Friday, November 27, 2009

Post Thanksgiving thoughts

1) First of all happy post Thanksgiving Day to everybody, even those who do not like everything I have to say! So many things to blog about and so little time. Where to begin?



2) Read this post from the Daily Howler blog from Wednesday. It will no doubt upset many "career" liberals whose main focus consists of bashing Sarah Palin and all the hicks, racists and stupid people that support her. I am speaking here of media commentators like Keith Olbermann, Rachel Maddow and Stephanie Miller among others. Somerby's blog refers to the Kentucky police investigation of the death of the census worker who was found hung with the word FED written on his chest. At the time many people based on the hysterical paranoia that the far right has toward the census bureau, assumed that he had been murdered. The initial news reports were sketchy and could have led one to this conclusion. It was reported originally that people who knew him had reported that he was happy and had no suicidal thoughts. Given that the death occurred in Kentucky which is a stereotypically culturally conservative state and by definition filled with the kind of "racists" and "hayseeds" that the media delight in mocking it would stand to reason that this was a hate crime committed by the far right. Wouldn't it? Certainly the nights that I watched Rachel Maddow or listened to Air America that was all they could talk about. I thought the same thing initially myself based on what I has read. It is easy to jump to conclusions when your ideological bias gets in the way. Turns out we should not have jumped the gun. Both the Post and the Times cover this but the Times goes into a little more depth. Basically the man, Bill Sparkman, had taken out two life insurance policies totaling $60,000 shortly before his death that would not pay out in the event of suicide. He had expressed suicidal thoughts to witnesses and seemed to be very aware that there was extreme hostility to census workers in that part of the state, no doubt whipped up by the Michelle Bachman's of the world. He was found loosely bound and it was determined that the word fed was written from the bottom up, which is not the way it would normally be written. According to the Times and I quote, "The police said they analyzed the ink on Mr. Sparkman’s chest to determine if someone else had written the word. They concluded that the letters had been written from the bottom to the top, which is not how another person would have written them while facing Mr. Sparkman. The police also found no evidence of a struggle, and there was only Mr. Sparkman’s DNA on the rag in his mouth and near his body. Mr. Sparkman’s hands were bound, but loosely, allowing him to move them a shoulder-width apart. The police added that they believed Mr. Sparkman had acted alone in manipulating the scene to conceal the suicide." Assuming that the conclusion reached here is true what does this say about our liberal pundits in the mainstream media and more importantly how is it that the people out there that are mocked on a nightly basis by the Olberman's and Maddows of the world, who should be based on their class position in the front line in supporting health care reform and other progressive causes, why do they harbor such rabid hatred of "liberals"?


