BP had 24 hours to come up with a less toxic and effective dispersant and 72 hours to implement the directive. That was on Wednesday the 19th. However according to a Times Picayune article on the 21st of May BP has in effect told the EPA that they will not comply with the directive. I quote from the article, "BP has told the Environmental Protection Agency that it cannot find a safe, effective and available dispersant to use instead of Corexit, and will continue to use that chemical application to help break up the growing spill in the Gulf of Mexico". Later on in the article and I quote, " He did not directly address widely broadcast news reports that more than 100,000 gallons of an alternative dispersant chemical call Sea-Brat 4 was stockpiled near Houston and available for application." According to reports BP had stockpiled very large amounts of Corexit before the disaster and given the reluctance to give it up I suspect they do not want to lose out on their investment. So there you have it folks. A large multinational corporation, whose total assets are larger than the assets of many sovereign nations throughout the world, is telling the United States government to go to hell. We will see if they get away with it. Given the dismal performance of the Obama administration throughout this crisis I suspect they will. The passivity of the Obama administration in allowing to allow BP to pretty much call the shots will be addressed in the next post.
This story would normally be filed in the news of the weird section of the Reader, which is a free weekly paper distributed in Chicago, and would be funny if it wasn't so tragic. I swear that I am not making this up! How could I? According to an article from the Mississippi Business Journal from the May 20th issue and I quote, " The state of Mississippi has received $15 million from BP PLC, which it will use to launch a new advertising campaign promoting its coastal counties. The campaign will communicate the message that the state’s beaches have not been affected by the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, which followed an April 20 explosion aboard the BP-owned offshore drilling rig Deepwater Horizon." How considerate of them.
Read the articles here: These deal with the controversy over Corexit and dispersant use.
http://www.gpb.org/news/2010/05/17/uga-researcher-warns-of-deep-water-impact-from-gulf-spill http://www.energyboom.com/emerging/basics-oil-spill-dispersants and http://www.propublica.org/ion/blog/item/In-Gulf-Spill-BP-Using-Dispersants-Banned-in-UK. This is a post from Climate Progress: http://climateprogress.org/2010/05/06/bp-dispersants-toxic-corexit-nalco/. These deal with the back and forth between BP and the EPA concerning Corexit: http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2010/05/bp_is_sticking_with_its_disper.html and http://views.washingtonpost.com/climate-change/post-carbon/2010/05/epa_demands_less_toxic_dispersant.html. This is the article about BP and their offer to promote tourism in Mississippi: http://memphis.bizjournals.com/memphis/stories/2010/05/17/daily17.html. Special mention must be made of the coverage at Firedoglake blog which has been spectacular. Read it here http://firedoglake.com/.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
BP and the oil spill
Unless you live in a cave you are no doubt aware of the April 20th oil well explosion that sunk the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig killing 11 people and led to a massive oil leak that shows no signs of abating anytime soon. While BP claims that the oil is leaking at a rate of 5,000 barrels a day independent observers who have studied a video that was finally released over the stonewalling of BP and the Obama administration are convinced that the oil leak is much bigger than that, possibly on the order of up to 25,000 to 80,000 barrels a day. Whatever the real amount is it also appears that a new video that was shot a couple days ago seems to show that a new leak has opened up. It is clear to me based on the research and reading that I have been doing on this blowout that it is worse than the 5,000 barrels that BP is claiming and that BP is clueless on how to stop this thing, relying on a host of ad hoc solutions that have done little to stem the problem. I am also convinced that BP cut corners here to rush this oil well to market and that they relied on government regulators who looked the other way while this was going on. Now that disaster has struck it is also clear that they and the Obama administration are looking for ways to try to minimize the full extent of the damage. The whole thing is pretty disgusting. The more I look into this the more funny this thing smells. I will try to lay out the evidence for my suspicions in a series of posts on this blowout over the next several days. I suspect this story will have legs. Lots of them.
Every day seems to bring new revelations and new stories that suggest that not all is well with the official story of BP. Today USA Today ran a story that confirms what anybody who has watched this sorry debacle with their head out of their ass could have told you. BP was not prepared for this. According to the USA Today article and I quote, " An emergency response plan prepared by BP shows the British energy giant never anticipated an oil spill as large as the one seeping through the Gulf of Mexico. The 582-page document, titled "Regional Oil Spill Response Plan — Gulf of Mexico," was approved in July by the federal Minerals Management Service (MMS). It offers technical details on how to use chemical dispersants and provides instructions on what to say to the news media, but it does not mention how to react if a deep-water well spews oil uncontrollably." The article goes on, " Most of the techniques recently attempted by BP to contain the spewing well — from a 100-ton containment device that didn't work to a mile-long tube aimed at piping out the spewing oil — are not mentioned in the plan.
