1) Trying to get over a nasty flu and staying out at mom's gives me an opportunity to get on the computer (I don't have one in Chicago which is why my posts are less frequent nowadays) and blog a little. A nice post today by Juan Cole on the Iranian nuclear issue. I agree that what Iran is aiming for is the "Japan option". What this means is that Japan does not possess nuclear weapons at this time. However , in the event of an emergency they being a very technologically sophisticated country and having mastered the fuel enrichment cycle could build a weapon on short notice. This seems to me to be what Iran is ultimately up to. The argument that is frequently given is that one reason Iran wants to enrich uranium is to lessen their dependence on their own oil reserves so they are able to sell it on the open market where it is a cash cow and allowing them to be independent to some extant of the Western led neo-liberal economic model makes sense to some extent. However I do not believe that is the only or the main reason. Nuclear power will not replace gasoline in the automobile. It can replace fuel oil used in electricity but I wonder how much electricity at the present time is oil based. Also Iran is sitting on top of massive reserves of natural gas which substitutes very nicely for oil in electricity generation. No, I suspect that the main reason Iran wants to enrich uranium is just in case they find themselves threatened by an outside power (Israel or the US) if need be they can build a weapon or two on short notice. In the comment section of Cole's post is this excellent letter from an Arnold Evans that puts this issue in perspective and makes some great points. It is worth reprinting in its entirety.
"Very well put.You assert that having nuclear latency is nearly as valuable as having an actual weapon.I agree, but you don't explain exactly why, and it may not be obvious.If Iraq had gotten a Japan option, then over the months-long period that the US was amassing an invasion force in Kuwait in late 2002, early 2003, Hussein at that point would have produced a weapon.What that means is that if the US believed Hussein could build a weapon, it would never have massed its troops for an invasion as that would have been a waste of time since they'd have to disband once Iraq announced or even hinted its nuclear weapon was complete.(Despite a program of calculated deception, there was no doubt at all in the minds of US military planners that Hussein could not field a nuclear weapon.)An Iranian nuclear latency or Japan option would render Iran invasion-proof. And take forcible regime change off the table permanently. It would also provide a lot of deterrence for any plan to even attack Iran from the air.John Bolton went on Jon Stewart's daily show and said that if Serbia had been nuclear capable, the West would not have been able to get regime change. Bolton is right, but I wonder if he realizes how that sounds to Iranian planners.The first Israeli nightmare is not that Iran will bomb Tel Aviv or Jerusalem, but that once Iran knows it will not be invaded or even bombed, it will feel free to offer more support to the Palestinians and to pressure Egypt and other Arab countries to do the same.The second Israeli nightmare is that once Egypt and Saudi Arabia see that Iran has achieved immunity to US bombings or invasion without making unpopular concessions to the project of Zionism, they will want the same deterrence. Once they get it, their domestically costly policies of cooperation with Israel will be less useful. These countries, whose cooperation Israel needs to remain viable as a Jewish state may follow the wishes of their people and become more hostile to Zionism.(Contrary to reports of rivalry with Iran, Iran has publicly offered to share its nuclear technology with any Muslim state. Saudi or Egyptian nuclear latency threaten Israel and make those states less dependent on the US, which is good from Iran's point of view.)Knowledgeable supporters of Zionism, such as France's Sarkozy, Israel's Netanyahu and many US political figures are lying, not mistaken but lying, when they declare the danger of Iran getting a nuclear weapon.The threat of an Iranian bomb is more emotionally compelling than the threat of an Iranian "Japan option". An Iranian bomb is also illegal unless Iran leaves the NPT, while a Japan option is not.But the true threat, and everybody knowledgeable knows it, is that Iran gets a Japan option. This is a great letter and really gets down to it. The point he makes about Iraq is one that I seldom see brought up but gets right to the point. If the US really believed that Iraq had or could field a nuclear weapon then the build up of forces in the Gulf in late 2002 and early 2003 would have been a waste of time because Saddam at the last moment could have pulled a rabbit out of his hat and declared that he had several nuclear weapons ready for delivery and the game would have been up. In fact it is clear to me that the US was certain beyond any reasonable doubt that Hussein did not have this capability. The war was a lie from beginning to end. This is why the Iranian nuclear issue has Israel and the US so nervous. They know that if Iran achieves the Japan option the geopoltical chessboard in the Middle East is suddenly rearranged-and not in a favorable way for either the US or especially Israel. As Evans points out in his letter the real fear in Israel is not that Iran will drop a nuke on Tel Aviv but rather that Iran knowing that they will be more secure from an attack will be able to increase their support for the Palestinians and to prod other countries in the region such as Egypt and Saudi Arabia to do the same. Which is why as of late all the horror stories are appearing in the Washington Post and the New York Times about the evils of the Iranian enrichment program. This is serious stuff. An attack on the nuclear facilities of Iran in the foreseeable future is a very real possibility. It will of course destroy any chance of an economic recovery and suck us back into the black hole that is the Middle East. It will become the moment when the American people finally wake up and realize that the game is up. That we cannot afford to be an empire anymore. But the people who will want to attack anyway may figure that is the risk we have to take. Let us hope more sober minds prevail here. Read the article here:http://www.juancole.com/2009/10/iran-and-nuclear-latency.html#comments
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)