Monday, May 11, 2009

What the hell is our strategy in Pakistan?

This article in today's Asia Times by Syed Saleem Shazad concerning the Pakistani military's assault on suspected "Taliban" positions in the Swat valley and the concomitant rise in refugees fleeing the fighting is a must read. According to the article 500,000 people are on the run and more could be expected to follow creating a massive refugee crisis of major proportions for a country that is already teetering on the brink of financial disaster and only stays afloat as a result of foreign aid. So as a result of American pressure to "do something" about the Taliban anywhere from 250-800 militants have been killed and as many as 500,000-1 million refugees have been created. Talk about asymmetry! Does the administration have any idea of the long term mess that they are creating for a country that already has too much on its plate. What is becoming clearer by the minute is that Pakistan/Afghanistan will be the Obama administration's quicksand. Every day we are getting sucked in deeper and deeper. I have said it previously but it bears repeating that there is little chance of Pakistan going "Taliban". The only way this could happen, a big if, is if we push the "Taliban" closer and closer to the heart of Pakistan which is Punjab and Sindh provinces. This can only happen as a result of the kind of policies that Obama is currently pursuing by creating a massive angry bitter refugee population that will blame the government for their problems and not the Taliban. It is as if we want Pakistan to fail! This is an incredibly short-sighted and stupid policy that we are pursuing but as I have said before there is little push back in the media because everyone is so happy to see Bush go that they labor under the false assumption that Barack "will do the right thing" Quite clearly he is not yet you will not hear much of a peep on what passes for our progressive talk shows where the only subject that is taken seriously,between the clowning around and the obligatory Sarah Palin jokes, is torture. The financial meltdown and the Obama administrations part in propping up the elites who got us into this mess by a massive transfer of wealth from average Americans to a small group of wealthy individuals does not register on the radar screen of Keith (the Big "O") Olbermann or Rachel Maddow nor does any real in depth look and criticism of our Pakistani strategy. What does count on these shows are endless insults, clowning around and snarky cheap shot comments that the incredibly lazy Keith Olbermann and to a lesser extant Rachel Maddow deliver every night ad nauseum. This is what passes for progressive cable folks. It is a disgrace in many ways. It is amazing that for over two decades I have waited for a progressive voice on TV and now that I have finally got a couple they are in many ways an embarrassment and in Olberman's case are little more than Fox news on the "left". I would strongly suggest that people who are offended at what I just wrote read Bob Somerby's Daily Howler web site for a more in depth critique of the silliness that passes for progressive cable. One thing is sure however and that is with the exception of torture the Obama administration will receive a pass and instead of a critical look at how important issues like Pakistan and the economy are being handled all we can count on are gratuitous insults at the Republican Party and a California beauty queen who offends the refined sensibilities of an asshole like Olbermann. Progressive talk should not be a clown show and a mirror image of the cheap shots and distortions of the right wing. We can do better than that. We really can.



Which gets me back to Pakistan. Because the media has chosen to remain silent for the most part about our increasing involvement in the quicksand that is Pakistan Americans will be unprepared for what lies down the road if this thing goes south. There is an eerie parallel here to the early 1960's when there was another charismatic glamour guy as President. His name of course was John F Kennedy and just like now the media did not pay attention to how we were getting gradually sucked into a long-term involvement in Vietnam. David Halberstam's book "The Best and the Brightest" deals with this period in depth and just might be something people might want to read today for some clarity about how events are unfolding in Pakistan. Back to the article by Shazad.Concerning the refugee population that is being created Shazad writes, " The number of displaced people is likely to grow to as many as 1.5 million in coming days. The total funds the government has allocated so far is 200 million rupees (out of total 1 billion rupees announced by the prime minister). This means roughly 133 rupees for each person, hardly enough for one day's food. The complaints have already started, and in the weeks ahead the situation is likely to get worse. As in the past, people may blame the government for the situation, not the Taliban." Talking about how this policy is a godsend for the very group, Al-Queda, that Obama supposedly is so concerned about he writes, "This is the situation al-Qaeda has desired for a very long time. Al-Qaeda carried out sectarian attacks on Shi'ite mosques, allegedly assassinated former prime minister Benazir Bhutto, and bombed bombed public places. But they failed to rupture the national fibre of the country or create enough chaos in Pakistan to draw security forces to multiple fronts. Now the government has done this for them. Islamabad has sponsored a military campaign that will push an isolated situation to the other parts of the country. The previous fear of the "Talibanization" of Pakistan could possibly become reality." Remember that when Shazad says the government has done that for them he in effect is saying the American government because only under heavy American pressure is Pakistan pursuing this policy. This is sowing the seeds of big trouble later on. Mark my words. Read Syed's article here:http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/KE12Ak02.html Also read Steve Chapman on why talk of the Taliban taking over Pakistan is totally blown out of proportion and the way Armageddon is used to scare Americans into supporting our escalation in Pakistan. Much like Bush in Iraq. http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/opinion/oped/bal-op.viewpoint11may11,0,958116.story

No comments:

Post a Comment