"These oil spill response plans suffer from what I would consider a 'failure of imagination,' " said Rep. Nick Rahall, D-W.Va., chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, which is investigating federal oversight of oil spills. "It seems to me that there should be a Plan B, C and D in place before the accident occurs, not created in haste while millions of gallons of oil are spewing into the Gulf." An oil spill response plan must be filed with the MMS, the agency that regulates oil companies, and details how a company will deal with potential spills, said David Dismukes, associate executive director of the Center for Energy Studies at Louisiana State University." Again from the article, " Parts of the document read like boilerplate used by BP from region to region and underscore the energy company's inability to adequately prepare for a major spill in deep water, said Rick Steiner, a former University of Alaska marine scientist and oil spill response consultant who has reviewed the plan. In a section titled "Sensitive Biological & Human-Use Resources," the plan lists "seals, sea otters and walruses" as animals that could be impacted by a Gulf of Mexico spill — even though no such animals live in the Gulf." It is clear that because of the greater depth at which this oil was being drilled the challenges were greater. Because a lot of the original wells in the Gulf which were closer to shore and not as deep are running dry there is pressure to bring more of the deep water oil to market. This is much riskier because of the greater water pressure, the higher oil temperature and the greater streeses on the metals. Clearly this was something that they did not have much experiance with and the only way they could troubleshoot problems that could arise would be by computer simulations. They do not seem to have much of a clue of what would happen if something went seriously wrong, thinking no doubt that nothing would. Deep water drilling is risky business and the fact that they did not have any plan to deal with a blowout of this magnitude should have raised alarm bells off at MMS, if we had regulators doing their job instead of signing off on everything that industry tells them to do. What good is regulation if the regulators don't regulate? This incestuous relationship between federal regulatory agencies and the industries they are supposed to regulate has to stop. If regulators are controlled by the people they regulate it just feeds into the right wing/corporate narrative of how regulation is a waste of time and harmful to the economy. Republicans have loaded up the regulatory agencies for some time with hacks who let the financial/industrial elites do whatever they want at the same time that they get paid out of our tax dollars to allow this to happen. Then as a result of this carelessness disaster strikes in the form of this blowout or the financial crash of 2008 we get stuck with the bill. If the review by the MMS was in July then this would have been during the Obama administration. Not good. Considering the potential damage that could result it should have behooved the MMS to be a bit more aggressive in pushing BP to provide better answers to what they intended to do in the case of a serious accident. There is more though.
According to an Associated Press story from May 13th, shades of Rose Marie Woods, it seems that there is a seven hour gap missing from that day's reports that were a part of the daily record of what was being done that were routinely kept. Whether this was because of the accident or a cover up I will leave to the reader to decide. I quote from the article, " Yet there are no records of a critical safety test supposedly performed during the fateful hours before the Deepwater Horizon oil rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico ....The gap poses a mystery for investigators: What decisions were made -- and what warnings might have been ignored? Earlier tests, which suggested that explosive gas was leaking from the mile-deep well, were preserved. "There is some delay in the replication of our data, so our operational data, our sequence of events ends at 3 o'clock in the afternoon on the 20th," Steven Newman, president and CEO of Transocean Ltd, told a Senate panel. The rig blew up at 10 p.m., killing 11 workers and unleashing a gusher that has spewed millions of gallons (liters) of oil into the Gulf. Houston attorney Tony Buzbee, who represents several rig workers involved in the accident, questioned whether what he called "the phantom test" was even performed. "I can just tell you that the Halliburton hands were scratching their heads," said Buzbee, whose clients include one of the Halliburton crew members responsible for cementing the well to prepare for moving the drilling rig to another site." The article continues later on, " Rigs like Deepwater Horizon keep a daily drilling report. It is the version of that report given to Congress that cuts off at 3 p.m. The log confirms that three pressure tests, conducted from the morning to the early afternoon of April 20, indicated unseen underground leakage into the well. But there is no mention of a fourth test that BP and Transocean say was conducted and that they say indicated it was safe to proceed. In the hours leading up to the explosion, workers finished pumping cement into the exploratory well to bolster and seal it against leaks until a later production phase. After the tests that indicated leakage, workers debated the next step and eventually decided to resume work, for reasons that remain unclear." How convenient for Transocean and BP that a record of that fourth "phantom test" does not exist. The article continues," At the same time, heavy drilling fluid -- or mud -- was being pumped out of a pipe rising to the surface from the wellhead, further whittling the well's defenses. It was replaced with lighter seawater in preparation for dropping a final blob of cement into the well as a temporary plug for the pipe. When underground gas surged up uncontrollably through the well, desperate rig workers tried to cap it with a set of supersized emergency cutoff valves known as a blowout preventer. However, the device was leaking hydraulic fluid and missing at least one battery, and one of its valves had been swapped with a useless testing part. Problems with the blowout preventer might have been a moot issue had someone not decided to continue offloading the drilling mud. This discussion gets rather technical and I don't pretend to be expert enough in these kinds of things to fully understand everything that is being said however at the end of the day it is clear that bad decisions were made, both in real time and in the readiness of this system to perform its function (the missing battery and valve on the blowout preventer). As of today I have seen little mention in the mainstream press about the things that I have just written about. There is more.
According to Jason Leopald, writing in Truthout on May 18th, a whistleblower who had been employed as a contractor by BP on one of their other rigs in the Gulf claims that they broke federal laws and failed to maintain their own internal standards concerning the engineering and safety documents they are supposed to keep. I quote from the article, " The whistleblower, whose name has been withheld at the person's request because the whistleblower still works in the oil industry and fears retaliation, first raised concerns about safety issues related to BP Atlantis, the world's largest and deepest semi-submersible oil and natural gas platform, located about 200 miles south of New Orleans, in November 2008. Atlantis, which began production in October 2007, has the capacity to produce about 8.4 million gallons of oil and 180 million cubic feet of natural gas per day." This well is much larger than the Deepwater Horizon well and one can only imagine what the consequences would be if this operation went south. Yet it would appear that BP is cutting corners here too. The article continues," It was then that the whistleblower, who was hired to oversee the company's databases that housed documents related to its Atlantis project, discovered that the drilling platform had been operating without a majority of the engineer-approved documents it needed to run safely, leaving the platform vulnerable to a catastrophic disaster that would far surpass the massive oil spill that began last week following a deadly explosion on a BP-operated drilling rig.
