Thursday, March 26, 2009

Some thoughts on Iraq

With all the attention being paid to the financial crisis it is easy to forget the issue that originally helped to put Obama in the White House. Iraq. Juan Cole references a story from AP concerning the Sunni refugees from Baghdad who were forced out of the city because of the civil war that heated up in 2006 as a result of the bombing of the Golden Dome in Samarrah and accelerated in the first six months of 2007. Read the story here. http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/sns-ap-ml-iraq-still-cleansed,0,414487,print.story Some of the statistics compiled by AP: 1) Only an estimated 50,000 of 300,000 displaced families — or 16 percent — have returned to their Baghdad homes, according to the U.S. military. Most are believed to be Sunnis. 2) The violence has virtually emptied parts of the city, particularly on the mainly Sunni western side of the Tigris river. In Amiriyah, for example, 100 of the 252 Shiite families that fled are back. Roughly the same number of Shiite families, 250, fled Khadra, another western Baghdad area; only 70 have returned. 3) In Hurriyah, an estimated 3,000 to 4,000 families, most of them Sunnis, fled in 2006 and 2007. Of those, only 648 families — or 16 to 22 percent — have come back since September. Hurriyah and Amiriyah are neighborhoods in Baghdad. As Cole points out 300,000 families would be around 1.5 million individuals give or take a several hundred thousand. That is a lot of people that are not returning folks. I hear constantly on cable and the news show about the "success" of the surge. If by success people who say this mean that the increase in American troops that started in January 2007 is responsible for the decrease in violence (decrease is a relative term-there is still violence every day that is politically motivated) they are wrong. The increase in troops occurred simultaneously with a marked increase in deaths in Baghdad as the civil war escalated. Only after that ended and the Shiites won, along with the US paying off the Sunni militias that had previously attacked us along with Iran telling Sadr's movement to back off did relative peace occur. The increase in American troops, the "surge" , that is frequently touted as the reason for this relative peace was not the reason. These other factors were far more important. Iran holds the key to maintaining stability in Iraq just as Syria holds the key in Lebanon. If either country wants to turn up the temperature they can. Reading this story you become aware of how many lives were shattered by this war of choice by America. People whose lives have been turned upside down never to return to the way things were. Think about that the next time someone tells you the surge "worked". Just say to that person,"worked for who"? Certainly not the refugees of Baghdad.

No comments:

Post a Comment