Unless you live in a cave you are no doubt aware of the April 20th oil well explosion that sunk the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig killing 11 people and led to a massive oil leak that shows no signs of abating anytime soon. While BP claims that the oil is leaking at a rate of 5,000 barrels a day independent observers who have studied a video that was finally released over the stonewalling of BP and the Obama administration are convinced that the oil leak is much bigger than that, possibly on the order of up to 25,000 to 80,000 barrels a day. Whatever the real amount is it also appears that a new video that was shot a couple days ago seems to show that a new leak has opened up. It is clear to me based on the research and reading that I have been doing on this blowout that it is worse than the 5,000 barrels that BP is claiming and that BP is clueless on how to stop this thing, relying on a host of ad hoc solutions that have done little to stem the problem. I am also convinced that BP cut corners here to rush this oil well to market and that they relied on government regulators who looked the other way while this was going on. Now that disaster has struck it is also clear that they and the Obama administration are looking for ways to try to minimize the full extent of the damage. The whole thing is pretty disgusting. The more I look into this the more funny this thing smells. I will try to lay out the evidence for my suspicions in a series of posts on this blowout over the next several days. I suspect this story will have legs. Lots of them.
Every day seems to bring new revelations and new stories that suggest that not all is well with the official story of BP. Today USA Today ran a story that confirms what anybody who has watched this sorry debacle with their head out of their ass could have told you. BP was not prepared for this. According to the USA Today article and I quote, " An emergency response plan prepared by BP shows the British energy giant never anticipated an oil spill as large as the one seeping through the Gulf of Mexico. The 582-page document, titled "Regional Oil Spill Response Plan — Gulf of Mexico," was approved in July by the federal Minerals Management Service (MMS). It offers technical details on how to use chemical dispersants and provides instructions on what to say to the news media, but it does not mention how to react if a deep-water well spews oil uncontrollably." The article goes on, " Most of the techniques recently attempted by BP to contain the spewing well — from a 100-ton containment device that didn't work to a mile-long tube aimed at piping out the spewing oil — are not mentioned in the plan.
"These oil spill response plans suffer from what I would consider a 'failure of imagination,' " said Rep. Nick Rahall, D-W.Va., chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, which is investigating federal oversight of oil spills. "It seems to me that there should be a Plan B, C and D in place before the accident occurs, not created in haste while millions of gallons of oil are spewing into the Gulf." An oil spill response plan must be filed with the MMS, the agency that regulates oil companies, and details how a company will deal with potential spills, said David Dismukes, associate executive director of the Center for Energy Studies at Louisiana State University." Again from the article, " Parts of the document read like boilerplate used by BP from region to region and underscore the energy company's inability to adequately prepare for a major spill in deep water, said Rick Steiner, a former University of Alaska marine scientist and oil spill response consultant who has reviewed the plan. In a section titled "Sensitive Biological & Human-Use Resources," the plan lists "seals, sea otters and walruses" as animals that could be impacted by a Gulf of Mexico spill — even though no such animals live in the Gulf." It is clear that because of the greater depth at which this oil was being drilled the challenges were greater. Because a lot of the original wells in the Gulf which were closer to shore and not as deep are running dry there is pressure to bring more of the deep water oil to market. This is much riskier because of the greater water pressure, the higher oil temperature and the greater streeses on the metals. Clearly this was something that they did not have much experiance with and the only way they could troubleshoot problems that could arise would be by computer simulations. They do not seem to have much of a clue of what would happen if something went seriously wrong, thinking no doubt that nothing would. Deep water drilling is risky business and the fact that they did not have any plan to deal with a blowout of this magnitude should have raised alarm bells off at MMS, if we had regulators doing their job instead of signing off on everything that industry tells them to do. What good is regulation if the regulators don't regulate? This incestuous relationship between federal regulatory agencies and the industries they are supposed to regulate has to stop. If regulators are controlled by the people they regulate it just feeds into the right wing/corporate narrative of how regulation is a waste of time and harmful to the economy. Republicans have loaded up the regulatory agencies for some time with hacks who let the financial/industrial elites do whatever they want at the same time that they get paid out of our tax dollars to allow this to happen. Then as a result of this carelessness disaster strikes in the form of this blowout or the financial crash of 2008 we get stuck with the bill. If the review by the MMS was in July then this would have been during the Obama administration. Not good. Considering the potential damage that could result it should have behooved the MMS to be a bit more aggressive in pushing BP to provide better answers to what they intended to do in the case of a serious accident. There is more though.