BP's own internal communications show that company officials were made aware of the issue and feared that the document shortfalls related to Atlantis "could lead to catastrophic operator error" and must be addressed. Indeed, according to an August 15, 2008, email sent to BP officials by Barry Duff, a member of BP's Deepwater Gulf of Mexico Atlantis Subsea Team, the Piping and Instrument Diagrams (P&IDs) for the Atlantis subsea components "are not complete" and "there are hundreds if not thousands of subsea documents that have never been finalized, yet the facilities have been" up and running. P&IDs documents form the foundation of a hazards analysis BP is required to undertake as part of its Safety and Environmental Management Program related to its offshore drilling operations. P&IDs drawings provide the schematic details of the project's piping and process flows, valves and safety critical instrumentation. "The risk in turning over drawings that are not complete are: 1) The Operator will assume the drawings are accurate and up to date," said Duff's email to BP officials Bill Naseman and William Broman, the existence of which was revealed earlier today, but is being detailed here for the first time. "This could lead to catastrophic Operator errors due to their assuming the drawing is correct. Turning over incomplete drawings to the Operator for their use is a fundamental violation of basic Document control, [internal standards] and Process Safety Regulations." BP did not respond to repeated requests for comment for this story. Despite the claims that BP did not maintain proper documentation related to Atlantis, federal regulators authorized an expansion of the drilling project." So the largest rig in the Gulf is up and running on the basis of incomplete Piping and Instrument Diagrams. Wonderful. The argument will be made by BP and their defenders that because the whistleblower is anonymous he/she should not be trusted. While that argument can be valid so can the other argument that he/she is a whistlblower because this information would damage some very important people and if the identity of the whistleblower became known he/she would find it next to impossible to find employment in this field again. Based on what I know and am learning daily I tend to trust what the whistlblower is saying. If this information is true it is a bombshell. While the chances of another blowout happening are slim, based on what I am reading here it cannot be discounted. If it were to happen, based on the response we have seen so far, the consequences would be horrific. One of the arguments that proponents make in favor of off shore drilling is that the chances of a catastrophe are next to impossible and in the event a "black swan" event (an event whose chances of occuring are so remote that one does not factor it into your risk anaylsis) the fallout could be managed. Like the financial collapse of the international banking system in 2008, another supposed "black swan" event, reality has a way of blowing these assumptions out of the water. Instead of making the argument that because the chances of a catastrophic event happening as a result of deep water drilling are so slim perhaps the better argument is even if that is the case if a catastrophic event does occur will it be so costly both economically and ecologically that we should forego it in the first place and work on coming up with a better alternative? Unfortunatley the oil companies have so much power that the question is seldom phrased in that manner. We are paying for it now.
Read the articles here: http://www.truthout.org/whistlelower-bps-other-offshore-drilling-project-gulf-vulnerable-catastrophe59027. http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2010/05/seven_hours_of_data_missing_fr.html and this http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-05-17-oil-spill-gulf_N.htm.
Every day seems to bring new revelations and new stories that suggest that not all is well with the official story of BP. Today USA Today ran a story that confirms what anybody who has watched this sorry debacle with their head out of their ass could have told you. BP was not prepared for this. According to the USA Today article and I quote, " An emergency response plan prepared by BP shows the British energy giant never anticipated an oil spill as large as the one seeping through the Gulf of Mexico. The 582-page document, titled "Regional Oil Spill Response Plan — Gulf of Mexico," was approved in July by the federal Minerals Management Service (MMS). It offers technical details on how to use chemical dispersants and provides instructions on what to say to the news media, but it does not mention how to react if a deep-water well spews oil uncontrollably." The article goes on, " Most of the techniques recently attempted by BP to contain the spewing well — from a 100-ton containment device that didn't work to a mile-long tube aimed at piping out the spewing oil — are not mentioned in the plan.
"These oil spill response plans suffer from what I would consider a 'failure of imagination,' " said Rep. Nick Rahall, D-W.Va., chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, which is investigating federal oversight of oil spills. "It seems to me that there should be a Plan B, C and D in place before the accident occurs, not created in haste while millions of gallons of oil are spewing into the Gulf." An oil spill response plan must be filed with the MMS, the agency that regulates oil companies, and details how a company will deal with potential spills, said David Dismukes, associate executive director of the Center for Energy Studies at Louisiana State University." Again from the article, " Parts of the document read like boilerplate used by BP from region to region and underscore the energy company's inability to adequately prepare for a major spill in deep water, said Rick Steiner, a former University of Alaska marine scientist and oil spill response consultant who has reviewed the plan. In a section titled "Sensitive Biological & Human-Use Resources," the plan lists "seals, sea otters and walruses" as animals that could be impacted by a Gulf of Mexico spill — even though no such animals live in the Gulf." It is clear that because of the greater depth at which this oil was being drilled the challenges were greater. Because a lot of the original wells in the Gulf which were closer to shore and not as deep are running dry there is pressure to bring more of the deep water oil to market. This is much riskier because of the greater water pressure, the higher oil temperature and the greater streeses on the metals. Clearly this was something that they did not have much experiance with and the only way they could troubleshoot problems that could arise would be by computer simulations. They do not seem to have much of a clue of what would happen if something went seriously wrong, thinking no doubt that nothing would. Deep water drilling is risky business and the fact that they did not have any plan to deal with a blowout of this magnitude should have raised alarm bells off at MMS, if we had regulators doing their job instead of signing off on everything that industry tells them to do. What good is regulation if the regulators don't regulate? This incestuous relationship between federal regulatory agencies and the industries they are supposed to regulate has to stop. If regulators are controlled by the people they regulate it just feeds into the right wing/corporate narrative of how regulation is a waste of time and harmful to the economy. Republicans have loaded up the regulatory agencies for some time with hacks who let the financial/industrial elites do whatever they want at the same time that they get paid out of our tax dollars to allow this to happen. Then as a result of this carelessness disaster strikes in the form of this blowout or the financial crash of 2008 we get stuck with the bill. If the review by the MMS was in July then this would have been during the Obama administration. Not good. Considering the potential damage that could result it should have behooved the MMS to be a bit more aggressive in pushing BP to provide better answers to what they intended to do in the case of a serious accident. There is more though.
