Monday, June 15, 2009

Short thoughts for a Monday morning

1) I have bitched about this before but I will do it again. Having to work so many hours really cuts into blogging which is a shame because there are so many things out there to write about. One is the recent election in Iran. Many in the West including liberals such as Juan Cole and Digby have jumped to the conclusion that massive fraud occurred. I predicted in a previous post that I felt that the race would be tight and that there would be a runoff and that Mousavi would win in the second round. According to the results announced I was wrong, Ahmadinajad won by a landslide. Most western observers assume that not only is that an impossibility but that there was no way Ahmadinejad could have won period. Why? Because they don't like him and they assume that most people in Iraq share their opinion. Is this accurate? Did I and many other people fall into the trap of relying on a relatively small sample of Iranian opinion favorable to the "reformer" Mousavi and totally misrepresent what was actually going on? It would not be the first time we in the west have misjudged what goes on over there. Most of the people that the western reporters talked to in Tehran were based in the northern part of the city which is very progressive. The southern part of Tehran is a totally different animal and I wonder how many reporters went out of their comfort zone and conducted interviews there. While there are some things that are suspicious here and it is entirely possible that some fraud did occur (on both sides possibly) the question is did it decide the election or was it just to pad an already commanding victory. The crackdown that has occurred after the election misguided though it is could very well be the regimes response to not letting this thing get out of hand and becoming a manipulation by the US and Israeli intelligence agencies to further their own agenda. This angle is seldom mentioned in the mainstream media, not even by people like Cole who knows something about Iranian history. The Iranians are not stupid and they know that an Ahmadinejad victory will give the US an excuse to either attack or refuse to negotiate with Iran and remembering what went on in 1953 with Mossaddeq and more recent elections such as Venezuela in 2002 where American manipulation was apparent to most people they might feel that it is in their best interest to do what they have to to stop the unrest from spreading. Why has this angle not been brought up by liberals who probably would have brought it up if Bush was still in power? Maybe because now that one of their own (Obama) is in power it is assumed that we would never resort to blatant interference in someone else's elections. This is a faulty assumption. I would be willing to bet the ranch that we were involved in some capacity in these elections and in the recently concluded Lebanese elections. If Ahmadinejad really did win this elections what would be the reasons why? One reason might be class. Ahmadinejad's appeal is to the lower classes and that is why he won the first time around. While much is made of the economic woes of Iran Mousavi has a reputation of appealing to the middle and upper classes which might explain his appeal to western reporters. People have benefited from Ahmadinejads rule and in the debates he was reported as being very effective at hammering at the corruption of the previous regime. Which leads us to Rafsanjani who was very vocal in his support for Mousavi. Rafsanjani is the equivalent of Ahmad Chalabi or Asif Zardari, an influential and wealthy individual who is widely thought of as being corrupt. Iranians do not really trust this guy or like him and I suspect that along with Ahmadinejad's strident nationalism that appealed to many Iranians who perhaps thought that a vote for Mousavi was a vote for the American agenda Rafsanjani's support for Mousavi did not sit well with many people. Mousavi was no reformer but someone who was an insider during the Iran-Iraq war and supports nuclear enrichment and will continue the hostility to Israel. He will not try to overthrow the system so I am a bit puzzled by all the hoopla over him. I am no fan of Ahmadinejad but regardless who won this election there would not be a radical change coming from Iran. That change will have to come from Washington. Liberals and progressives should be very careful here about jumping to a conclusion that as of this moment cannot be ascertained with certainty and falling into the trap that is being set by the people who want to use this as an excuse to attack Iran. That would be a disaster.



For differing opinions on this election read this poll conducted by the Terror Free Tomorrow no fan of Ahmadinejad:http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/06/14/AR2009061401757.html?hpid=opinionsbox1 For a rebuttal of this read today's blog by Juan Cole at the Informed Comment website. This column by Jim Lobe is about why this election makes no difference to hard liners like Daniel Pipes no matter how much he might join in protesting "the stolen election:" :http://www.ips.org/blog/jimlobe/?p=256 Here is an article that goes into some depth about the class dimension in Iranian electoral politics that is more important than many American commentators give it credit for:http://djavad.wordpress.com/2009/06/09/the-poor-vs-the-middle-class/ It is way too soon to conclude with a high degree of certainty that massive vote fraud occurred. It very well may be the case that there was but as of now we do not know. Be careful about rushing to judgement here folks. There are people in the background who are eager to manipulate this for their own neo-con agenda.

No comments:

Post a Comment