According to an Associated Press story from May 13th, shades of Rose Marie Woods, it seems that there is a seven hour gap missing from that day's reports that were a part of the daily record of what was being done that were routinely kept. Whether this was because of the accident or a cover up I will leave to the reader to decide. I quote from the article, " Yet there are no records of a critical safety test supposedly performed during the fateful hours before the Deepwater Horizon oil rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico ....The gap poses a mystery for investigators: What decisions were made -- and what warnings might have been ignored? Earlier tests, which suggested that explosive gas was leaking from the mile-deep well, were preserved. "There is some delay in the replication of our data, so our operational data, our sequence of events ends at 3 o'clock in the afternoon on the 20th," Steven Newman, president and CEO of Transocean Ltd, told a Senate panel. The rig blew up at 10 p.m., killing 11 workers and unleashing a gusher that has spewed millions of gallons (liters) of oil into the Gulf. Houston attorney Tony Buzbee, who represents several rig workers involved in the accident, questioned whether what he called "the phantom test" was even performed. "I can just tell you that the Halliburton hands were scratching their heads," said Buzbee, whose clients include one of the Halliburton crew members responsible for cementing the well to prepare for moving the drilling rig to another site." The article continues later on, " Rigs like Deepwater Horizon keep a daily drilling report. It is the version of that report given to Congress that cuts off at 3 p.m. The log confirms that three pressure tests, conducted from the morning to the early afternoon of April 20, indicated unseen underground leakage into the well. But there is no mention of a fourth test that BP and Transocean say was conducted and that they say indicated it was safe to proceed. In the hours leading up to the explosion, workers finished pumping cement into the exploratory well to bolster and seal it against leaks until a later production phase. After the tests that indicated leakage, workers debated the next step and eventually decided to resume work, for reasons that remain unclear." How convenient for Transocean and BP that a record of that fourth "phantom test" does not exist. The article continues," At the same time, heavy drilling fluid -- or mud -- was being pumped out of a pipe rising to the surface from the wellhead, further whittling the well's defenses. It was replaced with lighter seawater in preparation for dropping a final blob of cement into the well as a temporary plug for the pipe. When underground gas surged up uncontrollably through the well, desperate rig workers tried to cap it with a set of supersized emergency cutoff valves known as a blowout preventer. However, the device was leaking hydraulic fluid and missing at least one battery, and one of its valves had been swapped with a useless testing part. Problems with the blowout preventer might have been a moot issue had someone not decided to continue offloading the drilling mud. This discussion gets rather technical and I don't pretend to be expert enough in these kinds of things to fully understand everything that is being said however at the end of the day it is clear that bad decisions were made, both in real time and in the readiness of this system to perform its function (the missing battery and valve on the blowout preventer). As of today I have seen little mention in the mainstream press about the things that I have just written about. There is more.
According to Jason Leopald, writing in Truthout on May 18th, a whistleblower who had been employed as a contractor by BP on one of their other rigs in the Gulf claims that they broke federal laws and failed to maintain their own internal standards concerning the engineering and safety documents they are supposed to keep. I quote from the article, " The whistleblower, whose name has been withheld at the person's request because the whistleblower still works in the oil industry and fears retaliation, first raised concerns about safety issues related to BP Atlantis, the world's largest and deepest semi-submersible oil and natural gas platform, located about 200 miles south of New Orleans, in November 2008. Atlantis, which began production in October 2007, has the capacity to produce about 8.4 million gallons of oil and 180 million cubic feet of natural gas per day." This well is much larger than the Deepwater Horizon well and one can only imagine what the consequences would be if this operation went south. Yet it would appear that BP is cutting corners here too. The article continues," It was then that the whistleblower, who was hired to oversee the company's databases that housed documents related to its Atlantis project, discovered that the drilling platform had been operating without a majority of the engineer-approved documents it needed to run safely, leaving the platform vulnerable to a catastrophic disaster that would far surpass the massive oil spill that began last week following a deadly explosion on a BP-operated drilling rig.
BP's own internal communications show that company officials were made aware of the issue and feared that the document shortfalls related to Atlantis "could lead to catastrophic operator error" and must be addressed. Indeed, according to an August 15, 2008, email sent to BP officials by Barry Duff, a member of BP's Deepwater Gulf of Mexico Atlantis Subsea Team, the Piping and Instrument Diagrams (P&IDs) for the Atlantis subsea components "are not complete" and "there are hundreds if not thousands of subsea documents that have never been finalized, yet the facilities have been" up and running. P&IDs documents form the foundation of a hazards analysis BP is required to undertake as part of its Safety and Environmental Management Program related to its offshore drilling operations. P&IDs drawings provide the schematic details of the project's piping and process flows, valves and safety critical instrumentation. "The risk in turning over drawings that are not complete are: 1) The Operator will assume the drawings are accurate and up to date," said Duff's email to BP officials Bill Naseman and William Broman, the existence of which was revealed earlier today, but is being detailed here for the first time. "This could lead to catastrophic Operator errors due to their assuming the drawing is correct. Turning over incomplete drawings to the Operator for their use is a fundamental violation of basic Document control, [internal standards] and Process Safety Regulations." BP did not respond to repeated requests for comment for this story. Despite the claims that BP did not maintain proper documentation related to Atlantis, federal regulators authorized an expansion of the drilling project." So the largest rig in the Gulf is up and running on the basis of incomplete Piping and Instrument Diagrams. Wonderful. The argument will be made by BP and their defenders that because the whistleblower is anonymous he/she should not be trusted. While that argument can be valid so can the other argument that he/she is a whistlblower because this information would damage some very important people and if the identity of the whistleblower became known he/she would find it next to impossible to find employment in this field again. Based on what I know and am learning daily I tend to trust what the whistlblower is saying. If this information is true it is a bombshell. While the chances of another blowout happening are slim, based on what I am reading here it cannot be discounted. If it were to happen, based on the response we have seen so far, the consequences would be horrific. One of the arguments that proponents make in favor of off shore drilling is that the chances of a catastrophe are next to impossible and in the event a "black swan" event (an event whose chances of occuring are so remote that one does not factor it into your risk anaylsis) the fallout could be managed. Like the financial collapse of the international banking system in 2008, another supposed "black swan" event, reality has a way of blowing these assumptions out of the water. Instead of making the argument that because the chances of a catastrophic event happening as a result of deep water drilling are so slim perhaps the better argument is even if that is the case if a catastrophic event does occur will it be so costly both economically and ecologically that we should forego it in the first place and work on coming up with a better alternative? Unfortunatley the oil companies have so much power that the question is seldom phrased in that manner. We are paying for it now.
Read the articles here: http://www.truthout.org/whistlelower-bps-other-offshore-drilling-project-gulf-vulnerable-catastrophe59027. http://www.nola.com/news/gulf-oil-spill/index.ssf/2010/05/seven_hours_of_data_missing_fr.html and this http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-05-17-oil-spill-gulf_N.htm.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment