Recently Barack Obama replaced his top general in Afghanistan David McKiernan with a man named Stanley McChrystal saying that the time had come to try a less traditional approach and start to develop new ways of thinking. McKiernan had only been at his post for eleven months and still had a year to go when he was released. At a Pentagon press briefing Robert Gates gave no particulars as to why McKienan was let go other than the reasons stated above. McKiernan recently asked for a troop increase of 30,000 and Obama gave him a little more than half of that, the reason being that Obama is looking for a new approach to the Af-Pak mess that does not rely primarily on traditional military means. It is said that McKiernan was also wary of conducting raids into Pakistan territory. This is something that McChrystal will have no inhibitions about doing. So just who is Stanley McChrystal and why should we care?
Let us start with the fact that Dick Cheney, who seems to be popping up just about everywhere after being incognito for the last eight years, in an interview with Fox news gave McChrystal a ringing endorsement saying, "The decision to send Stan McChrystal...is a good one. think the choice is excellent. I think you'd be hard put to find anyone better than Stan McChrystal." Considering that Cheney has little to say that is positive about the Obama administration the fact that he is warm to the McChrystal appointment should be a red flag for those of us who were appalled at the Bush-Cheney approach to fighting "the war on terror". Why is Dick Cheney warm to McChrystal? A look at the career of Stanley McChrystal gives us the answer. I knew little about this guy myself until his appointment and the more I looked into who he was the less that I liked. For starters McChrystal was the head of a super secret special operations unit that went under the name of Joint Special Operations Command or JSOC for short. He also led a group of special ops forces called Task Force 6-26 that ran their own detention camp in Iraq near Baghdad called Camp Nama where torture and bad behavior seemed to be the norm. All in the name of "the war on terror". The New York Times ran an expose on this unit back in 2006 entitled "In secret unit's black room-A grim portrait of U.S Abuse." I quote from the article, "In the windowless, jet-black garage-size room, some soldiers beat prisoners with rifle butts, yelled and spit in their faces and, in a nearby area, used detainees for target practice in a game of jailer paintball. Their intention was to extract information to help hunt down Iraq's most-wanted terrorist, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, according to Defense Department personnel who served with the unit or were briefed on its operations. The Black Room was part of a temporary detention site at Camp Nama, the secret headquarters of a shadowy military unit known as Task Force 6-26. Located at Baghdad International Airport, the camp was the first stop for many insurgents on their way to the Abu Ghraib prison a few miles away. Placards posted by soldiers at the detention area advised, "NO BLOOD, NO FOUL." The slogan, as one Defense Department official explained, reflected an adage adopted by Task Force 6-26: "If you don't make them bleed, they can't prosecute for it." According to Pentagon specialists who worked with the unit, prisoners at Camp Nama often disappeared into a detention black hole, barred from access to lawyers or relatives, and confined for weeks without charges. "The reality is, there were no rules there," another Pentagon official said." This systemic abuse occurred at the same time as Abu Ghraib and should put to rest any lingering ideas that the torture and sadism exhibited at Abu Ghraib was an anomaly. This was U.S policy folks. According to the article things has gotten so out of hand that the CIA banned its personnel from the camp and the Army and law enforcement officials in Iraq issued warnings about what was going on there. The number of personnel who worked at Camp Nama was only around 1,000 and yet a high proportion of them were punished for detainee abuse (34). No doubt this was the tip of the iceberg and I suspect many more abuses were covered up. McChrystal supplied the troops for this operation and must have been aware of what was going on. Their main mission was to get Abu Musab al-Zarqawi and it seems that they went about it with all the zeal that a Dick Cheney centered approach to fighting terror entailed. I quote again from the article, "Task Force 6-26 had a singular focus: capture or kill Mr. Zarqawi, the Jordanian militant operating in Iraq. Anytime there was even the smell of Zarqawi nearby, they would go out and use any means possible to get information from a detainee," one official said. Defense Department personnel briefed on the unit's operations said the harsh treatment extended beyond Camp Nama to small field outposts in Baghdad, Falluja, Balad, Ramadi and Kirkuk. These stations were often nestled within the alleys of a city in nondescript buildings with suburban-size yards where helicopters could land to drop off or pick up detainees.
At the outposts, some detainees were stripped naked and had cold water thrown on them to cause the sensation of drowning, said Defense Department personnel who served with the unit. In January 2004, the task force captured the son of one of Mr. Hussein's bodyguards in Tikrit. The man told Army investigators that he was forced to strip and that he was punched in the spine until he fainted, put in front of an air-conditioner while cold water was poured on him and kicked in the stomach until he vomited. Army investigators were forced to close their inquiry in June 2005 after they said task force members used battlefield pseudonyms that made it impossible to identify and locate the soldiers involved. The unit also asserted that 70 percent of its computer files had been lost." The key quote here is anytime there was even the smell of Zarqawi nearby, they would go out and use any means possible to get information from a detainee. Given the fact that the average American soldier had little knowledge of Iraqi tribal culture and few knew Arabic one can safely assume that many people who were guilty of nothing more than being in the wrong place at the wrong time were severely beaten and abused all in the name of fighting the war on terror the Dick Cheney/Stanley McChrystal way. After this treatment these prisoners were then often transferred to Abu Ghraib were they would be abused again. This torture and humiliation more than anything contributed to the growth of the Sunni insurgency in the fall of 2004. How many Americans died or came home with one or two less limbs as a result of roadside bombs that were planted by bitter Iraqis as a result of this crap we will never know. In spite of this harsh treatment it seems that they often yielded no intelligence. Again I quote, "Despite the task force's access to a wide range of intelligence, its raids were often dry holes, yielding little if any intelligence and alienating ordinary Iraqis, Defense Department personnel said. Prisoners deemed no threat to American troops were often driven deep into the Iraqi desert at night and released, sometimes given $100 or more in American money for their trouble." In other words those detainees who had done nothing wrong were dumped in the middle of the desert to fend for themselves and find their way home! I guess that would qualify for humane treatment under the Cheney/McChrystal approach. This is a very depressing article but a definite must read to get some background about how the war on terror was conducted. It is clear that McChrystal was up to his neck in this stuff. Then there was Pat Tillman. You remember him. He was the rising NFL star who gave up what would have been a very lucrative career in pro football to enlist in the military and help fight the war on terror. Sadly he died in combat courageously while engaged in a firefight with a contingent of Taliban in Afghanistan. This story touched a nation who admired this man's sacrifice. However the story turned out to be not true. Like the Jessica Lynch story it turned out to be a fabrication of the Pentagon propaganda machine. It turned out Tillman had died as a result of "freindly fire" (this has to be one of the most oxymoronic terms currently in use today). For reasons known only to the Pentagon they covered this up and went with the falsified combat story. Stanley McChrystal later awarded Tillman the Silver Star for meritorious service in combat even though it was based on a lie- a lie that McChrystal later said he had suspicions that it was friendly fire. When the truth came out Tillman's family were furious. Many details about Tillman's death were suspicious to say the least. Why were his clothes and field journal burned up. It was known that Tillman contrary to the sanitized pro-Bush spin that the media was putting out had grown disenchanted with the war on terror as it was being waged and was very critical of the war in Iraq. According to a San Francisco Gate article entitled "Family demands the Truth" and I quote,"Yet other Tillman family members are less reluctant to show Tillman’s unique character, which was more complex than the public image of a gung-ho patriotic warrior. He started keeping a journal at 16 and continued the practice on the battlefield, writing in it regularly. (His journal was lost immediately after his death.) Mary Tillman said a friend of Pat’s even arranged a private meeting with Chomsky, the antiwar author, to take place after his return from Afghanistan — a meeting prevented by his death. She said that although he supported the Afghan war, believing it justified by the Sept. 11 attacks, “Pat was very critical of the whole Iraq war.” If this story is true and Tillman really did plan to do an interview with Noam Chomsky who is a well known opponent of American foreign policy that would explain the burning of the journal, especially at a time when the publication of the Abu Ghriab photos was just one week away. More from the article, "Baer, who served with Tillman for more than a year in Iraq and Afghanistan, told one anecdote that took place during the March 2003 invasion as the Rangers moved up through southern Iraq. “I can see it like a movie screen,” Baer said. “We were outside of (a city in southern Iraq) watching as bombs were dropping on the town. We were at an old air base, me, Kevin and Pat, we weren’t in the fight right then. We were talking. And Pat said, ‘You know, this war is so f— illegal.’ And we all said,‘Yeah.’ That’s who he was. He totally was against Bush.” Another soldier in the platoon, who asked not to be identified, said Pat urged him to vote for Bush’s Democratic opponent in the 2004 election, Sen. John Kerry. Senior Chief Petty Officer Stephen White — a Navy SEAL who served with Pat and Kevin for four months in Iraq and was the only military member to speak at Tillman’s memorial — said Pat “wasn’t very fired up about being in Iraq” and instead wanted to go fight al Qaeda in Afghanistan. He said both Pat and Kevin (who has a degree in philosophy) “were amazingly well-read individuals … very firm in some of their beliefs, their political and religious or not so religious beliefs.” None of this would have looked good for the Bush administration had it come out so a decision seems to have been made to cover it up and deceive the American public. The Tillman family to this day blames McChrystal and is trying to derail his nomination. This too is a depressing article that leaves a lot of questions unanswered. One thing seems clear. There was a cover-up and it was orchestrated with the knowledge of Stanley McChrystal as was the cover up of the abuses at Camp Nama which were detailed in an Esquire article from 2006 entitled "Acts of Conscience". From the article comes this concerning the abuses and whether the Red Cross would be allowed in, "It was a point of pride that the Red Cross would never be allowed in the door, Jeff says. This is important because it defied the Geneva Conventions, which require that the Red Cross have access to military prisons. "Once, somebody brought it up with the colonel. 'Will they ever be allowed in here?' And he said absolutely not. He had this directly from General McChrystal and the Pentagon that there's no way that the Red Cross could get in — they won't have access and they never will. This facility was completely closed off to anybody investigating, even Army investigators." In other words the unit at 6-26 could torture to their hearts content secure in the knowledge that their actions would be covered up by our new commander of forces in Afghanistan! This may be the most depressing of the three articles I have cited and clearly show that after 9-11 the United States ran what could only be called a torture regime that was in defiance of international law and which would explain why we have to see Dick Cheney and his daughter on TV all the time to try to spin their way out of a prosecution. This is not America people. It isn't. We can do much better than this. Which makes the choice of Stanley McChrystal such an odious one.
