1) On occasion you will hear it be said by defenders of BP and those who would like to minimize the damage that is being done on the Gulf region by this spill that there have always been leaks, natural leaks that over time have leaked large amounts of oil into the Gulf and that over time the Gulf has adapted to this and it will to this latest man made disaster. It has been estimated that over the course of a year natural seeps of oil, which occur as a result of fissures that allow oil and gas to seep into the water, release between 560,000 to around 1,400,000 barrels of oil a year throughout the Gulf. This would be equivalent to around 1,500 to 3,800 barrels a day. Over time it seems that the ecosystem of the Gulf has developed a way to adjust to this and inoculate itself. However what is critical to note here is the concentration of the oil and not just the total quantity spread throughout the whole Gulf. While true that over thousands of years bacteria evolved that are able to eat up the released oil what we are talking about here is a whole different animal. The amount of oil being released per day and the concentration of it adds a whole new dimension to what would naturally occur. It should be noted that natural seeps are not constantly active. The volume can vary throughout the day and hence only a small area close to the seep is exposed to the most toxic non-degraded oil. Very different from what is going on as I write. Clearly what is going on right now threatens to overwhelm the natural coping mechanisms that are in place to deal with a natural leak. This has led some people to suggest that one response to this disaster would be to release large additional amounts of oil eating bacteria into the Gulf to take care of the spill. The response to this is that these microbes also suck up dissolved oxygen along with the oil thereby setting up an additional set of problems. The question of oxygen levels is a serious one. The big question for many researchers now is what is the effects on oxygen depletion as a result of the oil plumes that have developed as a result of the widespread use of the dispersants BP is using?
Unfortunately there does not seem to be as much research into what is happening with the plumes as there should be. I have posted previously about this. Clearly though what is going on down here is the elephant in the room. One would think that the Obama administration would give it a more urgent priority. One person who is concerned about this issue is Dr. Samantha Joyce who writes for the blog Gulf Oil Blog and has done research into the plumes. She has been out conducting research in the Gulf on the plumes and describes her experiences in a travel log. At the same time she answers some questions that people have about the effects of the spill on the surrounding ecosystem. Concerning the dissolved oxygen levels she says and I quote, "How serious is the oxygen depletion problem? Potentially, this is a very serious problem. At present, oxygen concentrations exceed 2 mg/L but if concentrations drop below that, it would spell problems for any oxygen requiring organisms. The Southwest Plume is, at a minimum, 15 miles long x 2 miles long and the plume is about 600 feet thick. Temperatures in the plume are about 8-12ÂșC. We do not know the absolute oil content at this time. The plume is largely water. This is not thick oil like you see on the surface in some places, it’s diluted oil and it’s most concentrated closest to the leaking riser pipe. Unlike a natural oil seep, which is most intense on the bottom and whose signal decreases with depth above the seafloor, the plume we are studying starts 200m above the seafloor and its intensity decreases horizontally with distance away from the leaking wellhead. The specific gravity of oil is irrelevant to this discussion. This is not oil like you buy at the auto supply store. Think of it as gas-saturated oil that has been shot out of a deep sea cannon under intense pressure – it’s like putting olive oil in a spray can, pressurizing it and pushing the spray button. What comes out when you push that button? A mist of olive oil. This well is leaking a mist of oil that is settling out in the deep sea." She goes on to say that there is significant respiration going on in the plumes, 5-10 times higher than usual. The conditions are very good for the microbes to ingest the oil droplets but that as of today they do not know enough about whether the toxicity levels of what the microbes are consuming will prove detrimental later on. Remember that crude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons, compounds made of hydrogen and carbon. These compounds vary. Some are simple like methane which is one carbon atom and four hydrogen atoms (CH4). Some are much more complex with over 40 or so carbon atoms. In addition, crude oil also has compounds that contain sulfur, oxygen, nitrogen along with metals such as iron, nickle and copper. There are also traces of mineral salts. This means that not all crude oil is the same. Some are better quality than others. There is heavy oil which contains a lot of impurities like metals and salts and sweet crude which is short on sulfur. When making gasoline for your automobile the light sweet kind is the one that is normally preferred. Dr. Bill Chameides of Duke has a blog called the Green Grog and he discusses the toxicity of the oil spilling into the Gulf. He assumes that it is light sweet crude. He focuses on one group of toxins called Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAC's) that he finds particularly worrisome. I quote from the article, " A wide array of toxic chemicals is found in oil — and in gasoline by the way, so be careful when you fill your tank and definitely try not to breathe in the fumes. Let’s focus here on one of those toxins: polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). PAHs are compounds where the carbon atoms are arrayed in a series of six-sided hexagons called rings.A 2003 study by the National Academy of Sciences found that of all the typical hydrocarbons in crude oil, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) pose the greatest risk to the environment.There are at least three things that make PAHs