Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Nawaz Sharif

In a previous post I made reference to a conversation Richard Holbrooke, our point man for Southeast Asia, had with Nawaz Sharif who is Pakistans most popular opposition politician and twice headed the government in the 90's. I said this:

"One other item in Shazads report struck my attention. According to the article Holbrooke met with Nawaz Sharif to get him to drop his support for the lawyers movement against the government because this could destabilize the government. So just like the Bush administration before it the Obama administration will join in a long line of US administrations that look the other way to Pakistani democracy."

Now this from the LA Times: http://http//www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/world/la-fg-pakistan26-2009feb26,0,1360310.story The relevant paragraphs: "The Supreme Court today banned the country's most popular opposition politician, former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, from holding elected office, a verdict that could trigger prolonged political upheaval in Pakistan.Sharif's supporters angrily protested the ruling, saying they do not recognize the legitimacy of the high court. They repeated demands for the reinstatement of the former chief justice and other senior judges dismissed by ex-President Pervez Musharraf in late 2007 during a bout of de facto martial law." Some thoughts:



1) This is a bad decision. I very much doubt that the high court of Pakistan would pass this without the United States being aware of it and approving this. Obviously Holbrooke's talk with Sharif did not go well. According to the Chicago Tribune the reason given had to do with criminal charges that were brought against Sharif when he tried to prevent Pervez Musharraf from overthrowing him back in 1999. However Sharif was able to compete in the most recent elections and with the death of Benazir Bhutto is probably the most popular politician in Pakistan right now, far more popular than Benazir's widower Asif Zardari (Mr. 10%). They also banned his brother Shabaz Sharif who is currently the chief minister of the Punjab, Pakistan's most important province. As I pointed out in that previous post the Obama administration joins a long line of previous administrations who have shut the door on democracy in Pakistan starting with the Eisenhower administrations embrace of Ayub Khan in 1958 and continuing with General Zia in the 1980s, Pervez Musharraf and recently the Bush administration's heavy handed attempts at a shotgun marriage between Benazir and Pervez that helped bring about her death. Sharif claims that because this court is illegitimate so is this decision and he repeated his calls for the reinstatement of Iftiqar Chaudry and the other judges sacked by Musharraf in a blatant attempt to protect himself from a judicial ruling that might have disqualified him from power. Sharif is hypocritical here because when he was in power he tried to intimidate the court himself but regardless of his motives he is right here. The judges should be reinstated. This is what the people want and this is why they in effect voted Musharraf out of power in the last election. We bear a lot of the blame here for the sorry state of Pakistan right now because of our blatant interference over the years in Pakistan's political development. There is always some "crisis" that we use to slam the door shut on democracy in Pakistan whether it is the communist menace or the war on terror. It is no wonder anti-Americanism is at an all time high.

2)I imagine that this ruling will create a firestorm of protest and rightfully so. If Holbrooke is so concerned about the destabilization of the Pakistani government this is a strange way of showing it. Again the timing here is critical. This move comes after Holbrook's talks with Sharif and after army chief of staff Ashfaq Kiani's visit to the US. Just like every coup that occurs in Pakistan it is hard to believe that we were completely out of the loop on this. Obama needs to speak out publicly against this and soon to contain the damage. However given that Holbrooke's fingerprints are all over this I doubt that will occur. As I have said before we are playing a very dangerous game here in regards to Pakistan. By allowing this to stand it appears that we are actively trying to destabilize Pakistan thereby giving us an excuse to go in and "grab the nukes" Either that or these guys are just clueless.

No comments:

Post a Comment