According to an Associated Press story from May 13th, shades of Rose Marie Woods, it seems that there is a seven hour gap missing from that day's reports that were a part of the daily record of what was being done that were routinely kept. Whether this was because of the accident or a cover up I will leave to the reader to decide. I quote from the article, " Yet there are no records of a critical safety test supposedly performed during the fateful hours before the Deepwater Horizon oil rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico ....The gap poses a mystery for investigators: What decisions were made -- and what warnings might have been ignored? Earlier tests, which suggested that explosive gas was leaking from the mile-deep well, were preserved. "There is some delay in the replication of our data, so our operational data, our sequence of events ends at 3 o'clock in the afternoon on the 20th," Steven Newman, president and CEO of Transocean Ltd, told a Senate panel. The rig blew up at 10 p.m., killing 11 workers and unleashing a gusher that has spewed millions of gallons (liters) of oil into the Gulf. Houston attorney Tony Buzbee, who represents several rig workers involved in the accident, questioned whether what he called "the phantom test" was even performed. "I can just tell you that the Halliburton hands were scratching their heads," said Buzbee, whose clients include one of the Halliburton crew members responsible for cementing the well to prepare for moving the drilling rig to another site." The article continues later on, " Rigs like Deepwater Horizon keep a daily drilling report. It is the version of that report given to Congress that cuts off at 3 p.m. The log confirms that three pressure tests, conducted from the morning to the early afternoon of April 20, indicated unseen underground leakage into the well. But there is no mention of a fourth test that BP and Transocean say was conducted and that they say indicated it was safe to proceed. In the hours leading up to the explosion, workers finished pumping cement into the exploratory well to bolster and seal it against leaks until a later production phase. After the tests that indicated leakage, workers debated the next step and eventually decided to resume work, for reasons that remain unclear." How convenient for Transocean and BP that a record of that fourth "phantom test" does not exist. The article continues," At the same time, heavy drilling fluid -- or mud -- was being pumped out of a pipe rising to the surface from the wellhead, further whittling the well's defenses. It was replaced with lighter seawater in preparation for dropping a final blob of cement into the well as a temporary plug for the pipe. When underground gas surged up uncontrollably through the well, desperate rig workers tried to cap it with a set of supersized emergency cutoff valves known as a blowout preventer. However, the device was leaking hydraulic fluid and missing at least one battery, and one of its valves had been swapped with a useless testing part. Problems with the blowout preventer might have been a moot issue had someone not decided to continue offloading the drilling mud. This discussion gets rather technical and I don't pretend to be expert enough in these kinds of things to fully understand everything that is being said however at the end of the day it is clear that bad decisions were made, both in real time and in the readiness of this system to perform its function (the missing battery and valve on the blowout preventer). As of today I have seen little mention in the mainstream press about the things that I have just written about. There is more.
According to Jason Leopald, writing in Truthout on May 18th, a whistleblower who had been employed as a contractor by BP on one of their other rigs in the Gulf claims that they broke federal laws and failed to maintain their own internal standards concerning the engineering and safety documents they are supposed to keep. I quote from the article, " The whistleblower, whose name has been withheld at the person's request because the whistleblower still works in the oil industry and fears retaliation, first raised concerns about safety issues related to BP Atlantis, the world's largest and deepest semi-submersible oil and natural gas platform, located about 200 miles south of New Orleans, in November 2008. Atlantis, which began production in October 2007, has the capacity to produce about 8.4 million gallons of oil and 180 million cubic feet of natural gas per day." This well is much larger than the Deepwater Horizon well and one can only imagine what the consequences would be if this operation went south. Yet it would appear that BP is cutting corners here too. The article continues," It was then that the whistleblower, who was hired to oversee the company's databases that housed documents related to its Atlantis project, discovered that the drilling platform had been operating without a majority of the engineer-approved documents it needed to run safely, leaving the platform vulnerable to a catastrophic disaster that would far surpass the massive oil spill that began last week following a deadly explosion on a BP-operated drilling rig.
BP's own internal communications show that company officials were made aware of the issue and feared that the document shortfalls related to Atlantis "could lead to catastrophic operator error" and must be addressed. Indeed, according to an August 15, 2008, email sent to BP officials by Barry Duff, a member of BP's Deepwater Gulf of Mexico Atlantis Subsea Team, the Piping and Instrument Diagrams (P&IDs) for the Atlantis subsea components "are not complete" and "there are hundreds if not thousands of subsea documents that have never been finalized, yet the facilities have been" up and running. P&IDs documents form the foundation of a hazards analysis BP is required to undertake as part of its Safety and Environmental Management Program related to its offshore drilling operations. P&IDs drawings provide the schematic details of the project's piping and process flows, valves and safety critical instrumentation. "The risk in turning over drawings that are not complete are: 1) The Operator will assume the drawings are accurate and up to date," said Duff's email to BP officials Bill Naseman and William Broman, the existence of which was revealed earlier today, but is being detailed here for the first time. "This could lead to catastrophic Operator errors due to their assuming the drawing is correct. Turning over incomplete drawings to the Operator for their use is a fundamental violation of basic Document control, [internal standards] and Process Safety Regulations." BP did not respond to repeated requests for comment for this story. Despite the claims that BP did not maintain proper documentation related to Atlantis, federal regulators authorized an expansion of the drilling project." So the largest rig in the Gulf is up and running on the basis of incomplete Piping and Instrument Diagrams. Wonderful. The argument will be made by BP and their defenders that because the whistleblower is anonymous he/she should not be trusted. While that argument can be valid so can the other argument that he/she is a whistlblower because this information would damage some very important people and if the identity of the whistleblower became known he/she would find it next to impossible to find employment in this field again. Based on what I know and am learning daily I tend to trust what the whistlblower is saying. If this information is true it is a bombshell. While the chances of another blowout happening are slim, based on what I am reading here it cannot be discounted. If it were to happen, based on the response we have seen so far, the consequences would be horrific. One of the arguments that proponents make in favor of off shore drilling is that the chances of a catastrophe are next to impossible and in the event a "black swan" event (an event whose chances of occuring are so remote that one does not factor it into your risk anaylsis) the fallout could be managed. Like the financial collapse of the international banking system in 2008, another supposed "black swan" event, reality has a way of blowing these assumptions out of the water. Instead of making the argument that because the chances of a catastrophic event happening as a result of deep water drilling are so slim perhaps the better argument is even if that is the case if a catastrophic event does occur will it be so costly both economically and ecologically that we should forego it in the first place and work on coming up with a better alternative? Unfortunatley the oil companies have so much power that the question is seldom phrased in that manner. We are paying for it now.