Remember that this choice did not occur under the Bush administration but rather under a Democratic administration that was elected to clean up and change America's image around the world. So what gives here? Why would Obama who campaigned and was elected partly on a platform of reaching out to the rest of the world and trying to repair the damage that the Bush administration's unilateralism and contempt for international law had caused pick someone who condoned and covered up a policy of torture. Is this the public face you want to show to the rest of the world? In a previous post I said this. "Because the media has chosen to remain silent for the most part about our increasing involvement in the quicksand that is Pakistan Americans will be unprepared for what lies down the road if this thing goes south. There is an eerie parallel here to the early 1960's when there was another charismatic glamour guy as President. His name of course was John F Kennedy and just like now the media did not pay attention to how we were getting gradually sucked into a long-term involvement in Vietnam." When I wrote that I thought that I was one of the first people to make the comparison. Whether I was or not it seems that others are starting to pick up on that theme. Alexander Cockburn writing in Counterpunch has this to say, "How long does it take a mild-mannered, antiwar, black professor of constitutional law, trained as a community organizer on the South Side of Chicago, to become an enthusiastic sponsor of targeted assassinations, “decapitation” strategies and remote-control bombing of mud houses the far end of the globe?...The nearest parallel to Obama in eager deference to the bloodthirsty counsels of his counter-insurgency advisors is John F. Kennedy. It is not surprising that bright young presidents relish quick-fix, “outside the box” scenarios for victory." I could not have said it better myself. Just like John Kennedy rejected calls for an increase in American troops into Vietnam and came to rely on the flashier and sexier counter-insurgency ideas of folks like Edward Lansdale, whose use of terror and assassinations had been successful in the Philippines in the early 50's so it seems that today we have an American president who will follow in the footsteps of JFK and rely on terror, drone attacks, assassination and "nation building" to win the hearts and minds of the Afghans. Will this be any more successful than the JFK approach, that would eventually morph into targeted assassinations of foreign leaders with brother Bobby enthusiastically leading the charge, time will tell-all the while as it sucks us in deeper and deeper just like we were sucked in deeper in Vietnam. Again I quote Cockburn, " Whether in Vietnam or Afghanistan the counsels of regular Army generals tends to be drear and unappetizing: vast, costly deployments of troops by the hundreds of thousand, mounting casualties, uncertain prospects for any long-term success – all adding up to dismaying political costs on the home front. Amid Camelot’s dawn in 1961, Kennedy swiftly bent an ear to the counsels of men like Ed Lansdale, a special ops man who wore rakishly the halo of victory over the Communist guerillas in the Philippines and who promised results in Vietnam.
By the time he himself had become the victim of Lee Harvey Oswald’s “decapitation” strategy, brought to successful conclusion in Dealey Plaza, Dallas, on November 22, 1963, Kennedy had set in motion the counter-insurgency operations, complete with programs of assassination and torture, that turned South-East Asia and Latin America into charnel houses, some of them, like Colombia, to this day." By selecting Stanley McChrystal as our "go to guy" in Afghanistan one can expect more of the same.
Read the article about Task Force 6-26 here:http://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/19/international/middleeast/19abuse.html?_r=2&pagewanted=print These stories concern the Pat Tillman controversy:http://www.thenation.com/doc/20090525/zirin2/print and http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2005/09/25/MNGD7ETMNM1.DTL&type=printable Akexander Cockburn article in Counterpunch can be read here:http://www.counterpunch.org/cockburn05222009.html An excellent article by Tom Englehart in Tom Dispatch about our ever widening escalation in Afghanistan can be read here:http://www.tomdispatch.com/post/175074/the_pressure_of_an_expanding_war The Esquire article concerning torture and abuse at Camp Nama can be read here:http://www.esquire.com/print-this/ESQ0806TERROR_102 Do yourself a big favor and read all these articles and familiarize yourself with what is really going on. Obama does not represent a quantum change from the Bush administration and its approach to the "war on terror". All that they are doing is putting a kindlier and gentler face on the empire and in the case of their approach to Pakistan are pursuing a worse policy than Bush. Perhaps someday people in this country will get it. There can be no real democracy or "change" under the current two party system. Only under a system of proportionate representation can other voices be heard and even then it will be difficult to effect change. But it is the only hope.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment