Wednesday, February 25, 2009

The derivatives mess

If you are confused by what is really going on in the economy I came across this post that does an excellent job of explaining the credit default swaps and the collateralized debt obligations to the average person who does not have an economics degree and is not privy to the language of the economic "experts" written by someone who bills herself as "the other Katherine Harris"!





http://dandelionsalad.wordpress.com/2009/02/18/exclusive-derivatives-for-dummies-by-the-other-katherine-harris/ Some thoughts:





1) I seldom hear anyone in the media talk about credit default swaps and the centrality of them in our economic meltdown. I watched the Frontline special on PBS that dealt with the chronology of the meltdown leading up to the passage of the TARP. It was made clear that when Paulsen decided to let Lehman Brothers fail this triggered all kinds of financial obligations that AIG had to pay based on these swaps. Hence the bailout. Yet Paulsen who is supposed to be a financial hot shot seemed to be unaware of the implications of what would happen when Lehman went under. If according to the Bank for International Settlements using the best guess they have that there are potentially 1.6 quadrillion dollars of potential liabilities here, that is more money than there is in the world!! (Unless you start printing money recklessly creating hyperinflation) One has to wonder that if AIG was knee deep in this crap who else is? How many banks and insurance companies are tied down with this. Which leads to my next point.





2) Most of these swaps are private affairs. They are not registered on a public market. There is no transparency here. This would help explain why many of the largest banks will not lend to each other. They don't trust the others balance sheet because they know how tied in they are in this. Remember I am talking only about the credit default swaps here and am ignoring the collateralized debt obligations which is another land mine. Until we get at the bottom of who owes what and who is holding what all the money in the world Obama wants to throw at Wall Street will not get us out of this mess. However if Paulsen himself seemed to be unaware of the impact of these things on allowing Lehman Brothers collapse I am not optimistic we will get to the bottom of this. This is the 800 pound gorilla in the room that will work against any resolution of this crisis.





3) The only way out of this mess is to declare ALL credit default swaps null and void. No doubt this will not go over well with Wall Street but that is too bad. These things were reckless from the get go. To quote from the article:


"but imagine that your payoff depends on the failure of a company, a currency or a country. The weaker your target is perceived to be, as reflected by the cost of default insurance on its debt, the closer you move toward your ultimate goal. So you and your friends will do all you can to drive that cost up and make the world fully aware of it, including buying and selling CDS contracts openly. This makes the rising cost apparent and you can count on the rating agencies to take notice swiftly. Their downgrade will become the death-knell.
Therein lies another great problem with Credit Default Swaps. They work exactly like short-selling and rumor-mongering (which CDS owners may well be doing, too) to create self-fulfilling prophecies."

In other words these bets can become self-fulfilling prophesies where to make money you actively engage in the failure of the institution you have a bet on and the American public pays for it. THIS IS NUTS!!! Declaring these swaps null and void will not solve our economic mess but will be a good first step in containing the damage. This should have been in Obama's speech last night.

No comments:

Post a Comment