Read the articles here: http://www.truthout.org/whistlelower-bps-other-offshore-drilling-project-gulf-vulnerable-catastrophe59027. http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2010/05/seven_hours_of_data_missing_fr.html and this http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-05-17-oil-spill-gulf_N.htm.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Short thought for a Monday morning
Good news! I finally have a computer and an internet connection so I have no excuse anymore not to blog on a regular basis. I believe the last post was in January and given all that has happened since then, there is a lot to comment on. I look forward to doing that in the coming year. So to all of my "millions" of devoted followers I thank you for your patience and as they say in the Viagra co0mmercial- "I'm back!"
Friday, January 15, 2010
Short thoughts for a Friday morning
1) The response time on my computer this morning is awful so I will not be able to say everything that I would like but I want to briefly discuss the recent attack on an Iranian nuclear physicist in Tehran that resulted in the death of Masoud Ali Mohammadi. According to the article in the New York Times and I quote, " A remote-controlled bomb attached to a motorcycle killed an Iranian physics professor outside his home in north Tehran on Tuesday, state media reported. The reports blamed the United States and Israel for the attack." Predictably Iran blamed the United States and Israel and just as predictably the United States said that this was "nonsense". The article written by Nazila Fathi goes on to cast suspicions on the Ahmadinejad regime for the attack supposedly because Mohammadi was a member of the opposition. Fathi devotes most of the article to attacking the regime and making the case that they were responsible for the attack while ignoring any discussion or analysis as to why Israel may be the guilty party. This is typical of the Times and the Western media in general. It is a trend that I have observed starting with the contested election where just about every mainstream journalist and liberals like Juan Cole assume that the election was stolen. I on the other hand think that it is very possible that Ahmadinejad did win this election. I don't know that to be the case I merely make the case that it is a possibility. I have linked previously on this subject to polls taken before the election that showed Ahmadinejad winning and while it is assumed by many liberals and Iranian exiles that vote fraud only happened one way there is no reason to believe that Moussavi's side was blameless on this score. Ali Akbar Rafsanjani, who is the Ahmed Chalabi of Iran, was a prominant supporter of Moussavi and who had his own axe to grind with Ahmadinejad was certainly capable of organizing stolen votes of his own. Yet I do not notice this fact ever being brought up. It seems what we have here is what I call "cheerleader journalism" which means that because we want an outcome so bad and we think that outcome is morally justified we skew our reporting to reflect our biases. It is clear to me that Fathi is doing something similar in the reporting on the murder of the Iranian physicist. As Fathi well knows Israel is hell bent on denying Iran not only nuclear weapons but also what I call "the Japan option". The ability to acquire the technical and infrastructual know-how to assemble and deliver a nuclear weapon on short notice if the need arises (As in the case of an American or Israeli attack). That being the case why wouldn't Israel resort to murder to prevent this from occurring? As the region is painfully aware Israel does not believe in nor observe international law. They take whatever actions they feel they must if they feel their national security interests are at stake and they know that in just about every case they can count on the support of the United States. We know that Israel is making plans to attack Iran to take out their nuclear capabilities as I write this. We also know that the Obama administration and every one else in the region and beyond worry, justifiably so, about how this will impact the price of oil and the effect that this will have on the world economy does not want Israel to attack Iran and are hoping that sanctions and peer pressure will do the trick. Given that and the fact that this is not the first time a Iranian nuclear physicist has been killed or disappeared it should be obvious that Israel should be at the top of the list of suspects in this murder. Yet Fathi who writes for the most prestigious paper in America doesn't seem to understand this? I suspect that Fathi is very aware of the strong possibility of Israeli involvement but chooses to ignore it instead keeping the reader in ignorance. Given what we know of the Times dismal performance in the run up to the Iraq war I suspect that they are up to their old tricks. This is bad journalism and does a disservice to readers who should be more informed about what really goes on in the world. Iran considers their nuclear physicists to be a national asset and the idea that they would murder one of their own because he was a member of the opposition seems far fetched to say the least, especially if the stories are true that Mohammadi was for the most part apolitical. Storm clouds are gathering in the region as Paul Rogers discusses in his Open Democracy article that I link to and we may be reaching the end game here where Israel feels they have to strike to maintain their nuclear monopoly no matter what the consequences are for the rest of us. Read these articles that I link to because they are far more informative about what is really going on here than the shallow analysis that passes for a New York Times article. Read the Times article here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/13/world/middleeast/13iran.html?ref=world Read this series of articles by Paul Rogers from Open Democracy that goes into detail about the Iranian/Israeli/American relationship and why it is so serious. Read them here:http://www.opendemocracy.net/paul-rogers/israels-shadow-over-iran and here:http://www.opendemocracy.net/opendemocracy-general/paul-rogers/america-and-iran-big-bombs-and-base-politics and here:http://www.opendemocracy.net/article/iran-america-israel-the-nuclear-gamble. Also this article by Trita Parsi who has also written a very informative book about this strategic triangle called "Treacherous Alliance - The Secret Dealings of Iran, Israel and the United States (Yale University Press, 2007). http://www.opendemocracy.net/democracy-irandemocracy/israel_2974.jsp Finally Glenn Greenwald thoughts on this topic: http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/01/12/iran_scientist/index.html
Sunday, January 3, 2010
More short thoughts
1) Last week of football and another season of futility for the Chicago Bears. When my team is out of the hunt I try to find another team to root for. This is not that easy this season. I could go for the Broncos because I like Kyle Orton and felt like the Bears never game him a chance here but I'm not even sure they are in the hunt. I like to watch New England but I really dislike their coach so that is out. I like this years edition of the Vikings with Favre however they have not played that well in the last couple of games and perhaps Favre will start to show his age in the playoffs. Oh well I know one thing- I wish the worst for the Indianapolis Colts. I really do!
