I have been reading and hearing a lot of talk recently about how we are going to be in Iraq a lot longer than people have been led to believe. Now this article appears in the Washington Post by Thomas Ricks a man who is pretty familiar with Iraq. Correct me if I am wrong but didn't Bush sign a Status of Forces Agreement government shortly before he left office saying that all our troops will be out by 2011. Why does Ricks and all the people he quotes in this article ignore this. It is not mentioned once. Read this from the article:
"I don't think the Iraq war is over, and I worry that there is more to come than any of us suspect. A smaller but long-term U.S. military presence in Iraq is probably the best we can hope for. The thought of having small numbers of U.S. troops dying for years to come in the country's deserts and palm groves isn't appealing, but it appears to be better than either being ejected or pulling out -- and letting the genocidal chips fall where they may."
Ricks goes on to quote others:
"Many worried that as the United States withdraws and its influence wanes, the Iraqi tendency toward violent solutions will increase. In September 2008, John McCreary, a veteran analyst for the Defense Intelligence Agency, predicted that the arrangement imposed by the U.S. government on Iraqi factions should worry us for several reasons. First, it produces what looks like peace -- but isn't. Second, one of the factions in such situations will invariably seek to break out of the arrangement. "Power sharing is always a prelude to violence," usually after the force imposing it withdraws, he maintained.
Many of those closest to the situation in Iraq expect a full-blown civil war to break out there in the coming years. "I don't think the Iraqi civil war has been fought yet," one colonel told me. Others were concerned that Iraq was drifting toward a military takeover. Counterinsurgency expert David Kilcullen worried that the classic conditions for a military coup were developing -- a venal political elite divorced from the population lives inside the Green Zone, while the Iraqi military outside the zone's walls grows both more capable and closer to the people, working with them and trying to address their concerns.
In addition, the American embrace of former insurgents has created many new local power centers in Iraq, but many of the faces of those who run them remain obscure. "We've made a lot of deals with shady guys," Col. Michael Galloucis, the Military Police commander in Baghdad, said in 2007, at the end of his tour. "It's working. But the key is, is it sustainable?"
Then this at near the end of the article:
"The quiet consensus emerging among many who have served in Iraq is that U.S. soldiers will probably be engaged in combat there until at least 2015 -- which would put us at about the midpoint of the conflict now."
Thomas Ricks is a smart guy with a lot of contacts so if he is writing about this there must be something to it. Many liberals/progressives mistakenly believe that Obama is pulling out all troops in 16 months. That is not what he said. He said he would pull out most combat troops but leave a residual force for counter-terrorism efforts and any other unspecified reasons. But all these military people Ricks is quoting and the Obama crowd seem to be ignoring the fact that Iraq signed an agreement and are under the impression that by 2011 it is bye-bye US. If that is not the case many people will be upset. In case any one noticed Iraq just had provincial elections and Malicki's party did very well. They ran as a nationalist party not a narrow sectarian party and even pulled in some Sunni votes. I would suspect one of the reasons he did so well was because of the SOFA agreement. If the US does not follow through on this agreement Malicki has an opportunity to unite the Sunnis and Shiites for the first time since our invasion. We have not faced a united opposition as of yet but that could happen if we ignore the SOFA. If this thing heats up again at the same time that we escalate Afghanistan and possibly deal with a destabilized Pakistan I don't see how we can afford it let alone how our military which is already stretched to the limit will be able to handle this added load. At some point in time we will have to come to some kind of an arrangement with Iran about Iraq and get out. It is the only way. This is a black hole that will only suck us in deeper and deeper.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment