Tuesday, December 15, 2009

We spent a trillion dollars (give or take and counting) and we don't even get the oil!

If it wasn't for all the dead bodies, the ethnically cleansed neighborhoods, sectarian hatreds that will take generations to heal, the four million displaced refugees and all the other horror stories of this ill-advised war this story would be funny. The Iraqi government recently held their oil auctions and it seems that the US companies did not do very well! To make matters worse two of the big winners were Russia and China, two of our biggest competitors and one of the reasons we invaded Iraq so as to corner the market on what could arguably be fields that rival Saudi Arabia. Despite the recent bombings in the capital the oil companies found their way to Baghdad to participate in the bid for contracts. The Iraqi government was determined that these auctions not be seen as a power grab by big oil. Hence the terms under which the contracts were awarded included a provision that big oil would not be given a share in production and that they would agree to fees that would be paid out if production increased over a certain amount. The oil companies agreed to a series of 20 year contracts. The fees came out to around $2 a barrel. The payoff is potentially so lucrative that many oil companies jumped at the chance to get involved in the bidding even though the payoff was lower than originally anticipated. Most of these fields are in the Shiite dominated southern part of the country. If these auctions can be seen by the Iraqi population as being in Iraqs best interest and not as a sell-out to big oil Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki could come out of this a political winner. Of course down the road there is no guarantee that these agreements will hold and it is always possible that big oil will be able to bring pressure and change the terms, which I suspect is one reason big oil jumped at the chance to get involved.

Remember when Paul Wolfowitz and other Bush administration officials would go before Congress and tell us with a straight face that the dollars from Iraqi oil would pay for the war? Unspoken of course was that the war would corner the Iraqi oil market for the Americans who would then be in a position to decide who would get it and who would not. China, which is gobbling up more and more oil and is becoming more dependant on oil imports and is considered by many to be our biggest geo-political rival in the coming decades, would be dependant on us to gain access to what potentially could be the largest oil fields in the world, even larger than Saudi Arabia. Because of 30 years of war and sanctions the Iraqi oil fields have been stagnant and underdeveloped. They need the technological shot in the arm that big oil can bring to the table. That would be provided by the Americans who would then benefit by controlling this most strategic of resources. At least that was the plan. However like everything else in this train wreck called the Iraq war it did not go according to plan. A closer look at the winners of this auction shows that we spent a trillion dollars to hand the country over to a government friendly to Iran and one that has decided that our strategic rivals such as Russia and China should get the bounty. Take that Donald Rumsfeld and Paul Wolfowitz! In today's edition of the Asia Times Pepe Escobar breaks it down. I quote, "Cheney's and Rumsfeld's script was never supposed to develop like this. Instead of US Big Oil getting the lion's share, strategic competitors Russia and China turned out to be big winners. Dick Cheney's "consolation prize" was an Exxon-Mobil-Shell alliance getting the phase 1 of West Qurna in early November. Exxon-Mobil had been the favorite to also win Rumaila (17.8 billion barrels of reserves). But a BP-CNPC (China National Petroleum Corporation) alliance got it in the end because unlike Exxon-Mobil they agreed to cut their fee per barrel down to the Oil Ministry-enforced $2. CNPC (50%), along with partners Total from France (25%) and Petronas from Malaysia (25%), was also a big winner for Halfaya (4.1 billion barrels of reserves, projected output of 535,000 barrels per day (bpd)), southeast of Amara. Petronas again (with 60%), and the Japan Petroleum Exploration Company (Japex), with 40%, will invest a cool $7 billion to develop Gharaf (reserves of around 860 million barrels, projected output of 230,000 bpd). Bidding was fierce. Losers were a joint Turkish-Indian bid, a Kazakh/South Korean/Italian consortium, and Pertamina from Indonesia. A Petronas-Shell alliance got the highly coveted Majnoon (reserves of more than 12 billion barrels, projected output of 1.8 million bpd), near the Iranian border. Russia's Lukoil (85%), with junior partner Statoil (15%), got phase 2 of the immense West Qurna (located 65 kilometers northwest of Basra; about 12 billion barrels of reserves; projected production of 1.8 million bpd) - which in theory it had already bagged under Saddam Hussein. When Lukoil was stripped of its contract by Saddam, it blamed US-instigated United Nations sanctions, while Saddam blamed Lukoil itself. West Qurna's phase 1 (8.7 billion barrels of reserves, with a projection to increase output from 300,000 bpd to 2.3 million bpd before 2016) was won in November by the aforementioned Exxon Mobil-Shell alliance. Losers were Total from France, a consortium of Petronas, Pertamina and Petrovietnam, and a BP-CNPC alliance. Gazprom (40%), with junior partners TPAO, Kogas and Petronas, got Badra (projected production of 170,000 bpd). Unlike the mad scramble for the southern fields, no one even bid for the East Baghdad field, for obvious reasons: it's located in a virtual war zone. [1] Take a look at those reserve numbers of oil for those various reserves. That is a hell of a lot of oil people! To push the idea that this war of choice had little or nothing to do with oil is assume the stupidity of the American people and yet the corporate mainstream media did just that in the run-up to the war. Almost seven years later Iraq is still pumping less oil per day than they did before the war under Saddam (around 2 million barrels per day). With these deals the Iraqi government hopes to jack up production while at the same time maintaining their control of this most precious of resources. I wonder how this will affect the scheduled withdrawal of American troops. To see the main prize of the war start to slip away like this must be a bitter pill for all the neo-cons who probably never anticipated this. Will this affect our plans to vacate the country? I have argued elsewhere that I do not believe after all the money we have spent and all the oil that sits under the Iraqi soil that we will be going anywhere soon. We are always one excuse away to continue our occupation and perhaps bring pressure to bear to give us a better deal. If not we can always start another propaganda campaign and call Maliki the new Saddam spend another trillion dollars and start another war to "liberate" the Iraqi people and try one more time to control the oil!

Read these articles that deal with the auctions here. From the Asia Times comes this one by Escobar:http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/KL16Ak02.html and another one from Asia Times:http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/KL16Ak01.html Also this one from Counterpunch and one of my favorite writers Patrick Cockburn:http://www.counterpunch.org/patrick12142009.html

No comments:

Post a Comment