worrisome: They are linked to cancer and other health problems, including fertility, reproductive and developmental issues, in both humans and wildlife.They are soluble in water so can be mobilized into the environment.They can persist in the environment where chronic exposure can cause long-term damage and even mortality at very low concentrations. In fact, these are the toxins that have been implicated in the slow recovery of the Bristol Bay ecosystems after the Valdez spill.Here’s a rough estimate of how much PAH contamination has been released into the gulf from the Deepwater disaster.Estimated metric tons of PAHs from the Deepwater rig spill as of May 19, 2010: 270-3,300 *For comparison:Estimated metric tons of PAHs from the two World Trade Towers' collapse: 100 and 1,000 Estimated metric tons of PAHs [pdf] emitted yearly in the United States as air pollution: 8,600-32,000That’s right — if not capped soon, the amount of PAHs put into the Gulf of Mexico may approach the amount of PAHs we put into the atmosphere across the entire United States over an entire year. Better get your gulf shrimp and oysters while you can." Remember that those totals were as of May 19th. As I write this it is June 18th and the estimated flow rate has been increased substantially since then and the leak continues. Also remember that the dispersants that are being used contain many toxins (although it seems that Nalco. the manufacturer, has gone out of its way to hide what is in there- read here: http://www.naturalnews.com/028974_Corexit_dispersants.html). Also remember that Corexit has been shown to be one of the most dangerous of the dispersants in terms of toxicity and you combine that with the PAH's and the other toxins in crude oil and you are playing with fire. Scary stuff indeed. Read the Gulf Oil Blog here: http://gulfblog.uga.edu/ and the Green Grog blog here: http://nicholas.duke.edu/thegreengrok/gulfspill-pahs. These articles discuss natural oil leaks in the Gulf. http://www.theoildrum.com/node/6552 and http://blogs.chron.com/sciguy/archives/2010/06/debunking_the_myth_that_natural_seeps_are_just_as_1.html.
Thursday, June 17, 2010
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Short thought for a Wednesday
1) The numbers just keep going up! From today's New York Times comes new figures on the estimated amount of oil that is spilling into the Gulf. I quote from the article, " A government panel on Tuesday released yet another estimate of the amount of oil flowing from BP’s damaged well, declaring that as much as 60,000 barrels a day could be spewing into the Gulf of Mexico. That is roughly 2.5 million gallons of oil a day, and it means an amount equal to the Exxon Valdez spill could be gushing from the well about every four days." Remember that BP claims to be capturing around 15,000 barrels a day with their containment device and that means something on the order of 45,000 barrels a day are leaking out. I quote again from the article, " The new estimate is far above the figure of 5,000 barrels a day that the government and BP clung to for weeks after the spill started, following the April 20 explosion of the Deepwater Horizon oil rig. That estimate was made by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration using methods not recommended for large oil spills, and it came under attack from professors and advocacy groups who said the spill had to be larger. Time has proven those critics right. The latest estimate reflects a possible increase in the flow rate that occurred after BP cut an underwater pipe called a riser on June 3 to install a new device to capture part of the oil. It is based on new information, including high-resolution video made after the riser cut, and on pressure readings taken by a device that was inserted this week into the equipment at the sea floor. Energy Secretary Steven Chu, a Nobel Prize-winning scientist, was personally involved in using those pressure readings to help make the latest calculation. “This estimate brings together several scientific methodologies and the latest information from the sea floor, and represents a significant step forward in our effort to put a number on the oil that is escaping from BP’s well,” Secretary Chu said in a statement. “As we continue to collect additional data and refine these estimates, it is important to realize that the numbers can change.” BP cut the riser pipe on June 3rd, although the original cut did not go as planned and instead of a clean cut with diamond wire saw they had to cut the pipe with shears that did not leave as clean a cut and made it more difficult to put the containment pipe over the spill possibly contributing to an increase in flow. BP plans to have the relief wells ready in August, so until then the oil will flow unabated. If the relief wells do not do the trick, then what? Read the article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/16/us/16spill.html?hp
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
Short thoughts for a Tuesday
1) An article in the New York Times from June 14, 2010 provides evidence that BP did willingly cut corners in their rush to get the Deepwater Horizon well completed. This backs up what I tried to prove in my previous posts. The article lists several things that BP did to save time and money and compromise safety to get the well completed on time. According to the article the well was already behind schedule and in March they had applied for a bypass whereby a well is drilled around a problem area. By the day of the blowout, April 20th, the rig which was leased from Transocean at one half a million dollars a day plus contracting fees, was 43 days late for its next drilling operation. It would seem that it was this delay that led to a series of hasty and fatal decisions that resulted in the blowout whose effects we are still trying to get a handle on. One of the bad decisions was to use what is called a tapered string casing design which costs about 7-10 million dollars less than other methods but offers less protection if the cementing job is poor and gas were to rise up the well. Casing refers to the pipe that is assembled and then inserted into a recently drilled borehole and then held in place by cement. It helps to