Why indeed is it that the people that should be supporting progressive causes often times are the most hostile to the people who supposedly are pursuing those policies? We all know these people. If you engage them in conversation they will rail about the hypocrisy of liberals, about their inability to take a position and stand by it regardless of the pressure. The way they talk out of both sides of their mouth, etc, etc. But the one thing that you will constantly hear is that liberals are elitist snobs who think they are better than everyone else. This is what drives all their discussions of politics. Why do they have these hostile attitudes towards liberals? One could answer that question different ways. If I was a Marxist I could say that they labored under a false consciousness that harbored a latent progressive politics and was just waiting for a major event or crisis to bring it to the surface. However we just had that event! A major economic meltdown not seen since the Great Depression whose consequences we will be living with for years to come. That has not changed them. Why? Do you think it may have something to do with the fact that the reason that they don't like liberals might be because they perceive that liberals/progressives don't like them. When someone feels that they are not getting respected they will turn on those people. They will turn to a party like the Republicans who offer little in terms of economic policies that will help them but will treat them with respect and take them seriously-or at least pretend to. As people like Olbermann and Maddow mock these people they become more bitter toward the party that Olbermann and Maddow represent. The Republican party has understood this since Richard Nixon and it explains the electoral success they have had. Somerby understands this and seems to be one of the few liberal/progressives that get it. I have no doubt that his column will upset many liberals. His thoughts are worth quoting, "Because yes: For decades, a large amount of “liberal” politics had really been tribal hatred. This helps explain why there’s nothing resembling a progressive politics in this benighted, laughing-stock nation. In all honesty, pseudo-liberals are in this game so we can vent at the unwashed masses—at the tea-baggers, the redneck racists, the people whose limbic brains don’t work right....In the past year, Maddow and Olbermann have schooled young liberals in this brainless brand of hatred. But in all honesty, this consummate dumbness has always been part of our “liberal” politics. Going back to Nixon and Wallace, politicians of the right have gotten fat on our hatred. Palin feeds on it today. In large part, our hatred explains why we have no progressive politics in this country. You see, if you despise the great unwashed, it’s a bit hard to advocate on their behalf. Are The Interests ripping them off—when it comes to their over-priced health care, let’s say? It’s hard for us to work up a fury when we hold such people in more contempt that even The Interests do. And of course, those people can see how much we hate them! As Palin prospers on our hatred, the only people who can’t seem to see our obvious hatred are the rubes in this whole story—us!" Why is it that FDR was able to rally most of the nation behind a progressive politics, a progressive politics that many people were not predisposed for, during a time of economic upheaval and Obama is having such a hard time getting a watered down health care bill through congress? Huh? The people that supported the New Deal included white southerners, many of whom could have qualified as racists, and immigrant working class people from urban areas, many of which no doubt had racial attitudes. In short the same people that Olbermann and Maddow make fun of regularly. Without these people on board there would have been no New Deal. Why? Because of their numbers the New Deal could not have passed without them. If you cannot get the support of the majority of the population the best progressive legislation has no chance of getting passed. The people that supported FDR did not sneer at their potential supporters. They welcomed them. I quote further, "On our side, we wanted to shriek and yell about the way the tea-baggers murdered Bill Sparkman. But then, we also like to shriek and yell about the way the tea-baggers yelled out “Kill him”—even after the Secret Service decided that hadn’t occurred. And we like to pose as shrinks on TV, diagnosing the tea-baggers’ favorite pol. We send our dumbest players out to do this, and they leap to the task....Might we return for a moment to the death of Bill Sparkman, a cancer survivor who apparently decided to take his own life? Let’s consider the logic of early reactions to Sparkman’s tragic death:Suppose something different had occurred. Suppose Bill Sparkman had been murdered by some local anti-government nut. As intelligent people, do we understand that a single such incident couldn’t define a vast sweeping movement? That this would have been the act of one deranged person, in a nation of 300 million? Not us! We would have shrieked and wailed about the way the tea-baggers had done this vile thing; we would have rushed to extend a vast sliming. And because we’re steeped in tribal hatred, we wouldn’t have realized how dumb and unfair it is to issue such claims—the kinds of claims which drive many people toward the opposite camp.Let’s get back to Sarah Palin’s Clearwater rally last year. Did someone yell “Kill him” at that rally? For ourselves, we have no idea; the Secret Service later said no. But suppose someone had let out such a yell—what exactly what that have meant? Since there were 3000 people at the rally, here’s one thing it would have meant: It would have meant that 2,999 of those people hadn’t emitted that cry! But so what? Because our side is full of haters, that logic has never intruded. In the case of Bill Sparkman, we prayed to our God for a type of death. But alas. As Lincoln observed, both sides’ prayers couldn’t be answered—or so it appears today. Here is the basic question:. Can a person disagree with your instincts and views without being a tea-bagger, a redneck, a racist—without having a limbic brain problem, a psychiatric disorder? Tribal haters have always said no. And that thinking persists in our world. This helps explain why a ludicrous health bill is barely limping its ways through the Congress. It helps explain why your corporate-run nation is correctly the joke of the world." That indeed is the basic question. Is someone who disagrees with our most cherished political opinions a hick, racist or "tea-bagger". Why is it that people whose class interests would indicate support for progressive causes like health reform, tax reform and a less interventionist foreign policy (in which their children will be the ones doing the fighting and not the children of the elites of the Republican party who push these wars) be so hostile to liberal causes? Because they do not like the people who advocate these policies! It explains their hostility to government and its programs, programs which would benefit them. Why? Because those government programs are run by the very people they don't like and who they think don't like them. These people are not as stupid as many career liberals think they are. Do not conflate Michelle Bachman or Newt Gingrich with some of the people who follow them. Many of these people did not like Bush. They know the Republican party offers them little in economic terms. But they also know that the Democrats are little better. That they talk out of both sides of their mouth and seldom follow through on the things they advocate on the campaign trail. Just look at the administration of Barack Obama so far. They could have told you in August of 2008 that Obama would not follow through on many of the things he advocated. Compared to the naivete of the people who went gaga over Obama like he was the second coming of Christ who is stupid and who is not? Huh? These people have some valid complaints. When they look at the low paying jobs that have replaced our former high wage manufacturing jobs they see both parties complicit in this. When they look at the mess that deregulation has made they see both parties going along with this. When the Bush and Obama administrations suck up to the financial elites that caused this train wreck of an economy they see little difference between the two parties. If both parties seem to offer little help then why wouldn't they support the party that treats them as human beings as opposed to the ones whose media supporters treat them like cartoon characters. The Republican party understands this and uses this bitterness to get them to support policies that are not in their best economic interests. The liberal blogosphere and Air America personalities are constantly bemoaning the fact that the Congress has the likes of a Ben Nelson or an Evan Bayh making it difficult to pass progressive policies. So do I. But they seem to forget why they are the type of Democrats representing those districts. Because the people in those districts have the very attitudes that I have been talking about. The people of Oklahoma or Kentucky or Indiana do not like the liberal wing of the Democratic party even though that wing would do more for them economically than the Ben Nelson's of the world. Clearly something is wrong here and it goes a long way toward explaining why Obama is having such a hard time getting a watered down health care bill through Congress. Until progressives and liberals can get these people on board and create a broad based coalition for progressive reform little will be done and the Republican party will come back with a vengeance. After all in our wonderful two party system there is no where else to go. One way to get them on board is to cut the snark and cheap shots and explain why these policies are in their interest in a manner that shows respect and treats them like adults who have been misled by a right wing ideology that has manipulated them into voting for policies that are not in their interest. Can we do that? Read the articles on the Sparkman investigation here:http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/11/24/AR2009112403778.html and here:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/25/us/25census.html?_r=2&ref=todayspaper The Daily Howler post is here:http://www.dailyhowler.com/