2) I cannot let the Blackwater story go without linking to this article that appeared last month in the New York Times. It details how involved these guys were in Iraq in the critical years from 2004-2006. I quote from the article, "Five former Blackwater employees and four current and former American intelligence officials interviewed for this article would speak only on condition of anonymity because Blackwater’s activities for the agency were secret and former employees feared repercussions from the company. The Blackwater employees said they participated in the raids or had direct knowledge of them.Along with the former officials, they provided few details about the targets of the raids in Iraq and Afghanistan, although they said that many of the Iraq raids were directed against members of Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia. To corroborate the claims of the company’s involvement, a former Blackwater security guard provided photographs to The Times that he said he took during the raids. They showed detainees and armed men whom he and a former company official identified as Blackwater employees. The former intelligence officials said that Blackwater’s work with the C.I.A. in Iraq and Afghanistan had grown out of its early contracts with the spy agency to provide security for the C.I.A. stations in both countries." I remember one of the major networks showed video of these house raids where they would kick down doors humiliate and scare the crap out of these families, many of whom probably were not guilty of anything other than resenting the occupation. I remember thinking to myself if I was in their shoes if I wasn't an insurgent before I probably would be now or I would at least help the ones out who were. When people are subject to humiliation they are not going to be your friends. Blackwater who was immune from prosecution could do a lot of the things that our military had to be more careful about. They were perfect for these kinds of raids. Along with the systemic torture and humiliation that went on in Abu Ghraib, the kind of things that make neo-cons and right wingers hearts go ga-ga over, this did not pass unnoticed by the Iraqi population. Take a look at the dates that this went on. 2004-2006. Now look and see when the insurgency against American troops started to kick in. Think there was a correlation here? Huh? As I try to point out to these angry emotional right wing types who can't get enough torture and humiliation to satisfy them actions have consequences. When you treat people like shit and you are in their country you can't very well expect them to respect you. I often wonder how many ordinary Iraqi citizens suffered at the hands of these kinds of operations that did not deserve to and as a result of this how many American soldiers came home in a box or without one of their limbs. There is a casual chain here. One of the many problems our culture has is that we do not practice empathy here. We seldom put ourselves in other peoples shoes and try to see how I would view the world if I was them. It is why we are always so quick condone torture, more wars and a loss of civil liberties here so we can show that we are "tough" on terror. Obviously this did not work in Iraq in 2004-2006 did it? Unfortunately it is next to impossible to get this point across to the hot heads who think along these lines. It is hard to argue with hardliners who are emotional and angry and are looking for blood. They are oblivious to the effect that these policies will have on their target audience out there in the rest of the world. Nor do they care about international law or in the words of Obama's man in Afghanistan Stanley McChrystal quaint things like the Geneva convention. Beat the crap out of them and that will do the trick say these people and even if it doesn't it will make the hotheads feel better. Meanwhile in the long run we just create more enemies. We play checkers while Al-Queda plays chess. I am not saying that we should do nothing here. Obviously we have a problem with an element of Islam that veers toward extremism. However, and this may come as a news flash to the hotheads and neo-cons who want to make Islam the enemy, most Muslims do not have these attitudes although they are fed up with American foreign policy. We could save ourselves a boatload of money here and pursue a more intelligent strategy if we went about this the old fashioned way through the sharing of intelligence and police networks around the world. The way we are pursuing the war on terror, and you can see it in the media frenzy over the latest attempted attack, is to ensure that we will be fighting "the war on terror" as long as the money holds out. Eventually the money will run out and we will have to pack it in and admit that the empire is busted. In the meanwhile to pay for the guns we will take away the butter for people here and we will continue to see an erosion of our civil liberties, all because a bunch of cowards are so scared of the possibility of a terror attack that they think that by curtailing our freedoms we will have perfect security. That will never happen and even if it was possible it would mean we were a police state. That is not the America I signed up for thank you. This is not Stalin's Soviet Union or Mao's China where the government watches your every move and as a result you have very low crime statistics. I'm big and I'm tough enough to put up with the occasional terror attack and not throw away our values. Are you? Read the article about Blackwater here:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/11/us/politics/11blackwater.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all
2) I cannot let the Blackwater story go without linking to this article that appeared last month in the New York Times. It details how involved these guys were in Iraq in the critical years from 2004-2006. I quote from the article, "Five former Blackwater employees and four current and former American intelligence officials interviewed for this article would speak only on condition of anonymity because Blackwater’s activities for the agency were secret and former employees feared repercussions from the company. The Blackwater employees said they participated in the raids or had direct knowledge of them.Along with the former officials, they provided few details about the targets of the raids in Iraq and Afghanistan, although they said that many of the Iraq raids were directed against members of Al Qaeda in Mesopotamia. To corroborate the claims of the company’s involvement, a former Blackwater security guard provided photographs to The Times that he said he took during the raids. They showed detainees and armed men whom he and a former company official identified as Blackwater employees. The former intelligence officials said that Blackwater’s work with the C.I.A. in Iraq and Afghanistan had grown out of its early contracts with the spy agency to provide security for the C.I.A. stations in both countries." I remember one of the major networks showed video of these house raids where they would kick down doors humiliate and scare the crap out of these families, many of whom probably were not guilty of anything other than resenting the occupation. I remember thinking to myself if I was in their shoes if I wasn't an insurgent before I probably would be now or I would at least help the ones out who were. When people are subject to humiliation they are not going to be your friends. Blackwater who was immune from prosecution could do a lot of the things that our military had to be more careful about. They