perform a variety of functions that facilitates the drilling operation. Although using this method saved BP money it also meant that the well had only two barriers to an upward gas flow that could cause a blowout. One was cement near the bottom of the well and a steel assembly near the top. Unfortunately the company made bad decisions regarding cementing. In regards to the cementing, BP used fewer centralizers, devices that make sure that the final string of casing is centered in the well hole and ensures that cement flows evenly around the casing. BP used only six instead of the twenty one that were recommended by the cement contractor Haliburton (yep! Those guys!). Haliburton had warned BP of severe gas flow problems. According to the article on April 16th in an internal e-mail a BP official complained that it would take 10 hours to do this and he didn't like this. In addition it turns out that BP did not fully circulate heavy drilling mud through the well , because that would have taken an additional 12 hours, before they started the cement job. The American Petroleum Institute recommends full circulation to reduce the possibility that the mud will contaminate the cement and contribute to failure. BP also failed to order a cement band log, which is a testing procedure that would have evaluated the quality of the cement barrier which had already been shown by computer model run by BP to be of poor quality. A company called Schlumberger was tasked with this job but on the morning of the blowout the projected test was cancelled and the Schlumberger employees were sent home. The test would have taken an additional 12 hours. You can read the Times article here: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/15/science/earth/15rig.html?hp
2) I wrote in one of my previous posts on this Gulf oil blowout that this story would have legs. I didn't know it would have this many! From the LA Times comes this story that goes into some detail about how companies get around US safety inspections by registering these off shore rigs, which are considered ships under international law, with foreign countries whose safety and maintenance rules are easily circumvented or nonexistent. It turns out that the Deepwater Horizon rig is registered to that bastion of tough environmental and occupational safety inspections...the Marshall Islands! This is a tiny impoverished group of atolls many of which are smaller than the Deepwater rig itself! Because these rigs are classified as foreign vessels the Coast Guard will conduct a cursory inspection and rely on the safety reports that are prepared by the outside firms that are often paid directly by the owner of the vessel. Minerals and Management Service is responsible for what goes on "below the waterline" but not for what occurs on the top including staffing decisions and command structure. It is this command and staffing structure that may have helped contribute to the blowout. According to Donald Brown who has been a chief mechanic on the rig since it was built in 2000, there has been a gradual reduction of manpower over the years. This has led to dual command structure whereby on the day of the explosion an oil drilling expert made critical decisions ahead of a licensed sea captain. John Konrad, who is a licensed sea captain and who writes a maritime blog, said that oil rigs should be under the command of a licensed sea captain. It turns out that on the Deepwater Horizon the oil drilling expert made the decisions about safety. This kind of dual command system would not be permitted on a US flagged operation. Offshore rigs like the Deepwater Horizon float above the well connected by thousands of pipes and are kept in place by elaborate navigational systems hence the need for an experienced sea captain. Read the LA Times article here: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-oil-inspection-20100615,0,7349376.story and access John Konrad's maritime blog here: http://gcaptain.com/
2) I wrote in one of my previous posts on this Gulf oil blowout that this story would have legs. I didn't know it would have this many! From the LA Times comes this story that goes into some detail about how companies get around US safety inspections by registering these off shore rigs, which are considered ships under international law, with foreign countries whose safety and maintenance rules are easily circumvented or nonexistent. It turns out that the Deepwater Horizon rig is registered to that bastion of tough environmental and occupational safety inspections...the Marshall Islands! This is a tiny impoverished group of atolls many of which are smaller than the Deepwater rig itself! Because these rigs are classified as foreign vessels the Coast Guard will conduct a cursory inspection and rely on the safety reports that are prepared by the outside firms that are often paid directly by the owner of the vessel. Minerals and Management Service is responsible for what goes on "below the waterline" but not for what occurs on the top including staffing decisions and command structure. It is this command and staffing structure that may have helped contribute to the blowout. According to Donald Brown who has been a chief mechanic on the rig since it was built in 2000, there has been a gradual reduction of manpower over the years. This has led to dual command structure whereby on the day of the explosion an oil drilling expert made critical decisions ahead of a licensed sea captain. John Konrad, who is a licensed sea captain and who writes a maritime blog, said that oil rigs should be under the command of a licensed sea captain. It turns out that on the Deepwater Horizon the oil drilling expert made the decisions about safety. This kind of dual command system would not be permitted on a US flagged operation. Offshore rigs like the Deepwater Horizon float above the well connected by thousands of pipes and are kept in place by elaborate navigational systems hence the need for an experienced sea captain. Read the LA Times article here: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-oil-inspection-20100615,0,7349376.story and access John Konrad's maritime blog here: http://gcaptain.com/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)