3) Blackwater/Xe will not go away. If you thought that a change in administration would lessen our dependency on them think again. As readers of this blog should know I have written several posts on how the Obama administration continues our cozy relationship with these guys. A new article that appears in the Nation written by Jeffrey Scahill shows that Stanley McChrystal is increasing our reliance on them through contractual relations with the US Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC). This is done because it is easier to keep these contacts secret from Congress as opposed to working through the CIA where Congressional oversight would be required. According to the article and I quote, "At a covert forward operating base run by the US Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC) in the Pakistani port city of Karachi, members of an elite division of Blackwater are at the center of a secret program in which they plan targeted assassinations of suspected Taliban and Al Qaeda operatives, "snatch and grabs" of high-value targets and other sensitive action inside and outside Pakistan, an investigation by The Nation has found. The Blackwater operatives also assist in gathering intelligence and help direct a secret US military drone bombing campaign that runs parallel to the well-documented CIA predator strikes, according to a well-placed source within the US military intelligence apparatus". This should not come as any surprise given the past record of Mr. McChrystal which has been documented in an earlier blog of mine which can be read here:http://jadele1.blogspot.com/2009/05/who-is-stanley-mcchrystal.html. We have Blackwater, who are loaded with a lot of former special ops guys who retired from the military and went on the Blackwater payroll for a much higher compensation, planning these operations for our military. Why can't our military do these things? Why do we need these guys? According to the article when our drones go awry and blast a bunch of civilians in Pakistan or Afghanistan it is often a result of the JSCO and Blackwater guys and not the CIA, althiough it is the CIA that inevitably gets blamed. Again I quote from the article, "The military intelligence source also confirmed that Blackwater continues to work for the CIA on its drone bombing program in Pakistan, as previously reported in the New York Times, but added that Blackwater is working on JSOC's drone bombings as well. "It's Blackwater running the program for both CIA and JSOC," said the source. When civilians are killed, "people go, 'Oh, it's the CIA doing crazy shit again unchecked.' Well, at least 50 percent of the time, that's JSOC [hitting] somebody they've identified through HUMINT [human intelligence] or they've culled the intelligence themselves or it's been shared with them and they take that person out and that's how it works." The military intelligence source says that the CIA operations are subject to Congressional oversight, unlike the parallel JSOC bombings. "Targeted killings are not the most popular thing in town right now and the CIA knows that," he says. "Contractors and especially JSOC personnel working under a classified mandate are not [overseen by Congress], so they just don't care. If there's one person they're going after and there's thirty-four people in the building, thirty-five people are going to die. That's the mentality." He added, "They're not accountable to anybody and they know that. It's an open secret, but what are you going to do, shut down JSOC?" Pakistani public opinion which is already hostile against the US is not happy about the purported Blackwater presence in their country. Considering how toxic Blackwater is it is small wonder that McChrystal is using them in tandem with the JSOC, a super secret miltary unit. We are becoming more and more dependant on this gang and considering their history this should be raising a lot of red flags. But no, Obama like Bush cannot get enough of them. My other blogs that deal with Blackwater can be read here:http://jadele1.blogspot.com/2009/04/short-thoughts-for-sunday-morning.html and here:http://jadele1.blogspot.com/2009_06_01_archive.html and finally here:http://jadele1.blogspot.com/2009/08/short-thoughts-for-friday_21.html. The article from the Nation can be read here:http://www.thenation.com/doc/20091207/scahill.

No comments:

Post a Comment