were perfect for these kinds of raids. Along with the systemic torture and humiliation that went on in Abu Ghraib, the kind of things that make neo-cons and right wingers hearts go ga-ga over, this did not pass unnoticed by the Iraqi population. Take a look at the dates that this went on. 2004-2006. Now look and see when the insurgency against American troops started to kick in. Think there was a correlation here? Huh? As I try to point out to these angry emotional right wing types who can't get enough torture and humiliation to satisfy them actions have consequences. When you treat people like shit and you are in their country you can't very well expect them to respect you. I often wonder how many ordinary Iraqi citizens suffered at the hands of these kinds of operations that did not deserve to and as a result of this how many American soldiers came home in a box or without one of their limbs. There is a casual chain here. One of the many problems our culture has is that we do not practice empathy here. We seldom put ourselves in other peoples shoes and try to see how I would view the world if I was them. It is why we are always so quick condone torture, more wars and a loss of civil liberties here so we can show that we are "tough" on terror. Obviously this did not work in Iraq in 2004-2006 did it? Unfortunately it is next to impossible to get this point across to the hot heads who think along these lines. It is hard to argue with hardliners who are emotional and angry and are looking for blood. They are oblivious to the effect that these policies will have on their target audience out there in the rest of the world. Nor do they care about international law or in the words of Obama's man in Afghanistan Stanley McChrystal quaint things like the Geneva convention. Beat the crap out of them and that will do the trick say these people and even if it doesn't it will make the hotheads feel better. Meanwhile in the long run we just create more enemies. We play checkers while Al-Queda plays chess. I am not saying that we should do nothing here. Obviously we have a problem with an element of Islam that veers toward extremism. However, and this may come as a news flash to the hotheads and neo-cons who want to make Islam the enemy, most Muslims do not have these attitudes although they are fed up with American foreign policy. We could save ourselves a boatload of money here and pursue a more intelligent strategy if we went about this the old fashioned way through the sharing of intelligence and police networks around the world. The way we are pursuing the war on terror, and you can see it in the media frenzy over the latest attempted attack, is to ensure that we will be fighting "the war on terror" as long as the money holds out. Eventually the money will run out and we will have to pack it in and admit that the empire is busted. In the meanwhile to pay for the guns we will take away the butter for people here and we will continue to see an erosion of our civil liberties, all because a bunch of cowards are so scared of the possibility of a terror attack that they think that by curtailing our freedoms we will have perfect security. That will never happen and even if it was possible it would mean we were a police state. That is not the America I signed up for thank you. This is not Stalin's Soviet Union or Mao's China where the government watches your every move and as a result you have very low crime statistics. I'm big and I'm tough enough to put up with the occasional terror attack and not throw away our values. Are you? Read the article about Blackwater here:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/11/us/politics/11blackwater.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all
Saturday, January 2, 2010
Thoughts to kick off a new year!
1) Happy New Year! Hopefully 2010 will be better than 2009. Time will tell. My resolution for the new year is to get my own computer so I can blog on a more steady basis. Hopefully the finances will be better this year. The year may be new but the same old problems remain with no end in sight. Some reflections and comments:
2) It seems that those five Blackwater employees who were on trial for the killing of 17 Iraqi civilians have had their case dismissed for prosecutorial misconduct. According to this New York Times article and I quote, "In a significant blow to the Justice Department, a federal judge on Thursday threw out the indictment of five former Blackwater security guards over a shooting in Baghdad in 2007 that left 17 Iraqis dead and about 20 wounded.The judge cited misuse of statements made by the guards in his decision, which brought to a sudden halt one of the highest-profile prosecutions to arise from the Iraq war. The shooting at Nisour Square frayed relations between the Iraqi government and the Bush administration and put a spotlight on the United States’ growing reliance on private security contractors in war zones.....In a “reckless violation of the defendants’ constitutional rights,” the judge wrote, investigators, prosecutors and government witnesses had inappropriately relied on statements that the guards had been compelled to make in debriefings by the State Department shortly after the shootings. The State Department had hired the guards to protect its officials." It seems that after the shootings the State Department debriefed the Blackwater employees and took testimony that they claimed had to be given but that would not be used against them later on. However the prosecutors did use these statements in their case against the employees. Again I quote, "The guards could not be prosecuted under Iraqi law because of an immunity agreement that had been signed by the Coalition Provisional Authority, the governing authority installed by the United States after the invasion of Iraq. But American prosecutors knew from the beginning that they were facing a difficult task in bringing the case. Complications included the applicability of federal statutes to the guards because they were working overseas at the time for the State Department, and the significant problem stemming from statements the guards gave shortly after the shootings. The guards had been told by State Department investigators that they could be fired if they did not talk about the case, but that whatever they said would not be used against them in any criminal proceeding. Nevertheless, Judge Urbina found that “in their zeal to bring charges,” investigators and prosecutors had extensively used those statements, disregarding “the warning of experienced, senior prosecutors” that “the course of action threatened the viability of prosecution.” The money quote here is that the prosecutors disregarded the warnings of experienced senior prosecutors that the course of action threatened the viability of the prosecution. So why did they do it? This story brings out many of the reasons that I dislike the mainstream/corporate media so much. This story has not been covered very much to begin with and when it is the obvious questions do not seem to be asked. Such as given that the Bush administration hired Blackwater and gave them immunity from Iraqi prosecution the idea that the Bush justice department was going to seriously go after these guys was a stretch to many of us who think the Bush justice department was one of the most politicized and dishonest since the Nixon administration. That being the case did it ever occur to these clowns who make up your media that perhaps the Bush justice department bungled this on purpose? That they were not interested in convicting them to begin with? Ya