Tuesday, March 3, 2009

The more things change the more they remain the same

When Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama said that there would be a change in tone with the new administration they were serious. There is no doubt that there is a willingness to dialogue with states that were for all intents and purposes frozen out under the Bush administration. It is also clear that Hillary Clinton is looked upon as a huge improvement over Condoleeza Rice and that Barack Obama is a huge relief to the rest of the world after the bumbling arrogant Bush administration. However based on these recent diplomatic moves once you move past the willingness to shake hands and engage Syria and Russia in conversation it would appear that there is no substantive change whatsoever. Consider:



1) In regards to Russia, the New York Times reports that Obama sent a "secret" letter to Russian president Dmitri Medvedev in which he "suggested " he would back off deploying a new missile defense system in East Europe if Russia helps the United States stop Iran's long range missile program. Assuming this story is accurate and not a leak by some hawks trying to put pressure on Obama, on the surface this looks positive except that when you scratch below the surface you find that it is really not much of a deal. In effect this is little different than the Bush administration in that it makes a demand , albeit in a nicer tone, without giving anything in return. Russia is expected to stop the Iranian missile program and then we may cancel our deployment plans. It is important to remember the historical background here. The United Stated unilaterally decided to deploy a missile defense system in Poland and the Czech Republic allegedly against the threat of long range Iranian missiles. Missiles that Iran does not even have and will not have for some time. Anybody with both eyes open should see what is really going on here. The Bush administration meant this not against Iran but against Russia. Russia understands that this is intended to give the United States a first strike nuclear capability and neutralize any Russian response. Factor in the proposed NATO expansion of Georgia and the Ukraine and you can see why relations have hit bottom. Russia will not bite on this especially now that we need their help in finding new supply routes to Afghanistan.



2) At the Gaza donors conference Hillary Clinton went out of her way to shake the hand of the Syrian foreign minister and stated that she wants to engage in a discussion not knowing where this will lead. So far so good. Obviously Obama would like to move Syria away from Iran.(Syria allied themselves with Iran during the Iraq-Iran war in the eighties-the only Arab state to do so, a relationship they have maintained ever since) According to Joshua Landis Syria Comment blog Hillary set out strict pre-conditions for a US support for a Syrian-Israeli dialogue. Syria would have to cut ties with Hezbollah and Hamas and Israel will consider returning the Golan Heights which they seized in the 1967 war. So here we go again. As Landis says " The demand that Syria abandon its supporters and friends before entering into full dialogue with the US is no more likely to work under Obama than it did under Bush. Why? Because Syria fears that the US will again fail to deliver Israel, as it did under Bill Clinton in 2000. Netanyahu will decline to return the Golan, as he promised during his campaign, and Syria will be left without a deal and with with no friends or regional leverage. Syria suspects this is, in fact, Washington’s desired outcome - to weaken Syria." Again what looks good on the surface is nothing different than the Bush approach but with a nicer face. You must do these things and maybe Israel and Netanyahu will give back the Golan! Who would take that deal? A change in tone is not enough. We need a substantive change in policy if we are to undo the damage that the Bush approach has done. I am not seeing much here. There are other disturbing signs but that will have to await another post.

No comments:

Post a Comment