think? However the media have not pursued this angle. Blackwater is despised in Iraq for what is perceived as their reckless disregard for the citizens of Iraq. It got so bad that the government of Iraq asked them to leave. Predictably the Iraqis are not too happy that the case has been dropped. It is unlikely the case can be appealed. One can be sure that this will fire up more anti-American attitudes around the world. By becoming so dependant on these private security contractors who operate as a law unto themselves we make it easier for Al-Queda groups to find new recruits for global jihad. Contrary to what the right would have you believe actions have consequences. American policies do make a difference in the way that Muslims view the world. The knee-jerk support we give Israel, the invasion and occupation of Iraq, the torture and the use of trigger happy private contractors like Blackwater who are immune from any accountability piss just about all Muslims around the world off. Thankfully most do not let their anger drive them into the arms of Al-Queda like organizations but along the way some will give in, no doubt aided by this kind of crap. In the New York Times article concerning the Iraqi reaction a man named Abdul Wahab Adul Khader is quoted. He says, "What are we — not human. Why do they have the right to kill people? Is our blood so cheap? For America, the land of justice and law, what does it mean to let criminals go?” After the last eight years especially, few people take our rhetoric about human rights and the rule of law seriously. Only gullible Americans who do not take the time to really get informed about the world and what we do buy into this. Read the article about the dismissal here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/01/us/01blackwater.html Read about the Iraqi reaction here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/02/us/02blackwater.html?hp Read about the Iraqi decision to revoke Blackwater's license here:http://www.mcclatchydc.com/iraq/story/61018.html
2) It seems that those five Blackwater employees who were on trial for the killing of 17 Iraqi civilians have had their case dismissed for prosecutorial misconduct. According to this New York Times article and I quote, "In a significant blow to the Justice Department, a federal judge on Thursday threw out the indictment of five former Blackwater security guards over a shooting in Baghdad in 2007 that left 17 Iraqis dead and about 20 wounded.The judge cited misuse of statements made by the guards in his decision, which brought to a sudden halt one of the highest-profile prosecutions to arise from the Iraq war. The shooting at Nisour Square frayed relations between the Iraqi government and the Bush administration and put a spotlight on the United States’ growing reliance on private security contractors in war zones.....In a “reckless violation of the defendants’ constitutional rights,” the judge wrote, investigators, prosecutors and government witnesses had inappropriately relied on statements that the guards had been compelled to make in debriefings by the State Department shortly after the shootings. The State Department had hired the guards to protect its officials." It seems that after the shootings the State Department debriefed the Blackwater employees and took testimony that they claimed had to be given but that would not be used against them later on. However the prosecutors did use these statements in their case against the employees. Again I quote, "The guards could not be prosecuted under Iraqi law because of an immunity agreement that had been signed by the Coalition Provisional Authority, the governing authority installed by the United States after the invasion of Iraq. But American prosecutors knew from the beginning that they were facing a difficult task in bringing the case. Complications included the applicability of federal statutes to the guards because they were working overseas at the time for the State Department, and the significant problem stemming from statements the guards gave shortly after the shootings. The guards had been told by State Department investigators that they could be fired if they did not talk about the case, but that whatever they said would not be used against them in any criminal proceeding. Nevertheless, Judge Urbina found that “in their zeal to bring charges,” investigators and prosecutors had extensively used those statements, disregarding “the warning of experienced, senior prosecutors” that “the course of action threatened the viability of prosecution.” The money quote here is that the prosecutors disregarded the warnings of experienced senior prosecutors that the course of action threatened the viability of the prosecution. So why did they do it? This story brings out many of the reasons that I dislike the mainstream/corporate media so much. This story has not been covered very much to begin with and when it is the obvious questions do not seem to be asked. Such as given that the Bush administration hired Blackwater and gave them immunity from Iraqi prosecution the idea that the Bush justice department was going to seriously go after these guys was a stretch to many of us who think the Bush justice department was one of the most politicized and dishonest since the Nixon administration. That being the case did it ever occur to these clowns who make up your media that perhaps the Bush justice department bungled this on purpose? That they were not interested in convicting them to begin with? Ya think? However the media have not pursued this angle. Blackwater is despised in Iraq for what is perceived as their reckless disregard for the citizens of Iraq. It got so bad that the government of Iraq asked them to leave. Predictably the Iraqis are not too happy that the case has been dropped. It is unlikely the case can be appealed. One can be sure that this will fire up more anti-American attitudes around the world. By becoming so dependant on these private security contractors who operate as a law unto themselves we make it easier for Al-Queda groups to find new recruits for global jihad. Contrary to what the right would have you believe actions have consequences. American policies do make a difference in the way that Muslims view the world. The knee-jerk support we give Israel, the invasion and occupation of Iraq, the torture and the use of trigger happy private contractors like Blackwater who are immune from any accountability piss just about all Muslims around the world off. Thankfully most do not let their anger drive them into the arms of Al-Queda like organizations but along the way some will give in, no doubt aided by this kind of crap. In the New York Times article concerning the Iraqi reaction a man named Abdul Wahab Adul Khader is quoted. He says, "What are we — not human. Why do they have the right to kill people? Is our blood so cheap? For America, the land of justice and law, what does it mean to let criminals go?” After the last eight years especially, few people take our rhetoric about human rights and the rule of law seriously. Only gullible Americans who do not take the time to really get informed about the world and what we do buy into this. Read the article about the dismissal here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/01/us/01blackwater.html Read about the Iraqi reaction here:http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/02/us/02blackwater.html?hp Read about the Iraqi decision to revoke Blackwater's license here:http://www.mcclatchydc.com/iraq/story/61018.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)